VALUTAZIONE IMDb
6,7/10
2708
LA TUA VALUTAZIONE
Amaree McKenstry, un atleta sordo della Maryland School for the Deaf e i suoi migliori amici alle prese con le difficoltà dell'ultimo anno di liceo e con la futura realtà del mondo esterno d... Leggi tuttoAmaree McKenstry, un atleta sordo della Maryland School for the Deaf e i suoi migliori amici alle prese con le difficoltà dell'ultimo anno di liceo e con la futura realtà del mondo esterno degli udenti.Amaree McKenstry, un atleta sordo della Maryland School for the Deaf e i suoi migliori amici alle prese con le difficoltà dell'ultimo anno di liceo e con la futura realtà del mondo esterno degli udenti.
- Regia
- Star
- Candidato a 1 Oscar
- 1 vittoria e 3 candidature totali
Recensioni in evidenza
This is a engaging short doc that follows Deaf football players in senior year of high school. It manages to hit a lot of common experience-lost, grief, young love, etc.-quickly and elegantly. The Deaf experience isn't otherized or looked down on. This was fully engaging the entire runtime. This is full of life and pathos.
I don't really understand why it's a short and not just a full on documentary. There is so much that could have been explored deeper and better, but because if the runtime kinda feels cropped up. The subject itself is very good. I like the way they do the interviews and let us into the mind of the deaf players, but again, that could and should have been explored a lot more. The subject and goal are very interesting and cool to look at, but the execution is poor on this one. It's a shame, because it does have its moments.
This documentary was just poorly done. Great topic. Great stories, I think? Too hard to tell. Nothing is fully told. Incredibly choppy. The final game sequence was poorly shot- no suspense, didn't know what was happening. So disappointing was really looking forward to it.
I hope someone else picks up this story, as others have said, and create a real full-length documentary and/or mini series.
I hope someone else picks up this story, as others have said, and create a real full-length documentary and/or mini series.
Competing for the Oscars 2022 in the short film documentary category, it is directed by Matthew Ogens.
The film follows Amaree, a teenager who plays on an American football team. The difference is that he is deaf, as well as the coach and all the team members. The team competes for the national championship, playing and beating teams with hearing players. A defeat, after more than 40 victories in a row, made the whole team unite even more towards the common goal, which was to overcome that obstacle and win the championship.
Director Ogens intersperses moments of the team with interviews with some players, among them Amaree, with the adoptive parents of a player who committed suicide at age 15 due to bullying he suffered at the listening school, and with members of the cheerleaders, among them a gay teenager, Amaree's friend, whose first love was just the boy who killed himself.
Although it's a documentary, in the moments when the players are in the locker room or on the field, the scenes felt rehearsed, scripted, not spontaneous. It was as if the director were directing a fiction.
This lack of spontaneity in the teams' scenes is a point that leaves the documentary without life, it doesn't take off, staying in the same way until its conclusion.
The coach's testimony, at the end, is very interesting, as he says that together, the boys overcame the challenges and obstacles of a deaf person on the football field, but he was sure they would face greater obstacles and prejudices when they left that bubble.
The film follows Amaree, a teenager who plays on an American football team. The difference is that he is deaf, as well as the coach and all the team members. The team competes for the national championship, playing and beating teams with hearing players. A defeat, after more than 40 victories in a row, made the whole team unite even more towards the common goal, which was to overcome that obstacle and win the championship.
Director Ogens intersperses moments of the team with interviews with some players, among them Amaree, with the adoptive parents of a player who committed suicide at age 15 due to bullying he suffered at the listening school, and with members of the cheerleaders, among them a gay teenager, Amaree's friend, whose first love was just the boy who killed himself.
Although it's a documentary, in the moments when the players are in the locker room or on the field, the scenes felt rehearsed, scripted, not spontaneous. It was as if the director were directing a fiction.
This lack of spontaneity in the teams' scenes is a point that leaves the documentary without life, it doesn't take off, staying in the same way until its conclusion.
The coach's testimony, at the end, is very interesting, as he says that together, the boys overcame the challenges and obstacles of a deaf person on the football field, but he was sure they would face greater obstacles and prejudices when they left that bubble.
Good & Nice beautiful. What more? Thank you! My review is to short they say. So OK! This is the best film ever! Thank you very big for this! Still to short my review, ok big big love for you all and keep keep. You are the best!
Lo sapevi?
- Colonne sonoreAlphabet Soup
Written by Fatima Dahmouh, William Egan and Shaun Lopez
Performed by Tima Dee
Courtesy of Defend Music
I più visti
Accedi per valutare e creare un elenco di titoli salvati per ottenere consigli personalizzati
Dettagli
- Data di uscita
- Paese di origine
- Sito ufficiale
- Lingue
- Celebre anche come
- Нехай мене почують
- Luoghi delle riprese
- Frederick, Maryland, Stati Uniti(How can a film about the Maryland School for the Deaf be fimed in Phoenix ??, IMDB page)
- Aziende produttrici
- Vedi altri crediti dell’azienda su IMDbPro
- Tempo di esecuzione39 minuti
- Colore
- Mix di suoni
- Proporzioni
- 2.35 : 1
Contribuisci a questa pagina
Suggerisci una modifica o aggiungi i contenuti mancanti