Adapted from the viral novel in 2000s. The original novel, which I read back when it first became popular, was inspired by a true story and was quite eye-opening, as it revealed some dark truths about an Islamic organization. Its realistic portrayal was powerful because it aligned with common rumors about the private lives within such groups that I always heard back then.
Unfortunately, the film version falls far short of expectations. Hanung's ( The director ) approach to exploring the story turns what could have been a gritty, realistic narrative into an over-dramatic, unrealistic and theatrical piece. His direction fails to capture the raw essence of the original novel, instead making it feel like an exaggerated stage play rather than a serious film that aims to uncover hidden truths.
Once again, Hanung struggles to deliver a truly inspirational movie. The film is made unnecessarily darker, with characters reacting in ways that seem melodramatic and artificial, which strips the story of its authenticity. It's disappointing to see how such a compelling novel with great potential was turned into a disjointed mess. This is by far the weakest film I've seen from Hanung, especially given its origins from a well-regarded and impactful novel.
