AVALIAÇÃO DA IMDb
7,3/10
6,8 mil
SUA AVALIAÇÃO
A aventura de um garoto judeu e seu irmão escapando da perseguição nazista na França ocupada.A aventura de um garoto judeu e seu irmão escapando da perseguição nazista na França ocupada.A aventura de um garoto judeu e seu irmão escapando da perseguição nazista na França ocupada.
- Direção
- Roteiristas
- Artistas
- Prêmios
- 3 vitórias no total
Batyste Fleurial
- Maurice Joffo
- (as Batyste Fleurial Palmieri)
Éric Bougnon
- Subinagué
- (as Eric Bougnon)
Michael Smadja
- Simon
- (as Mica Smadja)
Avaliações em destaque
It is one of the best movies I have ever seen about WWII. I trully adored these two brothers and the affection between them. It is about family, caring, trusting, loving. What makes it special among other WWII movies is the fact that it does not focus on the battles or the holocaust itself two much, so it is friendly enough for a younger audience. The picture is amazing and the soundrack is totally touching. And when it comes about acting, oohh when it comes about acting. . .you'll see! I really don't want to overdo it with my review, so I will let you enjoy it. An explosion of emotions shall begin...
"Papa, tu te souviens? Vous m'avez dit une fois que lorsqu'un homme meurt, une étoile s'allume dans le ciel. Et l'espoir doit être maintenu. C'est vrai, tu es là, papa. Et vous le serez toujours."
Such a beautiful movie. The touching story brought me to tears. The young actors who play Maurice and Joseph are phenomenal and just do an amazing job portraying these amazing strong characters. Didn't know this was a true story but it just turned everything more beautiful. One of my favourite movies without a doubt. Hurts to think the amount of people who went through this, most of them not surviving these horrifying events. A beautiful homage nevertheless.
Such a beautiful movie. The touching story brought me to tears. The young actors who play Maurice and Joseph are phenomenal and just do an amazing job portraying these amazing strong characters. Didn't know this was a true story but it just turned everything more beautiful. One of my favourite movies without a doubt. Hurts to think the amount of people who went through this, most of them not surviving these horrifying events. A beautiful homage nevertheless.
The two main characters of A Bag of Marbles are young Jewish brothers, Joseph and Maurice, whose lives are upended by the German invasion of France.
They live peacefully in Paris with their parents and two older brothers, until the occupation forces them to flee to the south, where they find temporary refuge - at least until the Nazis tighten their grip on the entire country.
Yes, it's another film about the Holocaust. And no, I don't understand the so-called "reviewers" who complain about that. If the subject matter bothers them, perhaps they should check the synopsis - or better yet, skip it altogether. As Holocaust films go, this one is exceptionally well made, with strong performances and moments that genuinely move. One especially powerful scene shows Jo's father slapping him to force a denial of his Jewish identity, a brutal act done out of desperate love. Another, more subdued but equally poignant, is Jo's failed attempt at romance with the daughter of a collaborator.
Definitely worth watching.
They live peacefully in Paris with their parents and two older brothers, until the occupation forces them to flee to the south, where they find temporary refuge - at least until the Nazis tighten their grip on the entire country.
Yes, it's another film about the Holocaust. And no, I don't understand the so-called "reviewers" who complain about that. If the subject matter bothers them, perhaps they should check the synopsis - or better yet, skip it altogether. As Holocaust films go, this one is exceptionally well made, with strong performances and moments that genuinely move. One especially powerful scene shows Jo's father slapping him to force a denial of his Jewish identity, a brutal act done out of desperate love. Another, more subdued but equally poignant, is Jo's failed attempt at romance with the daughter of a collaborator.
Definitely worth watching.
It is difficult to find the words to review a movie - and even more assign a rating - on a subject like the holocaust, drawing a line between an objective review of the filmic qualities of the movie and the emotional impact of its context. Nevertheless, I found it beautiful, delicate, moving, excruciating - even more so knowing it comes from a true story. The performance of the key actors is impeccable, always perfectly measured even in the most dramatic moments; the narrative tension is maintained high throughout the whole movie between the brutal reality of the events and the poetry of such reality seen through the eyes of a little, brave kid. Personally, I place Un Sac de Billes next to Schindler's List and La Vita é Bella; a movie that needed to be made and needs to be seen.
I wandered between the channels and there it was, an emotional movie with another amazing holocaust survival story. Especially in these days we must remember how human beings can become animals and treat other humans with an un-human treatment. Remember and never forget that history is starting to repeat itself and do what ever we can not to get there once again.
It is a story that is based on true events, which occurred to Joseph Joffo, the writer and main character in this movie. It is a family story and especially brothers' special bond and connection between young Jo and his brother - Maurice. They are both finding themselves running from the Nazis rising in France and trying, time to time, to unite with the rest of their family.
The story is written and performed with "lite" way of telling it. A lot of funny bits, that makes the horrific era to get a little bit softer, then it is remembered through out history pages. As Roberto Benigni tried to make a comedy out of his story, Christian Duguay tries his luck also and makes a big drama with a lot of thrilling moments and most important, funny moments that would let the plot go smoother in the viewers throat.
Sometimes it feels that Duguay is trying to avoid the monstrosities, in order to stay at reasonable limits of drama, but the movie illustrates properly the difficulties and the horror the Jewish community was, at those times, that mustn't even show any way of returning back to us. Excellent movie that doesn't stand out at its genre, but does the job and keeps the viewer involve and fascinated through all of its runtime.
It is a story that is based on true events, which occurred to Joseph Joffo, the writer and main character in this movie. It is a family story and especially brothers' special bond and connection between young Jo and his brother - Maurice. They are both finding themselves running from the Nazis rising in France and trying, time to time, to unite with the rest of their family.
The story is written and performed with "lite" way of telling it. A lot of funny bits, that makes the horrific era to get a little bit softer, then it is remembered through out history pages. As Roberto Benigni tried to make a comedy out of his story, Christian Duguay tries his luck also and makes a big drama with a lot of thrilling moments and most important, funny moments that would let the plot go smoother in the viewers throat.
Sometimes it feels that Duguay is trying to avoid the monstrosities, in order to stay at reasonable limits of drama, but the movie illustrates properly the difficulties and the horror the Jewish community was, at those times, that mustn't even show any way of returning back to us. Excellent movie that doesn't stand out at its genre, but does the job and keeps the viewer involve and fascinated through all of its runtime.
Você sabia?
- CuriosidadesKev Adams and Christian Clavier previously starred in Les Profs 2.
- Erros de gravaçãoA sequence show a truck carrying a SS detail as their uniforms indicate it, the truck has clearly visible a license plate referring to Wehrmacht WH. It should have a plate indicating SS.
- ConexõesFeatured in ACS France (2018)
Principais escolhas
Faça login para avaliar e ver a lista de recomendações personalizadas
- How long is A Bag of Marbles?Fornecido pela Alexa
Detalhes
- Data de lançamento
- Países de origem
- Central de atendimento oficial
- Idiomas
- Também conhecido como
- A Bag of Marbles
- Locações de filme
- Nice, Alpes Marítimos, França(on location: Nice beach in front of Negresco hotel)
- Empresas de produção
- Consulte mais créditos da empresa na IMDbPro
Bilheteria
- Orçamento
- US$ 21.400.000 (estimativa)
- Faturamento bruto nos EUA e Canadá
- US$ 411.318
- Fim de semana de estreia nos EUA e Canadá
- US$ 14.420
- 25 de mar. de 2018
- Faturamento bruto mundial
- US$ 10.898.998
- Tempo de duração
- 1 h 50 min(110 min)
- Cor
- Proporção
- 2.35 : 1
Contribua para esta página
Sugerir uma alteração ou adicionar conteúdo ausente