Avaliações de usuários

This is the second J-Drama that I've seen centring on classical musicians that I found to be just adorable!

What I loved:

• the complicated plot that unravels slowly with lots of surprises
• the acting by all the ensemble cast
• the soundtrack- the modern adaptations of classical music - wish they had it on Spotify
• the developing friendships between the characters
• esp. Between Maki and Suzume
• building on the themes of trust and loyalty

What was iffy:

• almost no chemistry between the characters who were romantically attracted to one another.

• would have been better if it were 11-12 episodes long
• needed more development to the character development of Suzume, Iemori and Beppu.

• as is, it leaves the impression that this was not a story about an ensemble of characters, but one that centred on Maki as the solo lead character instead.

A young woman counts her tips after busking with her cello in a busy Tokyo square and is approached by an elderly lady who offers her ¥10000 to get to know the woman with a violin in a photograph that she holds up. The woman in the photograph waits in the pouring rain for a minibus that collects her and takes her to a villa in the resort town of Karuizawa. On the way the driver, who is also revealed to be a musician, stops to collect a young man standing by the roadside and, at the villa, the cellist is found sleeping under a table.

This somewhat unconventional introduction to the four characters who form the string quartet alluded to in the title of the series, is a harbinger of the quirky dialogue and convoluted plot that is to follow in this unusual comedy of manners in which very little is what it initially seems.

Quartet is actually a brilliant study of how four disparate characters with a common purpose, i.e. to become a successful string quartet, learn to overcome their differences and reveal their secrets to become a harmonious and emotionally interdependent little group. So much so that it begins to seem that life as an albeit celibate group of four seems to trounce hands down the dull conventionality of being in a couple.

Unexpected events do their best to unsettle the group's composure and one serious revelation from the past leads to one of the group running away to deepest Tokyo, only for the other three to track them down, rally round and bring them back to the villa (a bequest from the grandfather of the second violinist, who keeps hold of it despite pressure from the rest of his family to sell).

As with a lot of J-drama, this show avoids the glossy, over-produced quality of equivalent western productions, lending it an easy spontaneity. I don't know if the actors were selected for their familiarity with stringed instruments but they are entirely convincing in their miming. Another pleasure is the witty, philosophical and sometimes absurdist conversations around the dinner table which occur on a regular basis.

'Quartet' is an intelligent and insightful comedy of manners, very different in character from (e.g.) Sakamoto's intense and melancholic 'Still, Life Goes On' and entertaining enough to engender withdrawal symptoms in this viewer after reaching the end.

This is currently the top of my list of recommendations for those who enjoy quirky, slice-of-life drama and would like to experience the best of what Japanese TV currently has to offer in that regard.

Decent concept, with a "is-she" "is-she-not" sort of plot device hanging over most episodes. But, even as a fan of classical music, I can't endorse this show more than, watch it if there's nothing else on.

The lead characters are, how do I say it,... far more "bland" than they need to be. I understand this is not an action movie. But you'd expect the characters to have some life in their eyes, or some emotion in their voices. Suzume sometimes does. But the other three never do. Unless it is for clearly comedic effect during a scene of such buffoonery that it feels totally out of place.

The story is slow. I don't mind slow. But compare this show to "Makanai: Cooking for a Maiki House" and you'll understand the difference. In that show, nothing much is happening, but the plot does move forward and the development of the characters is riveting. You want to listen to every word, and never take your eyes off the screen.

In Quartet, the characters never really say anything of importance, and repeat themselves so often, that you can safely fast-forward through whole sections of the show, simply because you know you won't miss any dialogue that matters in the least. Going into scenes, it is clearly obvious what will happen, and what will be said. There's no joy in that.

Bland, boring, and predictable. Could have been so much better. Casting and writing are the big culprits here.

FIVE stars for the music.