Recensioni degli utenti

Lee Grant---yes, the goofy shoplifter in Detective Story; yes, Warren Beatty's wealthy lover in Shampoo; yes, the one who won the Oscar for it---also won an Oscar (actually it was a tie, suspiciously) for directing this unflinching, incredibly succinct documentary which critiques Reaganomics by showing poverty in the United States infecting three subdivisions of American society stricken by depression in the mid-1980s: heartland farms, factory workers made redundant, and the recently homeless. Hundreds of family farms were being reclaimed every week, and these people speak of their farms, the quality of their bank loans, the blitz of corporate farming---which still continue to make family farms, not to mention healthy food and humanity toward the animals, increasingly difficult to sustain---and their grief and hopelessness. In cities where thousands of jobs per day go abroad, laid-off workers consider their alternatives. The freshly destitute describe the jobs of which they've suffered the loss, JusticeVille in Los Angeles, soon leveled by court order, and sitting on their heels in New York's deserted buildings. A family living in a welfare hotel relates their story.

In a time when over three thousand jobs a day were being shipped overseas, the unemployment rate averaged higher under Reagan than under Nixon, Ford or Carter, at the same time as the average productivity growth decelerated more under Reagan than those same three. What's more, real wages dropped harshly throughout the Reagan Presidency. Perhaps at the heart of this film's subjects and quite possibly the impetus for it, the tax reform would supposedly have decreased or done away with tax deductions but this legislation expanded the minimum tax from a law for untaxed rich investors to one redeployed to middle class Americans who had children, owned a home, or lived in high tax states. They were the ones on whom the most adverse effect was made by diminishing their deductions and in effect raising their taxes. In the meantime, the highest income earners were in proportion less impinged on, in this manner moving the tax burden away from the richest 0.5% to poorer Americans. Not even a few years ago, the minimum tax was stressed to be the sole most crucial setback in the tax code.

Thirty years after being blacklisted for refusing to testify against her husband, Grant took matters into her own hands with this Oscar-winning example of unfortunate Americans and the social dynamics that shared in their poverty. During an hour of varied footage, narrated over by Grant, Down and Out in America looks at a cluster of farmers demonstrating their disapproval upon being foreclosed on by the bank, a grassroots homeless alliance obstructed by stingy, acquisitive property owners, and a family of six make shifting a home in a filthy welfare hotel after being bereaved of their home in a fire. Grant does not pull overt associations between the oppressed, exploited Americans. In place of that, she allows the shared torment they make known to work as an overarching criticism of a wealthy society that has made an exception to the requirements of its most defenseless voters.

Lee Grant's Academy Award-winning "Down and Out in America" focuses on the people driven into poverty in the 1980s. A group of farmers in rural Minnesota, as well as homeless people in the big cities got left behind by Reagan's policies. These things continue to this day. NAFTA drove more jobs out of the country, while tax cuts shifted the tax burden onto the working class. One of the people in the documentary mentions that the jobs have gone to Mexico and Korea - nowadays it's usually China - so that the companies can pay pennies on the dollar. Indeed, the documentary addresses many of the same topics that Michael Moore's "Roger and Me" did (but never taking a comedic approach).

This is something that everyone should see. Along with "Roger and Me", other movies that look at the destruction of the so called American dream are Norman Jewison's "Other People's Money" and Richard Linklater's "Fast Food Nation".

Lee Grant directs and narrates this dismaying look at the results of Reaganomics upon America's working class. She looks at the plight of the farmers who face foreclosure on their lands, people living in a 1980s' version of a "Hooverville" and are being forced to move, and at a family who has been burned out of their home and has nowhere to turn except for an overcrowded welfare house. The stories are moving and prove that bad things can happen to good people, but the film grows a bit tiresome by its conclusion. Grant does an obviously careful job of choosing well-spoken subjects in order to help strengthen her slant on the issues at hand. The result is the feeling of being a bit manipulated by the filmmaker, but of course, almost every documentary filmmaker is going to have a passion for his or her subject matter and have his or her opinions on it, otherwise the filmmaker would not bother to make the film in the first place. "Down and Out In America" is an interesting film in terms of its subject matter, but it offers nothing ground-breaking in regards to its contribution to the genre of the documentary.