Humor Risk

I suspect that if HUMOR RISK was ever located, and transferred to video or DVD, it would eventually disappoint people.

The problem is that only one of the four (in 1926 five) Marx Brothers was silent - Harpo. Groucho and Chico required sound for their types of humor, with malapropisms, puns, double entendres, and mistaken words thrown in so much. Zeppo too would have needed some type of script (due to the parts he was playing in the five films he did with them). However, Zeppo (like Harpo) did apparently make one silent film (though not a major one - Frank Tuttle directed it, and Ziegfeld star Ann Pennington appeared in it).

It would be a curiosity to us if we watched it, and we would wait for it to take off. But the glorious mangling of the English tongue by Chico, and the souring confusion of metaphors and similes by Groucho would have been sorely missed.

It's curious that Jobyna Rawlston, the co-star of Harold Lloyd, was in this film. Is it just possible that Lloyd or his producer Hal Roach had some hand in the production. Maybe (if a copy survives) it's in Lloyd's or Roach's vaults. Just a guess though.

It is always welcome to see a missing film turn up, or an unexpected film turn up. For a number of years a film short with the brothers (including Zeppo) has popped up and been shown. It is of the four of them trying to get hired for a show and going to the agent's office. The skit (which is in spoken and sung rhyme) is actually the same one that would be used in a new setting in MONKEY BUSINESS where the brothers try to leave the ocean liner claiming to be Maurice Chevalier. Here they all come in wearing straw hats, trying to impress the agent. Harpo also does an interesting gag never done by him in his films. He blows up a rubber glove so that it looks like a cow's udder, "milks it into a bottle (as his hand slowly lets the air out of the glove, then he "drinks" the milk! Apparently the whole routine is from the brother's first Broadway hit: I'LL SAY SHE IS! That show appeared in 1927, before THE COCONUTS. It's nice that they saved a scene from the show.

Since the movie was only shown once and the last time was about 80 years ago, how can anyone review this film or give a rating score??!! To make this appeal to others NOT to rate or review this film, I was forced by IMDb to give a rating but how could I?!?! Unless someone who is well into their upper 90s or older can come forward and rate and review this film, I really don't think it makes any sense at all to speculate about this picture. Groucho supposedly said it was lousy and this is probably the best available assessment of the film. And, how can the film have a rating of over 7? It seems that fans of the comedy team are voting on how popular or good the group is WITHOUT REGARD TO WHETHER OR NOT THEY SAW THE FILM! My opinion is that if you haven't seen this film, don't rate it! And, if you know where there is a hidden copy of the film, sell it and make a fortune and earn the undying gratitude of Marxophiles!

By the way, another reason it's sad that this film probably no longer exists is that Harold Lloyd fans can see two of his frequent co-stars (one of which who became Mrs. Lloyd) in the film--Mildred Davies (Mrs. Lloyd) and Jobyna Ralston. Too bad...