Katy Keene

Overall the first episode was not all bad. However the fashion storyline is nothing more than The Devil wears Prada. The proposal at the end was very predictable.as her response will be. She will either say no which will end the relationship and he will go off to Philadelphia or she will accept be miserable with her decision for a few episodes and the the same results as first scenario will take place.

I've only seen the pilot so far but I like the vibe and visual aesthetics of the show. I appreciate that they don't make Instagram or social media a theme or prominent because it makes it really timeless and focused on their real lives. I feel like it's the world of the comic book but with a peppering of modernism. I also love Lucy Hale. She's adorable.

I love it, it's mindless fun and has cool fashion and takes place in NYC. Does it have a serious plot like, not really? If you want some fluff in your life , this is a great show.

Okay I love a musical but if you aren't ready to listen to a full chorus line every show.... it's just too much. BUT THE FASHION I love and the acting is good. The story lines are alright, love the drag element and the shots of NYC are great. I just think if they cut a couple of the songs it would be better.

This show isn't Riverdale it's a SPIN OFF. If you truly are into riverdale you'd see Josie is a singer who has brighter ambitions than staying in riverdale. I'm happp this show is more glam NYC , along with showing the true struggles and life styles of us New Yorkers. I personally like it and think it's cute. Plus a gay lead that also plays drag? I love it ! This show is what we needed ! So stop comparing two totally different shows to eachother.