Avaliações de usuários

"Wild Boys", homeless juvenile criminals, are reformed by the opportunity for honest labor in what is claimed as the first Soviet talking feature.

That means, of course, that it has a very strong propaganda component, and that the copy I saw, with a foreword by John Dewey and the New York State Censor's seal, with lots of English titles, was anything but the original version. The writer-director, Nikolai Ekk, only directed five features and a couple of shorts, none of which I have seen. The performers are likewise strangers to me.... oh, everyone is new to me. So, without putting this movie into the context of the career of any of the cast or crew, what's on the screen in what I assume to be a severely compromised version?

It begins as a very Academician-style movie: so much so that any movement is subordinated to the rigors of editing, and the soundtrack seems to be more a matter of scene-setting crowd noises, and bits of dialogue connected to characters when they are not on screen. In other words, it's more of a photo album with commentary for the prologue, telling how this marvelous reform began. It is not until the story is well away, and the youngsters are at the settlement where they will work, that things begin to settle down into what is more understandable story-telling.

I find the use of "wild boys" for what we would call "juvenile delinquents" to raise some questions. Certainly, William Wellman's WILD BOYS OF THE ROAD describes the American equivalent. Because the two movies are contemporary... well, some problems are universal, even if their solutions are not.

I watched this movie for a film class in college. The Road to Life exemplifies Soviet propaganda. Promoting the "collective" experience which basically boiled down to child labor was an ingenious and effective method of encouraging young Soviets to join the cause. The performances were very moving, especially the character of Mustapha. I kept expecting him to turn out to be the bad guy and ruin the work of the others... yet another Hollywood cliche shot down by a foreign film. Thank goodness for film history classes or I would have never even heard of this gem of a movie.

i have to say very little cause all you need to do is read his book "pedagoziki" cause its amazingness will drag you away from all that hollywood @#$%, i have never been to russia, or know many russian directors, but i have seen russian movies, and they were all better that the hollywood crap we're watching today