C'era una volta a New York

7.4 stars.

'The Immigrant' starts off really good. They captured the 1920's a genuinely as any film I've seen. What I didn't quite understand were the characters. They are all acted superbly, yet something is amiss with a few of the secondary females and also Renner's character. Can't quite put a finger on it, but whatever it was, it didn't completely eliminate my enjoyment.

As usual, Joaquin Phoenix shines as the shady and miserable, self-loathing individual. We become somewhat sympathetic of him as time passes, just a little, but there are ups and downs. He is quite an intriguing and disgusting fellow, but he has one or two decent qualities (you'll see). Renner's character is a very likable man, yet something is strange with him, and you can see glimpses of his quirks. Miss Cotillard also performs with great intensity and I feel like her portrayal was a mixture of driven and wooden. Frankly, I feel that she was being very realistic in her portrayal of a woman experiencing such severe abuse. The downside is that her strong accent is a bit difficult to understand, and the sound was not the best. I was tempted to put on the subtitles, which is very rare for me.

This film was a bit too uneven for my tastes. There was so much potential, but something was out of place. Frankly, I think the whole Renner side plot was mishandled. However, I can't shake the gut instinct that it was unbalanced. Even with this caliber of actors, it wasn't quite enough to round up to 8.0, and that's too bad.