With the popularity of musical films during the golden era of Hollywood, the major studios dabbled some with bringing prominent opera stars of the stage to the general public. "Hitting a New High" is the third film by RKO to star French-born Lily Pons. She was a leading soprano with the Metropolitan Opera in New York, from 1931 to 1960. Besides opera, Pons was a successful concert singer. She was known especially for her exceptional ability to reach the super high notes - above high C which all good sopranos could sing. Pons regularly hit D above high C and was the only classical singer of her time who could sing F above high C.
Some of the musicals with opera singers did well, but many did not. The most popular opera singers with mostly successful films were Kathryn Grayson, Jeanette MacDonald, Jane Powell and Deanna Durbin. While just a few musicals by the opera stars were biographical, most were comedies and romance. One of the most successful overall was Jeanette MacDonald. She and Nelson Eddy were the most enduring couples in musicals, making eight films together. But she made 20 plus more films with various leading men of the day.
This film turned out to be a flop, and it was the last musical Pons made, with just one more small part in a later film. The problem with "Hitting a New High" is that it dwelled on Pons's coloratura talent - lots of vibrato and movement within long-held and repeated high notes that she just sang solo. She appeared to be warbling like birds that were in scenes with her. She only sings parts of two operatic songs in this film, and her frequent super high and chirping type of notes soon become tiring - even irritating. Still, the movie might have worked if it had a better screenplay to milk the great comedy talent assembled for the film.
With Jack Oakie, Eric Blore, E. E. Horton and Luis Alberni, this film should have caused lots of laughter. But the script hardly used any of their talents. It had a wacky plot of a singer being discovered in the jungle. That could have been developed with much humor, but it wasn't. Horton's frequent pompous and flummoxed high society character was overdone, with nary a humorous scene or funny line. He soon became irritating. Alberni wasn't used for comedy at all, and Jack Oakie's male lead was so weak in humor as to be dull. Eric Blore had one lively scene toward the end. Had the writers exploited the idea more that he was the father of the long-lost bird girl raised in the jungle, there could have been some great comedy. But RKO let that chance slip through its fingers.
As a result, this is a quite dull film that moves very slowly. It's wroth viewing for those who like music, to see and hear Pons reach those super high notes. Otherwise, it has just the small bit of humor added mostly by Blore. Most modern audiences would probably give up and quit watching this film before halfway through. I like musicals, and great comedies, so I stuck to the end.
