La fée Carabosse ou le poignard fatal

One of Melies' super-productions, like VOYAGE A LA LUNE and LA ROYAUME DES FEES, this is a bit of fairy tale, about a minstrel who rescues his love from dungeon, with lots of sparklers, the usual wonderful Melies camera trickery and, in the print I was fortunate enough to see today, lots of hand-tinting. While Melies' day was passing rapidly -- Gaumont and Pathe had caught up with him in camera trickery and, if they did not produce the lush looking background and foreground that Melies specialized in, they were large enough enterprises that they could take away his market -- and Melies' film grammar always remained primitive: usually confined to the proscenium arch, his cutting rarely showed any of the sophistication discovered by George Smith in England and elaborated on by Zecca in France.

Stiill, Melies was putting up a big fight against the competition, and this is an very enjoyable movie to watch. My only issue with it is that I am on the side of the Fee Carabosse -- the minstrel paid her, not with gold, but with sand!

This is another example of a story that has scenes that confuse the viewer. A man goes to a witch to find out where the love of his life is being held. He embarks on a journey but the witch is always somewhere nearby. We are constantly distracted by superfluous events, but ultimately we get back to the idea of his goal. The final scenes are confusing and silly and a disappointment. But it is colorful and a worthy effort.

Apparently this film was commissioned by a department store, so that children could watch something and be entertained while their parents were shopping. The fact that 117 years later I could watch in my living room and wonder what the experience must have been like in 1906 tickles me.

The first thing that stands out in the production is the coloration, which was all done by hand, which at this era's frame rate and this film's length must have been well over 10,000 frames. There are no intertitles, so not being familiar with Breton folklore or the Carabosse, it took a second viewing after a Wikipedia perusal to completely understand it. There are lots of fun little elements, like the myriad beasts guarding the damsel's castle. My favorite was the witch flying through the air on her broomstick, in hot pursuit of the escaping couple. It was also interesting that the morality was kind of inverted here, since the troubadour cheated the witch to begin with.

This is Méliès in his heyday, that period between 1897 and 1914 when he made 600 films, the first to explore the fairy-tale (Cinderella), fantasy (The Bewitched Inn), science fiction (A Trip to the Moon), and the film serial (dramatizing the Dreyfus affair). He meticulous planned out his films as scénarimages, essentially inventing the modern storyboard, and for each of them, designed the sets and costumes, occasionally acted (apparently he's the title character here), and devised the special effects that would become his trademark. (All of this information comes from Alice Guy First Lady of Film by Catel and Bocquet). How incredibly tragic that after the ugly patent tussle with Edison and demise of Star Film, Méliès, at 62, ruined and disillusioned, he would burn his entire cinematographic archive in the garden of his house from which bailiffs were evicting him. It's a minor miracle this print survives, as many of those still in existence only did because of the bootleg copies that plagued him, ironically enough. Watch it in 1906 mode, and enjoy.

Witch, The (1906)

*** (out of 4)

aka La Fée Carabosse ou le poignard fatal The Impossible Voyage

Colorful and engaging film from Melies about a troubadour who goes to see a witch to get his fortune told. He promises the witch a bag full of gold but it turns out to be sand so the witch seeks vengeance on him with various hauntings. Hand-coloring these films are always tricky as some of them look great while others look incredibly bad and silly. I've seen quite a few of these tinted films from this era and I must admit that this here is the best one I've seen. I really loved all the colors being thrown around and this is easy to see when the troubadour first goes to see the witch. The color of their outfits are really terrific and the look of the witch is rather breathtaking and will make you think of the 1939 version of THE WIZARD OF OZ. The story itself is pretty strong as well, although the subplot of the troubadour trying to save a princess being held captive stops the film in its tracks to a point. With that said, there are plenty of wild special effects and neat tricks to make this a must see from the filmmography of Melies.

"La fée Carabosse ou le poignard fatal" is one of filmmaker Georges Méliès' more fanciful and strange productions. It has a much longer running time as well as many sets and costumes, making it a relatively expensive film from this French filmmaker. Sadly, it's also pretty confusing in spots and could have benefitted from intertitle cards. But such explanatory cards were only occasionally used in 1906...and I cannot recall any of his films ever using them...a big weakness of his pictures as sometimes you really do need dialog or explanations instead of all pantomime.

When the story begins, a dumb troubadour approaches the witch (she's NOT a fairy no matter what the title of the film says). He wants her to show him is future...which she does. Unfortunately, the guy is also a cheapskate and he skips out without paying her. Well, hell hath no fury like a witch who's been cheated, so she spends the rest of the film chasing him or having her minions chase him until, ultimately, God or some angel or saint appears. Then, inexplicably, they help this guy defeat the witch....even though she really just wants to be paid for her time and trouble!

A few parts, such as the neat looking but confusing part at the cemetery, were confusing. Still, despite this, the story is interesting, the costumes very nice and the print (fortunately) still has a bright hand-colored look to it. Well worth seeing.