Vecchia California

The movie is a stab at an epic western that simply fails to gel. The best part is the "moving west" scenes of wagon trains convoying across the open southwestern terrain. These achieve an epic feel that the dramatics unfortunately fail to duplicate. The screenplay itself is pretty crowded, telling the story of California's becoming a state, no less. From settlers to gold rush to saloons to political intrigue, the story is traced out mainly through Milland, Stanwyck, and Coulouris, with Fitzgerald as a salt-of-the-earth anchor.

Now, that might work, except director Farrow has little feel for the material. The various parts come across in rather limp, unexciting fashion. It's as if he's content to simply film the script without bringing its many conflicts to dramatic life. Thus, the drama is conveyed in words instead of characters. Then too, Oscar winner Milland appears either miscast or uninspired. His role really calls for a bigger personality than Milland's generally low-key wagon master. (He may have viewed a western as a comedown after his award winning role in The Lost Weekend.) Stanwyck is of course Stanwyck even though she's dolled-up to suit Technicolor filming and crowded around by the packed screenplay . Too bad the guy who could have enlivened the action remains in supporting background, namely, the commanding Albert Dekker (Pike).

Anyway, I guess I now know why this epic western remains so obscure, despite its Paramount pedigree and marquee cast.

California really disappointed me. It is without question Barbara Stanwyck's least shown Western ( and the only one that eluded me). The problem is not that it is bad movie ( it isn't), it is that Barbara ( Lily) is wasted. Barbara in westerns from the beginning ( Annie Oakley) until the end ( The Big Valley) is the reason to watch. Not here: It is. Ray Milland's ( Jonathan Trumbo) Film all the way, and he dominates the movie. One major plus is the print. I am willing to bet that Universal remastered the movie because of how crystal clear the print is. I still cannot get over how disappointed I was in this movie. I give it 5/10 stars. All for Milland and the quality of the print.

I always thought Barbara Stanwyck had the measure of any of the men she co-starred with in westerns, and here she certainly holds her own as the manipulative "Lily". She joins a wagon train heading west, but the gold rush rumours split that up and so she proceeds to the coast where she quickly ends up owning quite a lucrative saloon. She's pretty much sharing control of the town with the odious storekeeper/daylight robbery merchant "Pharaoh Coffin" (George Colouris) when her erstwhile pals "Trumbo" (Ray Milland) and "Fabian" (Barry Fitzgerald) arrive, all amidst increasing calls for Californian statehood. Needless to say, those in power locally want the status quo - the new arrivals want something more "democratic". What now ensues are a series of cat-fights that keep this moving along well enough until, what I must admit to feeling was a bit of a disappointing denouement. Stanwyck stands out, and Fitzgerald and the rather oddly cast Coulouris are also effective. Milland, however, well he doesn't quite cut the mustard and there is way, way too much dialogue as this story takes far too long to get up any head of steam. Still, it's got a pioneering sort of spirit to it that I quite enjoyed.

Epic account of how California became a state, featuring a wagon train full of settlers that joins Wicked" Lily Bishop (Barbara Stanwick) expeled from a town , to go California, led by Michael Fabian (Barry Fitzgerald) and Johnnny Trumbo (Ray Milland) . However , news of the Gold Rush scatters the caravan and subsequently taking on evil profiteers . But worse troubles are ahead : California is inching toward statehood and corrupt politicians wish other personal and mean purports .

Awesome epic Western with giant cast , gorgeous photography and wonderful scenarios . Turbulent and mighty story about an epic saga set against the background of Gold Rush and historical deeds ; covering several decades of Westward expansion in the nineteenth century--including the Gold Rush, and usual political confrontation . And of course , the building of the California State with certain politicians who want to make it their private empire ; among other epic events . The picture gets great action , expansive Western settings , shootouts , love stories , it is quite entertaining and there some some scenes still rate with the best of the West , including marvelous moments along the way . It efficiently describes an attractive panoramic view of the American Western focusing on the tribulations , trials and travels of settlers and adventurers . It's a big budget film with good actors , technicians, production values and pleasing results . Breathtakng as well as spectacular scenes such as the long Wagon Train , and the final attack sequences , among others . Particularly supreme for its all-star cast list with some actors epitomising the spirit of the early West , at least as Hollywood saw it , including the indomit wicked saloon queen Barbara Stanwick , the tough wagon train guide Ray Milland and his colleague the always sympathetic Barry Fitzgerald .And a splendid support cast as George Coulouris as the powerful storekeeper , former slaver Pharaoh Coffin , Albert Dekker , Anthony Quinn , Eduardo Ciannelli and Frank Faylen.

Impressive cinematography filmed in big screen by Ray Rennahan , and photographed in splendorous Technicolor , though it loses much of its overwhelming visual impact on TV but otherwise holds up pretty well . This star-studded, epic Western adventure is a really old style Hollywood film well directed by John Farrow . At his begining he stayed in Hollywood as a screenwriter, from A Sailor's Sweetheart (1927) through Tarzan escapes (1936). He married Tarzan's Jane, Maureen O'Sullivan, in 1936. He began directing in 1937 Men in Exile and West of Shanghai (1937). He was injured while serving as a Lieutenant Commander in the Royal Navy in World War II. After that he converted to Catholicism and wrote a biography of Thomas More, a history of the Papacy, a Tahitian/English dictionary and several novels. And directing notorious films as Wake island , This kind of woman , Hondo , Calcuta , China , The big clock , Red, Hot and Blue ,Alias Nick Beal , Beyond glory , Hitler Gang and several others . He collaborated in the writing of several of his films and shared the Academy Award for Around the world in 80 days (1956). Rating : 6.5/10 , essential and indispensable watching . It's a magnificent example of the kind of old-fashioned blockbuster just don't make anymore .

The Casting of Barry Fitzgerald as a Dirt Farmer/Politician/Saint.

And George Coulouris as a Former Slave Trader and Devil Incarnate.

Almost Ruin a Sprawling Technicolor Production.

Ray Milland and Barbara Stanwyck are Stalwart as in On Again-Off Again Romance Trying Desperately to Inject some Suspense and Intrigue in this Hopelessly Overblown Story.

John Farrow's Direction is Pedestrian with Few Flourishes that Make the Movie come to Life as it just Hops Around from One Direction to the Next.

A Huge Disappointment Considering.

The First Act with a Wagon Train that Stampedes as soon as the Word Arrives that Gold was Discovered in the Titled Territory.

The Second Act is a Gambling Hall with Stanwick and Coulouris being Infiltrated as Milland Shows Up.

Then there's Talk about California becoming a State.

The Third Act is Political and an Attempted Empire Building by Coulouris.

Buy this Time the Film has Worn Out its Welcome and Scenes Come and Go with Little Gravitas.

It just Runs its Course to the Predictably Flat Ending.

Worth a Watch with Very Low Expectations.