Scheherazade

Biography films are an odd genre; composer films are in a class by themselves. Facts are brushed aside blithely in this film. Korsakov was in the navy and wrote some music while aboard ship. That is the total agreement with history of this film. Add to this the vision of poor Yvonne De Carlo's out-takes of nearly falling over while dancing and you have one of the lamest composer movies ever. So why is this movie so much fun? I think it's the Viennese operetta feel of the piece: logic should never intrude on fun. And Eve Arden's dry delivery doesn't hurt either.

I saw this movie as a Russian speaking teenager in Boston, but it couldn't have been further away from anything truly Russian. I had already studied a lot of Russian music and dance and so was anxious to see a film about one of my favorite composers: Nicholi Rimsky Korsakov. I couldn't have been more disillusioned. The Rimsky Korsakov that I knew from pictures in books wore glasses and had a long beard though he could have looked a bit like Jean Pierre Aumont when he was young. He certainly was in the Russisn navy and did travel all over the world but his life was absolutely nothing like that portrayed in the film. Even so, that's Hollywood and it was enjoyable though hilarious. Eve Arden couldn't have been worst cast, though I always loved her witty remarks and wise cracks in all her movies. But as a Spanish Duena? And wearing a Mantilla? Really! Yvonne De Carlo was surely beautiful but a dancer? Never. And who on earth did her choreography? I understand dummying down choreography for non dancers to be able to do, (called sham dancing) but surely it could have been a bit more inventive than this. Then, low and behold, she is dancing as Prima Ballerina at the Bolshoi Theater no less. OK, when in doubt, use a tambourine. Forget that Scherezade (only in the Ballet Russe repertory and not until 1920) as a ballet was never given at the Bolshoi in Moscow until the 1980s. And as Prima Ballerina in this silly version, (not even in toe shoes) she meets Rimsky (presumably during intermission) on the front steps of the Bolshoi wearing wedgies in the Moscow snow. AND, who on earth was the kid dancing with her on stage? Was it her little sister or the grand daughter of one of the producers from a local dancing school? Neither one would be allowed to even set foot on the stage of the Bolshoi let alone dance, even back during that time; 1880 or thereabouts. Brian Donlevy strutting around in a dance belt, puffing out his bare chest. Is this what one reviewer here was referring to as homo erotic? I suppose so, for 1947, but he sits in a box at the Bolshoi where he wouldn't have even been allowed past the front entrance, cigarette and all. But actually, I really love this movie for all its silliness and somehow I even managed to get it on tape, possibly it was shown on TV back during the 1980s. It's time I take another look at it. Yvonne De Carlo went on to be a star on Broadway and of course as Lily Munster on TV. Jean Pierre later married Maria Montez. Could that be right??? An added note: Years later, while in Moscow, I saw a Soviet version of Rimsky's life. Much more authentic of course with wonderful actors and in gorgeous Soviet color but of course no equal to MGM's production values. I think it was just called "Rimsky Korsakov's Life". They also did one on "Mousorgsky" another Russian composer. That was during Soviet times. I don't think Russian film industry would attempt such films now.

Rimski-Korsakov was a great composer who wrote much very beautiful music, especially his masterpiece, Scheherazade, which is featured in this fictionalized film about his early years as a Russian naval cadet (although he really was a naval cadet before he switched to music as a full- time vocation). Yvonne DeCarlo was an exceptionally beautiful woman, more appreciated for her outstanding beauty than for her acting which, nevertheless, was reasonably competent. That combination was good enough for me when I first saw this movie decades ago as a teenager, and it's still enough to let me enjoy it as an adult. If musical beauty plus feminine beauty are appealing to you, please treat yourself to this film. I do, however, wish that it was available as a DVD.

This film was one of my favorites when I was in junior high school in the early 60s and a local TV station played it somewhat regularly on their four-o-clock movie, perfect for after school viewing. After that it seemed to vanish forever and I had even forgotten its title until by chance it turned up on Turner classics one day. It's a really fun film, very colorful and full of the music of Rimsky-Korsakov, who is its main subject in what is not a biopic so much as a fantasy about the composer's days as a Russian naval cadet who falls in love in Cadiz, Spain. I've been a fan of the composer even back in those afternoon TV days. I've read his fascinating autobiography "My Life In Music" and have written reviews of many CDs of his works. Don't worry, I'm not going to go on for paragraphs about his life and music. I just want to make two things clear. Rimsky-Korsakov actually was in the Russian navy and as a cadet, did make an almost three year voyage (from late 1862 to May, 1865) on the clipper ship, Almaz and did visit New York and Rio as is mentioned in the film. The ship never docked in Spain and everything else in the film is made up. Secondly, all of the music in the film, even short background music as when the cadets report on deck, is by the composer, that being the March from Tsar Tsaltan.

The audience of the 1940s would have been familiar with most of this music. People in general were much more aware of classical music, at least its big, tuneful hits, than they are today. The most featured music here is from his symphonic suite, "Scheherazade". Its third movement, subtitled "The Young Prince and the Young Princess" was a very popular romantic orchestral number, second only to the finale of Rachmaninov's Second Piano Concerto. Everyone knew "The Flight of the Bumblebee", though few would have known that it came from an opera. Another opera excerpt. "Song of India" had been a huge hit for Tommy Dorsey in a jazz arrangement. The big dance at the party is set to "Capriccio Espagnol", another piece the audience would have known.

It's interesting that this film can be appreciated straight on as a romantic film as many people do, but also can be viewed as a camp classic. After all, it's a post-war 40s over-the-top Technicolor musical and dance fest with colorful costumes and an elaborate Kismet-like finale. It also includes an operatic singing doctor, a villainous prince with a bullwhip and Yvonne De Carlo dancing in exotic costumes. IHere she's seen early in her career when Universal was mainly using her for her looks and featuring her in roles that allowed for exotic costuming. Her next film was "Slave Girl", so you see what she was up against. She managed to escape into film noir and British comedies and, of course, "The Munsters" (1964-1966). In 1971 on Broadway, she introduced "I'm Still Here" in Stephen Sondheim's "Follies". Then there's Eve Arden, who is the real highlight of the film as De Carlo's mother. This was something she wasn't thrilled about, being only fourteen years older. But she has a great time dropping droll and witty comments in her deadpan way as she had been doing since her first film, "Stage Door:(1937). Here she is the life of the party, chewing through scenery left and right and providing the energy that keeps the film going.

The critics hated the film, considering it kitsch totally beneath their consideration, but the public loved it and made it a big box office hit grossing 2.1 million, which would make it the 13th biggest film of 1947. The critics were too hard on such an unpretentious film that wants nothing more than to be entertaining. It had an odd origin back in World War II when the U. S. and U. S. S. R. found themselves unlikely allies against Hitler and American movie studios were shopping around for upbeat Russian material. A pair of producers bought the rights to Rimsky-Korsakov's music from the Soviet government and had screenwriter Walter Reisch write a screenplay. Reisch had been a highly regarded screenwriter in Vienna and at Berlin's UFA, where he often worked with Billy Wilder. Both fled to America when Hitler took power and occasionally continued to work together. Reisch wrote "Ninotchka" and "Gaslight" among many other films. The plan had been for MGM to film it but they lost interest and the would-be producers let the music rights and screenplay go to Reisch. He took it to Universal, who even let him direct it (the only American film he would ever direct).

"Song of Scheherazade" has an outstanding cast who also give it more life and character than one would usually expect. Jean-Pierre Aumont plays the composer with great charm. He never became a big star in Hollywood, but appeared in many films in both America and France including "Lili"(1953)., "Gigi" (1958), "Day For Night" (Truffaut/France) and Merchant/Ivory's "Jefferson In Paris" (1995). DeCarlo was not known as a dancer but had danced in nightclubs since 1940 and was coached by noted dancer Tilly Lesch and was able to handle the balletic finale. Brian Donlevy does a light version of his usual tough guy roles. Lyric tenor Charles Kullman was borrowed from the Metropolitan Opera and is surprisingly fun in his role as the ship's doctor. Child actor Terry Kilburn, now twenty, is Midshipman Loren, whose humorous escapades also enliven the film. Go into this film with expectations of fun and you'll have a good time.

I was an Australian Israeli doing 31 days reserve army duty in the Israel Defence Forces during the 1968-69 War of Attrition along the Suez Canal. My duty at this time was driving a Dodge truck with a young army movie projectionist, a movie projector and a portable screen. We were given just the one movie, 'Song of Scherezade' with Yvonne De Carlo, and we were ordered to show this film as entertainment - even though sometimes we were under fire from the enemy - to the guys in all our heavy gun positions along the Canal. I had no choice but to sit in the sand and watch this movie 31 times, and I ended up knowing the dialogue off pat. It was a funny experience, but it also got a bit hairy at times, and to top it off, I was wounded on the 31st day which was my last day of service. I have nearly finished writing a story about this crazy experience, but it all happened 37 years ago and, being 74 years old now, unfortunately, there's no way can I remember any of the dialogue. I desperately need to get hold of a video or DVD to help me out with this problem. So far I haven't had any luck and this is why I am sending this email to you. It would be great if maybe you could tell me where I could pick up a copy of the movie.