VALUTAZIONE IMDb
6,3/10
3651
LA TUA VALUTAZIONE
Segui questi sei giovani che combattono con veemenza e senza compromessi per il loro sogno di felicità. Non sono vittime, ma giovani, coraggiosi e forti e la loro storia è assolutamente tocc... Leggi tuttoSegui questi sei giovani che combattono con veemenza e senza compromessi per il loro sogno di felicità. Non sono vittime, ma giovani, coraggiosi e forti e la loro storia è assolutamente toccante e commovente.Segui questi sei giovani che combattono con veemenza e senza compromessi per il loro sogno di felicità. Non sono vittime, ma giovani, coraggiosi e forti e la loro storia è assolutamente toccante e commovente.
- Premi
- 1 vittoria e 5 candidature totali
Sfoglia gli episodi
Riepilogo
Reviewers say 'Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof Zoo' garners mixed reactions. Strong acting, especially Jana McKinnon, and high production values are praised. However, critics argue significant deviations from the original book and movie, including changes in character ages and settings. Some feel it glamorizes drug use and lacks the original's gritty realism, while others appreciate the modern interpretation and deeper character exploration.
Recensioni in evidenza
There's not much else left to say. Cinematography is decent, some of the actors deliver a pretty good performance (Angeline Häntsch, Bruno Alexander, Gerhard Liebmann, Bernd Hölscher) - the main character's, however, is not really convincing at times.
Other than that, it's completely overproduced, drifting away from reality since minute 1. A rather cringeworthy take on David Bowie, massive overuse of soundtracks, it just feels like a never ending music video, picking up overly idealized stories of the character's lives. The "Sound" Disco looks more like a high-priced elite club of the 21st century in the US.
It's like they tried to take the whole Stranger Things fictional 80's retro vibe filter featuring fantasy content and apply it to a surprisingly uncritical story about drug addiction of Berlin's troubled youth in the 70's experiencing a mild existential crisis.
They lost me for good when they actually muted Bowie's song Heroes, the masterpiece that was carrying the atmosphere throughout the 1981 film "Christiane F.", after a few seconds just to fade in some somber piano cover of Sia's Chandelier. Not a bad song, but completely misplaced!
And that's one of the problems I have with this adaptation. It's a total overkill of dramatic elements, fake snow, wind machines, close-up shots and fake tears. It's similar to what happens to a good photo when you start tweaking and using Instagram filters...
It's like they tried to take the whole Stranger Things fictional 80's retro vibe filter featuring fantasy content and apply it to a surprisingly uncritical story about drug addiction of Berlin's troubled youth in the 70's experiencing a mild existential crisis.
They lost me for good when they actually muted Bowie's song Heroes, the masterpiece that was carrying the atmosphere throughout the 1981 film "Christiane F.", after a few seconds just to fade in some somber piano cover of Sia's Chandelier. Not a bad song, but completely misplaced!
And that's one of the problems I have with this adaptation. It's a total overkill of dramatic elements, fake snow, wind machines, close-up shots and fake tears. It's similar to what happens to a good photo when you start tweaking and using Instagram filters...
Uli Edel's originale movie is better than this show, but, however I find Philipp Kadelbach did a good job of telling an intense and painful story, but what I appreciated most is the performance of the young actors, all very talented, in particular Jana MacKinnon, who is truly exceptional in the role of Christianne.
In collective this new version of the story is not great, but not bad either, it is good and this is enough for me and advances.
In collective this new version of the story is not great, but not bad either, it is good and this is enough for me and advances.
..and thats the only real-life 70'ies about this. I get the fact that young people today have to be able to relate, but why make it more appealing? It's all way too glamorous. The argument that Christiane herself is a writer on the series doesn't impress - she may have just been outlining the story. It's annoying that the actor mother and Christiane are about the same age and that they put in the sound of a canary bird and not a budgie. The actors are ok though. She has definitely written the book herself - read that, also read the second one.
In the original book Christiane F is a 13 year old child and in the original movie she is played by a little 13 year old girl.
so it seems odd that in this version Christiane is played by a 18 year old woman, dressed and groomed like an adult and wearing makeup like a grown woman and yet seems oblivious to the fact that women have periods.
it is not a bad show but if you expect anything like the original you will be disappointed.
I totally understand, that if you have seen the Original movie from the 80s, you won't feel comfortable with this. Or it is very likely that you don't feel this movie at all. You are missing the grittiness, the dirtiness of the original. This actually is a more modern and more smooth looking approach and retelling of the source material.
That being said, it does not mean it shies away from some very irritating and disturbing things that happen to the characters here. And because this is a show, that spans 8 episodes, it is able to dive further into those characters. Which gives them more motivation and gives them more background. It works in the shows favor.
The actors really do their best and this new take will either enlighten you (better to try something different than just copy something 1 to 1, yes?) or annoy you. Be open minded if you can and you get more in depth - since I have not read the source material, I can't say how much is still probably missing from it. But it does look like we get a lot more than the original film was able to convey - just due to running time issues alone
That being said, it does not mean it shies away from some very irritating and disturbing things that happen to the characters here. And because this is a show, that spans 8 episodes, it is able to dive further into those characters. Which gives them more motivation and gives them more background. It works in the shows favor.
The actors really do their best and this new take will either enlighten you (better to try something different than just copy something 1 to 1, yes?) or annoy you. Be open minded if you can and you get more in depth - since I have not read the source material, I can't say how much is still probably missing from it. But it does look like we get a lot more than the original film was able to convey - just due to running time issues alone
Lo sapevi?
- QuizAccording to producer Oliver Berben, the budget for the first season episodes is more than 25 million euros.
- ConnessioniReferenced in Kino im Rausch: Die Kinder vom Bahnhof Zoo (2022)
I più visti
Accedi per valutare e creare un elenco di titoli salvati per ottenere consigli personalizzati
- How many seasons does We Children from Bahnhof Zoo have?Powered by Alexa
Dettagli
- Data di uscita
- Paesi di origine
- Sito ufficiale
- Lingue
- Celebre anche come
- We Children from Bahnhof Zoo
- Luoghi delle riprese
- Aziende produttrici
- Vedi altri crediti dell’azienda su IMDbPro
- Tempo di esecuzione1 ora
- Colore
Contribuisci a questa pagina
Suggerisci una modifica o aggiungi i contenuti mancanti
Divario superiore
By what name was Noi, i ragazzi dello zoo di Berlino (2021) officially released in India in Hindi?
Rispondi