The Investigator

Ephraim McDougall is a private investigator who investigates claims. When he is approached by a woman with a job, he turns her away as her job is not the sort he usually takes. He then finds himself drawn into a strange series of events.

When this short started it held high hopes for me: a quirky leading man, a strange visual feel to it with a focus on oddities, unexplained and mysterious characters - all these things seemed to be leading it down a very odd road that I thought would deliver a weird but enjoyable twist on the PI genre. However it doesn't manage to go down that road at all - instead stopping off at a service station and ending up stalled on the forecourt! Excuse the wandering metaphors, but it's hard to really know how to describe the film's inability to go anywhere of any value.

The film becomes more of a suggested romance with McDougall finding a young woman that he quite likes. It doesn't really do anything, in fact it has so little meaning that I was taken by surprise by the fact that it ended - in my mind it had yet to even start! This wasn't just my expectations not being met, it was the fact that the film did nothing - never mind meeting my expectations! It is all the more irritating as it managed to create a visual style and other-worldly feel that offered hope but then just held it at this level.

D'Onofrio is OK in the lead role and he contributes to the feeling of it being a little weird and otherworldly. It is a shame he is so badly served by the material. During the film he had a look of a man lost and unsure of what is going on - I assumed that this was part of the film but I now believe it was because D'Onofrio had as little understanding of the short film as I did.

Overall, this starts well and clearly had potential if the film had wanted to continue along the road it started on. Instead it stalls along the way and becomes a mostly meaningless short film that manages to lose it's audience in a very short time.

To clue in the user bob the moo who obviously dissed this one because he/she didn't have the right frame of reference to get it: The origin of this short film is that it was made for a short-lived cable TV series in the USA (along with many others such as 'Teach 109' and 'Override', films that have more of a sci-fi theme to them). Destiny was the overarching theme of all the shorts made for this late 1990s series and 'The Investigator' is a stand-out.

The film is based on O'Henry's "The Green Door". The story has been cleverly adapted to a period that is closer to 1930-1940 rather than set in O. Henry's turn of the century (1900s) New York and to make Vincent D'Onofrio's lead character, Ephraim McDougal into a claims investigator -- in the original short story the protagonist Rudolf Steiner is a piano salesman. Both stories concern themselves with personal curiosity, timidity, following conventions, a romantic outlook, risk taking, and predestination.

bob the moo is just plain wrong; D'Onofrio NAILED his character -- he's simultaneously curious, shy, timid, observant, clever, fanciful and charming. He plays his character with a clever kind of physicality, knowing how to approach each strange event that befalls him, revealing his feelings with the slightest facial expressions, mannerisms and even in his subtle variations in his speech patterns. He and the script stay surprisingly faithful to how O. Henry saw Rudolph Steiner (and for that matter the vast majority of "The Four Million" of New York in the 1900s and "The 6+ Billion" that now populate our planet - all of us may well be 'grown stiff with the ramrod of convention down our backs' and generally unwilling 'to investigate' the strange and ordinary little mysteries of life that happen to confront us daily). This part is nothing like the roles of Detective Robert O. Goren, Edgar Bug, or Pvt Leonard Lawrence/Gomer Pyle -- it's small and anachronistic and surprisingly human in scale and a totally refreshing experience to be able to revel in something so ordinary and illustrates D'Onofrio's range and versatility better than those bigger bravura roles.

I won't say anymore for fear of spoiling 'The Investigator' but my all-time favorite short story was well adapted and retold in this film -- the costumes are great (right down to D'Onofrio's too-small hat), the sets well dressed and nicely lit, the music charming. Be sure to watch for Anne Heche, quirky pop singer Rachel Sweet, and 'Dr. Quinn Medicine Woman's' Frank Collison (Collison played Horace Bing in Dr. Quinn) in this one, an adaptation that stays true to the material on which it's based.

One of my all-time favorite D'Onofrio vehicles bar none.