Trocando as Pernas

This, the 3 Stooges' second short for Columbia, is my all-time favorite. Perhaps it's because it's the only one that they themselves wrote. This was the first film to have the Stooges' famous "cure" for a tapeworm ("Four pieces of burnt toast and a rotten egg."). It also truly showcases Larry's violin-playing ability. The sight of Larry running down the streets looking for something playing "Pop Goes the Weasel" are hilarious. However, there were a bit of dangerous bits that came from this short: The actor playing Killer Kilduff actually bloodied Curley's lip and nose. The man on the truck that Larry takes to play "Weasel" broke his arm when he fell off the truck. Also, I think the ending has been cut, at least in the prints that I've seen. The ones I've seen show at least three or four other men stretched out in the ring with Kilduff at the end of the fight. Yet, no explanation of how they all got there. I'm thinking that PUNCH DRUNKS had a similar ending to the later GRIPS, GRUNTS AND GROANS, but is now cut for some reason. Has anyone ever seen the uncut version of this short? I'd really love to see it that way.

Have seen this episode over and over for more than 40 years and still remains my favorite Stooges short. Seems however, that some editing has been done in the end of the film where a bunch of guys are knocked out in the ring with no apparent reason. Curly knocked them all out but this footage seems to have been lost over the years. Anyone with a copy showing this action has a real treasure! Funniest parts are when Larry is serenading girl and Moe pours a bucket of water over his head. Moe crashes big wooden radio over Larry's head. Larry drives truck away with guy standing in back. Guy falls out onto street an actually breaks his arm in real life. Larry catches fish while standing on his head in a swamp.

In the early 1930s, the Three Stooges and their leader, Ted Healy, were signed to contracts with MGM. Unfortunately, this prestige studio had no idea what to do with them and their careers floundered. When you watch these films it's obvious why--they acted nothing like the Stooges! Sometimes they acted separately (such as in "Dancing Lady") and other times they were odd...but not the usual violent but lovable mugs. In their first short for Columbia, the formula still was missing--and the film was a musical! However, here in their second Columbia film, "Punch Drunks", the trio hit their stride and the film is pretty typical of their films from then on...at least while Curly played the third Stooge.

The film begins with Moe having a trio of angry boxers who hate him as their manager. But before they can pulverize him, Larry happens to be playing the violin and it just happens that the song he's playing turns Curly into a boxing maniac! So, after knocking out the three guys, Moe astutely signs Curly as his latest boxing prospect. See the film to see what's next.

Whether you think this film is good depends on you. If you hate the Stooges, it probably won't change your mind. If you are willing to watch them instead of screaming and running from the room (like my wife often does), then I think you'll enjoy their cerebral humor-- especially since it has a lot more energy than the usual short the team made. This is especially true for Larry. Even though he isn't boxing, in this one he ends up doing most of the work! And, a lot of it is genuinely funny--something that is NOT the case with many of their later efforts.

By the way, like almost every Stooge short, this one ended up getting remade. However, "A Hit with a Miss" stars Shemp Howard BEFORE he became a film Stooge!

Curly plays a gentle and passive waiter. Who is bullied by a fight promoter(Moe)and his friends. And a strugling musican(Larry) plays Pop Goes the Weasel, and something snaps inside Curly, he becomes a mean fighting machine, and beats up the guys who were bullying him. But when Larry stops playing Pop Goes the Weasel Curly becomes gentle and passive again, and does not remember a thing. Moe sees the next champ in Curly and trains him. With Larry along for the ride. A Stooge classic. The funniest boxing scenes ever. Its Moe larry and Curly at there best.

"Punch Drunks" is a very good Three Stooges' comedy, with a typically silly situation leading to a lot of confusion and laughs. Moe is a struggling boxing manager who is eating lunch when he discovers that his waiter, Curly, transforms into a formidable fighter whenever he hears the song "Pop Goes the Weasel". Curly soon gets the chance to fight the champ. The fight sequence, cross-cut with Larry's frantic attempts to provide the needed musical accompaniment, is filled with laughs, and caps off a very funny short film. All three Stooges get the chance to perform at their best in this one.