Um Gosto de Mel

The 1960's brought about many of my favourite films about the English working class experience: The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner; Saturday Night, Sunday Morning; This Sporting Life and - naturally - Kes. Coming from the North and being around - just - during the sixties helps naturally.

I dislike the term "kitchen sink" because it puts too many people off a film that while bleak remains so true it almost hurts. There isn't a word, phrase or scene in this movie that I don't believe and remember: I was there, although not in Salford!

A dimly lit world of booze, cups of tea, canals, seaside trips, bonfires, repressed emotions, unprotected sex (and what follows) and the limits and cheap thrills of the Northern English working class.

In 1961 this must have looked like the start of a new age of film. Real stories about real life. Almost a docu-drama in the modern parlance. However it never really happened. Why? Because there is more skill required than you might imagine and even this verges on going over the top. You could say it is tries to tick too many boxes. And isn't really true drama because it stops at a point in which so many threads remain loose.

(I suppose you could say it ends with the characters facing up to the realities that they have been so long running away from - but will they actually achieve it?)

Star of the show is Rita Tushington who never went on to do much with her career after being given the part of a lifetime to start it all off. Murray Melvin is also good as the homosexual boyfriend who wants to help out - although maybe in a misguided way.

A Taste of Honey has its limits and you could attack it for being snobbish. It is an artistic product born of the middle class - but it remains utterly true in a way that is mostly absent in cinema today.

Shelagh Delaney's screenplay for "A Taste of Honey," based on her play of the same name, remains a moving period drama. Beautifully directed by Tony Richardson, this film evokes all the stark realism of the famed English "New Wave/kitchen sink" dramas (made popular by John Osborne) of the late 50s/early 60s.

Rita Tushingham is striking as an working-class adolescent girl, growing into maturity--first through her pregnancy by a young sailor, played by Paul Danquah, and then by her association with a sensitive man, played by Murray Melvin. Dora Bryan is impressive Tushingham's mom.

The sparse photography, sets and score, all combine to make an unforgettable statement.

'A Taste of Honey' provides a grim slice-of-life look at the working class poor in early 1960's England. Teen pregnancy, an openly homosexual companion, a negligent single mother and homelessness are featured- mainstream topics in today's movies, but this was released in 1961, folks (beats me how they got it past the censors). This sensitive, remarkable film should be required viewing for junior high schools.

During the late fifties and early sixties a feature of the British film industry was what have become known as "kitchen sink" films- social-realist pictures focusing on the lives of ordinary working-class people. Tony Richardson was one of the key figures in this movement, and "A Taste of Honey" is one of a number of such films directed by him; others include "Look Back in Anger" from 1958 and "The Loneliness of the Long-Distance Runner" from 1962. All of these films are based upon literary sources, in the case of "A Taste of Honey" upon a play by Shelagh Delaney.

The main character is Jo, a working-class Manchester teenager. The plot is a fairly simple one and charts Jo's relationships with her sluttish mother Helen, her sailor boyfriend Jimmy, Helen's car-dealer lover (and later husband) Peter and Geoff, the young man who befriends Jo after Jimmy disappears back to sea leaving her pregnant. There are a number of fine performances, from Murray Melvin as the gentle, sensitive Geoff, Dora Bryan as the promiscuous Helen and from Robert Stephens as the relatively affluent but coarse and vulgar Peter. The best is probably from the nineteen-year-old Rita Tushingham, making her screen debut as the naïve and vulnerable yet determined and strong-willed heroine. She was to become a well-known figure in the British cinema of the sixties and seventies, even though she was far from having classic "film star" looks.

The film contains a number of elements which would have been highly controversial in the early sixties, in particular its non-judgemental attitude towards premarital sex and pregnancy and the mixed-race love affair between Jo and Jimmy. The British cinema was, in some respects, more liberal than its American counterpart at this period. I cannot imagine the Hollywood of 1961 making a film about a sexual relationship between a black man and a white woman. Still less can I imagine a Hollywood film about a sexual relationship between a black man and a white teenage girl, a theme which would probably still be off-limits in 2008.

There were, however, limits to British liberalism. A number of reviewers have assumed that Geoff is gay. Certainly, Melvin plays him with what might be seen as stereotypically gay characteristics- he is, for example, rather effeminate in his voice and gestures. He is also much more "domesticated" than Jo, being better than her at cooking, needlework and housekeeping. He is never, however, identified in the script as a homosexual; there is no reference to his having sex with, or being sexually attracted to, other men. Indeed, it is suggested that Geoff is romantically in love with Jo, and he even proposes marriage.

It should be remembered that, at the time this film was being made homosexuality was still illegal in Britain and there had never been a British film with an explicitly gay theme; the first such was "Victim", which opened in August 1961, only a month before "A Taste of Honey". When "The Trials of Oscar Wilde" came out the previous year it refused to admit that Wilde actually was a homosexual, but rather tried to give the impression that he was the victim of unfounded gossip, of a deliberate conspiracy to blacken his name and of perjured evidence.

Like a number of "kitchen sink" films, it has a strong sense of place, conjured up by its atmospheric black-and-white photography of Manchester scenes, especially the terraced houses of the working-class districts. We see recognisable landmarks such as the city's Town Hall, the Ship Canal and Blackpool Tower (Like many working-class Mancunians from this period, Jo and Helen take their holidays in Blackpool).

Another notable feature of the film is the presence of children. The film opens and closes to the accompaniment of the nursery rhyme "The Big Ship Sailed on the Alley-Alley-O", and in several scenes we see children playing outside. (Among them, apparently, is the future Government minister Hazel Blears). Richardson's intention was presumably to contrast the innocence of childhood with the cares of adult life and to stress that Jo is little more than a child herself. Indeed, when the film opens she is still a schoolgirl, probably aged fifteen, that being the age when most pupils left school in the early sixties, unless they were intending to obtain formal educational qualifications such as O-levels. Delaney herself was only seventeen when she wrote the play on which the film is based.

"A Taste of Honey" perhaps lacks the dramatic power of some of the social-realist films of this period, such as J. Lee Thompson's "Tiger Bay" or John Schlesinger's "A Kind of Loving". It is, however, a sensitive, well-acted and occasionally humorous look at human relationships and one of the better British films from this period. 8/10

Jo's (Rita Tushingham) a daydreaming teen with a distracted mom (Dora Bryan) in search of Mr. Right or a reasonable facsimile. When ma hooks up with a guy she leaves Jo to fend for herself. Jo enters into a romance with a boat cook who ships out to sea after impregnating her and she forms a living arrangement with a gay man (Murray Melvin) to make ends meet and for moral support. When mom returns the two lock horns, debating who is the better fix for Jo and her family way.

What might pass for a very dark Hallmark domestic drama today was a groundbreaking event in 1961. Interracial relationships were scarce on the screen and homosexuality would be a crime until the law was relaxed in 67. Director Tony Richardson met the controversy head on in Honey, softening neither the outcome or its characters. Tushingham is exasperatingly brilliant as the independently minded Jo. You sympathize with her but she can be trying and stubborn. Murray Melvin is also sympathetic, avoiding caricature flamboyance with a low key sensitivity, stating his case as an outsider. Dora Bryan as Jo's floozy mom is abrasively outstanding as she lectures Jo with challenged nurturing skills on the ugly reality of her class and future.

Director Richardson captures the bleak industrial landscape of Manchester, England, managing to romanticize it in moments between the lovers but refusing to sell out the story with its sober, somber climax.

A glum well played drama.