DigIt
Iscritto in data gen 2002
Ti diamo il benvenuto nel nuovo profilo
Stiamo ancora lavorando all'aggiornamento di alcune funzionalità del profilo. Per visualizzare I loghi, le suddivisioni delle valutazioni e i sondaggi per questo profilo, vai a versione precedente.
Recensioni25
Valutazione di DigIt
First of all each Episode is lasting about 44 minutes but more than 2 minutes are spent with some intrusive titles (a suggestive collection of shots that will also spoils the future views) that pops in breaking the narrative of the episode. If you find this already annoying like SPAM you will also get about 8 minutes (!) in the end to present you with some more spoilers for the next part and the endless credits.
To me this is already pointing to some very poor choices in the editing room.
Then we should also consider the original book from which they extracted the lack luster script: I have not read this particular book (although I am extensively well read on all WWII Military History) but I'm sure it misses the emotional human factor that was so much relevant in the previous two series. Besides the vocal testimonies from the E-Co / 506th / 101AB veterans for the Band Of Brothers as well as some good memoir and books, for the Pacific we had top notch source material with such books as Helmet for my Pillow and With the Old Breed. Then we also have the script here that is possibly lacking inspiration and falls into some trivial writings that make me suspect these characters are real ones and not just a product of creative invention. Besides their names who are them? It doesn't really matter as they disappear in the cold blue sky and nobody cares.
Please watch Twelve O'Clock High if you really want to know more about these people and their sacrifices!
I'm not sure they can fix this mess by re-editing the whole series, if they have filmed much more materials.
As it is I find it a big disservice to that Greatest Generation and a travesty of real History.
To me this is already pointing to some very poor choices in the editing room.
Then we should also consider the original book from which they extracted the lack luster script: I have not read this particular book (although I am extensively well read on all WWII Military History) but I'm sure it misses the emotional human factor that was so much relevant in the previous two series. Besides the vocal testimonies from the E-Co / 506th / 101AB veterans for the Band Of Brothers as well as some good memoir and books, for the Pacific we had top notch source material with such books as Helmet for my Pillow and With the Old Breed. Then we also have the script here that is possibly lacking inspiration and falls into some trivial writings that make me suspect these characters are real ones and not just a product of creative invention. Besides their names who are them? It doesn't really matter as they disappear in the cold blue sky and nobody cares.
Please watch Twelve O'Clock High if you really want to know more about these people and their sacrifices!
I'm not sure they can fix this mess by re-editing the whole series, if they have filmed much more materials.
As it is I find it a big disservice to that Greatest Generation and a travesty of real History.
I was expecting Stabler as an Interpol chief or an UC FBI Special Agent fighting the mafias of the World and instead I find a mere detective forcefully enrolled by a dumb sergeant in a dumber squad.
Hopefully the single ludicrous case will not be solved until the end of a season, and this is another aspect of the format I was not expecting or eager to see.
A very poor script that is another betrayal of the original concept behind the Law & Order francise. This series is a dud.
Hopefully the single ludicrous case will not be solved until the end of a season, and this is another aspect of the format I was not expecting or eager to see.
A very poor script that is another betrayal of the original concept behind the Law & Order francise. This series is a dud.