Panggonan Wingit

Don't believe the good ratings, this movie is awful!

It's a Ringu (The Ring) rip-off and a really bad one. It's like if The Asylum made a Ringu movie, but at least the Asylum movie don't take themselves too serious, but this movie does.

It's so boring that I was fighting to stay awake, and I watched it AFTER I taking a 3 hours nap. Seriously the only reason I finished the movie is because I was expecting that it at least had to have a good ending and that's why this movie has an above 5 rating in here; but no! The ending was almost an exact copy of the ending of the Ring, except the ending in that movie was good, but in this movie is really bad.

If you want to waste 2 hours of your life, just count your toes a million times, I bet that's more "entertaining" than watching this movie.

This film essentially takes place in Indonesia with a woman by the name of "Ningrum" (Hami Diah) getting hired to work as a maid at a hotel not too far from Jakarta. On her very first day, she is told that the 3rd floor is under construction and to avoid it at all costs. Not seeing any problem with this instruction, she readily agrees and begins her first day at work. It's then, to her surprise, that she hears a noise that sounds like a woman sobbing--and it's coming from a room on the 3rd floor. Naturally, being somewhat curious, she immediately goes to investigate. Then, upon entering the room where the sound appears to be coming from, she stares in horror at an extremely pale woman with white hair who, after mumbling some strange words to her, causes her to run out of the room in sheer terror. Sure enough, three days later she is killed by an unseen entity at midnight. The scene then shifts to a woman named "Raina" (Luna Maya) being driven to a hotel that she has just inherited from her father. Traveling with her is her adopted, preteen daughter "Fey" (Bianca Hello) who looks forward to starting a new life in this exotic location. When they get there, she is greeted by her in-laws who have been taking care of the place for several years. And like everyone else who comes to this hotel, they tell her to avoid the 3rd floor at all costs. Unfortunately, it isn't too long before she hears what appears to be a woman sobbing from one of the rooms on that very floor--and that's when the horror begins all over again. Now, rather than reveal any more, I will just say that this was an okay horror film which primarily benefited from its dark atmosphere and beautiful scenery. And although the acting was adequate, what lessened the film, to a certain degree, was its rather predictable plot and unsatisfying ending. That being said, while certainly not a great horror film by any means, it still kept my attention for the most part, and I have rated it according. Average.

Without ever having heard about this 2023 Indonesian supernatural horror movie titled "Panggonan Wingit" (aka "The Haunted Hotel"), I sat down to watch it here in 2024, as I happened to have the opportunity to do so. And given my life-long love of the horror genre and Asian movies, of course I needed no persuasion to sit down and watch this movie.

Writer Riheam Junianti put together a fair enough script. It was entertaining for sure, but at the same time writer Riheam Junianti was cashing in on a lot of stereotypical horror tropes, which sort of made certain aspects of "Panggonan Wingit" a bit mundane and generic. I am not saying that it is a bad movie, far from it, because I definitely enjoyed the storyline, and I am sure that newcomers to the horror genre will get a kick out of watching this movie. As a life-long horror aficionado, however, I found the movie to be good but not impressive.

Given my relatively brief exposure to the Indonesian cinema, then I was only familiar with leading actress Luna Maya in this movie. I will say, though, that the acting performances in the movie were good. The actor Egy Fedly, playing the spiritualist Ki Danang, was really well-cast for his role, because he put on quite a memorable and convincing performance.

"Panggonan Wingit" has a fair amount of blood and visual mayhem, without being over-the-top. So director Guntur Soeharjanto managed to take something that was used in moderation and get something good from it. I liked the special effects, props, sets, and wardrobe in the movie.

Running at 110 minutes, the movie could perhaps have benefitted a bit from a more generous trim in the editing room.

Worth sititng down to watch if you enjoy horror and Asian genre, of course. But it is hardly a movie that warrants more than just a single viewing.

My rating of director Guntur Soeharjanto's 2023 movie "Panggonan Wingit" lands on a five out of ten stars.

As a lifelong horror enthusiast, I approached this Indonesian supernatural flick with cautious optimism, drawn by its eerie premise rooted in Semarang's local lore. Directed by Guntur Soeharjanto, the 2023 film attempts to weave a tale of dread around a cursed hotel room, but it struggles to rise above the genre's well-worn tropes. While the movie delivers moments of visceral unease, its predictable narrative and uneven execution left me wanting more.

The film's strongest asset is its atmosphere. Soeharjanto and cinematographer create a gloomy, oppressive vibe within the Ambar Mangun Hotel, where flickering lights and shadowy corridors amplify the sense of foreboding. The sound design, with its relentless, pulse-pounding score, keeps you on edge, especially during the film's more brutal scenes. These gory moments, driven by a vengeful spirit's sadistic streak, are genuinely unsettling; the ghost's method of peeling her own skin is grotesque enough to make you wince. The makeup and visual effects, particularly the ghost's pallid, white-haired visage, are convincing, adding a layer of authenticity to the horror. For fans of gore, these elements deliver, but they're not enough to salvage the film's deeper flaws.

Where the movie stumbles is in its storytelling and character development. The script, penned by Riheam Junianti, leans heavily on familiar horror clichés: a forbidden room, a cryptic warning, a countdown to doom. It feels like a rehash of countless other ghost stories, with little innovation to set it apart. The pacing drags across its 110-minute runtime, with long stretches of repetitive dialogue and predictable jump scares that fail to land after the first act. I found myself checking the time, a cardinal sin for a horror film meant to grip you. The characters, while competently acted, are thinly drawn. Luna Maya, as Raina, brings a quiet intensity, and Egy Fedly shines as the spiritualist Ki Danang, but their roles lack depth. Christian Sugiono's journalist Ardo feels like an afterthought, his investigative thread fizzling out without impact. The film hints at a richer backstory involving the ghost's origins, but these glimpses are too brief to add emotional weight.

What frustrates most is the missed potential. The film claims inspiration from a real haunted hotel in Semarang, yet it barely taps into the cultural specificity that could have made it stand out. A flashback to the ghost's past offers a fleeting glimpse of something compelling, set in the 1980s with period-appropriate costumes and a tragic tale of betrayal. But this thread is rushed, leaving the spirit's motivations murky. Compare this to something like The Shining, where the hotel's history seeps into every frame, and you see what's lacking. The dialogue, often stilted and overly formal, further undercuts the tension; it's jarring to hear characters speak like textbooks in a supposedly casual setting.

On the technical side, the production values are solid for an Indonesian horror flick. The hotel set, with its peeling paint and creaky floors, feels lived-in, and the lighting choices enhance the eerie mood. But these strengths can't mask the narrative's shortcomings. The film's reliance on gore over psychological depth makes it feel like a one-trick pony, entertaining in bursts but forgettable overall. It's not a bad movie; newcomers to horror might find it a decent thrill ride. For seasoned viewers, though, it's a reminder of how hard it is to craft something truly haunting. I enjoyed the visceral shocks and the cast's effort, but I left wishing for a tighter edit and a bolder vision. One viewing is enough.

In fairness I'm not selecting a star rating for this film so as not to influence the user "grade" considering I didn't finish watching; I invested thirty-five or so minutes (IMO star ratings should generally be given when a film is watched in its entirety). The budget appeared to be in place and the production looked nice, but the writing! And, as a result, the acting was less than good or convincing. The dialogue was unnatural and seemed to be solely expository for us viewers. My eyes were rolling within minutes. I decided early on that another 90 minutes were probably not worth the time. But, perhaps it did turn into something worthwhile....