The Glass Key

This 1935 version of The Glass Key is not often seen, the 1942 film with Alan Ladd, Veronica Lake, and Brian Donlevy is far better known. Still this one has some interesting features, notably for the one and only time in his career George Raft played a Dashiell Hammett hero.

It is one of the legends of Hollywood that George Raft turned down three of the roles that made Humphrey Bogart a legend, High Sierra, The Maltese Falcon, and Casablanca. The middle one of these was taken from the Dashiell Hammett novel and Ed Beaumont is very much like Sam Spade.

They have the same laconic personality, but unlike Spade who is a partner in a detective agency and for hire, George Raft as Beaumont is the personal retainer and fixer for political boss Edward Arnold. And Arnold is heading for some trouble. He's decided to join the 'reform' element in his town headed by Senator Charles Richman and that does not please gangster Robert Gleckler who has had a working relationship with Arnold up to this time. But Arnold who has worked his way up from poverty sees a chance at respectability and the thing that makes him interested is Claire Dodd who is Richman's daughter and who plays along with Arnold's interest in her for her father's sake.

At the same time Richman has a wastrel son in Ray Milland who has added Arnold's daughter Rosalind Keith to his list of conquests. He's needing some money real bad to pay off gambling markers to Gleckler. Later on Milland winds up dead and suspicion falls on Arnold. It's up to Raft to investigate and get him out of the jackpot.

Three big changes from this version of The Glass Key are readily apparent. First in the 1942 version the daughter of Arnold becomes the sister of Brian Donlevy played there by Bonita Granville. Secondly the character of Emma Dunn is here as Arnold's mother, the mother isn't in the 1942 film. Finally a most unfunny comic relief character in this film played by Tammany Young is dropped altogether from the later film. Otherwise if you know what happened in that film the same occurs here with the same ending.

But the leads are the exact same, tightlipped and tough. George Raft and Alan Ladd are just about the same as actors except for hair color. Veronica Lake is a bit more sultry than Claire Dodd, but then again she was more sultry than most of the women ever born on planet earth.

I think Donlevy convinced himself in his version that he was really in love with Veronica Lake. Arnold whose character mouths the words was married before and now that he's a widower is looking for that all important trophy wife this time around.

It's hard to choose between Guinn Williams and William Bendix who played the sadistic Jeff who was the button man for Gleckler. Williams could be brutal in films if he had to, though most of the time he played amiable lunkheads. There's no element of latent repressed homosexuality in Williams's performance as there is with Bendix however.

Although both versions from Paramount of The Glass Key standup well today, it's really a pity that Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall never got to do this story. It would have been perfect for both of them.

This early adaptation of Hammett's novel is not as well known as the Alan Ladd version but is very much worth seeing. Different in some ways, eerily similar in some ways, it's usually a little more raw than the later remake (the car crash that opens the film is still jarring today). And as the other reviewer notes, it has all the classic noir elements. Definitely worth seeking out.

Lacking Only the Glossy Sheen Perfected in the 40's, this is, the Under-Seen 1st Version of the 1931 Dashiell Hammett Novel, which was Remade 1942 with Alan Ladd and Veronica Lake.

This is Directed by the Blacklisted Frank Tuttle (who made a mark with "This Gun for Hire" (1942), and made a Star out of, wait for it...Alan Ladd.

Ever Since the Remake this One has Faded Further and Further From Film-Buffs Lexicon and has Lingered in Near Obscurity Only Mentioned in Passing Reference.

Also Hindering the Reputation is the Much Maligned and Overrated, especially Compared to Alan Ladd, George Raft in the Lead.

But, Truth be Told, it is a Solid and Spot-On Performance from Raft that He Seldom Matched, and the Enormous Popularity of Alan Ladd Helped Hide this Under-Seen Gem for Years.

It Contains some Brutal "Code-Pushing" Violence, especially the Famous Scene, in Both Versions where "Ed" Gets the Tar Beat Out of Him by a Possibly "Gay" Sadist Guinn Williams, William Bendix in the Ladd Version.

Also, Witness some Impressionistic Overlays of Shadowing that Preceded the Film-Noir Prime, Possibly Influenced by the Recent Run of "Horror" Films that were Extremely Expressionistic.

Edward Arnold Plays the "Mob-Boss" Controlling the Politics and the City, Brian Donlevy in the Remake. Arnold is More Hard-Boiled, but Phonies Up a Laugh Now and Then. Both Performances Hold Their Own.

Where the 40's Version has Effervescent Veronica Lake Stealing the Spotlight, Rosalind Colli as the Love-Interest Here is Basically a Non-Entity and is Overshadowed by Raft, Arnold, and the Interwoven Political Corruption-Crime Elements.

Look for a Young "Ray Milland in the Opening Act as a Freeloading Gambler that Stirs Things Up in a Big Way.

Madvig: "He's practically given me the key to his house." Beaumont: "Yeah? A glass key. Look out it don't break off in your hand."

Film-Buffs Must See Both Versions for the Full-Monty.

Dashiell Hammett's 1931 novel, 'The Glass Key,' has been compared favorably to his earlier 1930 detective thriller, 'The Maltese Falcon." Paramount Pictures, buying the rights to the book as soon as it was hot off the presses, was the first Hollywood studio to bring the yarn to the screen in June 1935's "The Glass Key." George Raft plays the lead character Ed Beaumont, an assistant to crime boss and politician Paul Madvig (Edward Arnold).

A number critics cite Raft's performance as one of his best. "Raft is letter-perfect as the fast-talking, faster-thinking gambler who plays his cards close to his chest, speaking only with his mouth while his face says nothing, just his flashing eyes giving evidence of the wheels turning behind his outwardly calm visage," describes blogger Educated Guesswork.

Beaumont is the strong-arm enforcer to political big-wig Madvig, who also runs the city's crime syndicate. Directed by veteran Frank Tuttle, "The Glass Key" has been categorized by film historians as one of the first 'film noirs' brought to the screen. One scene especially qualifies its membership to the world of noirs' expressionistic lighting. Critic Dan Stumpf notes, "There's a particularly fine moment where he (Beaumont) watches a brutal murder without a flicker of emotion. Tuttle keeps the camera on Raft, his face lit by a wildly swinging overhead light that slows as a life slowly ebbs away." While directing "The Glass Key," Tuttle joined the American Communist Party, seeing it as a force to tamp down the rising power of Adolf Hitler. His membership ultimately hurt his career after World War Two, and was listed as one of 36 names linked by the Congressional House Committee in the late 1940s to be blacklisted in Hollywood.

Young actress Ann Sheridan, who claimed she was genealogically linked to Civil War Union general Philip Sheridan (her father was his grandnephew), showed an interest in acting at Denton Texas High School before earning a bit part in the 1934 movie 'Search for Beauty.' After twenty small uncredited roles, the 20-year-old actress appeared in "The Glass Key," playing the nurse overseeing the beaten up Ed in the hospital. Sheridan was one of Hollywood's more prominent screen actresses, whose career was cut short at 51 from cancer in 1967.

Gary Cooper was originally scheduled to play the George Raft role, but he was in the middle of a contract dispute with Paramount. "The Glass Key" was remade in 1942 with Alan Ladd and Veronica Lake, while the Coen Brothers made a more stark version of the Hammett story in their 1990 "Miller's Crossing" with Albert Finney.

Crime novelist Dashiell Hammett is best-known for penning THE THIN MAN and THE MALTESE FALCON and, like the latter's original 1931 film version was completely overshadowed by John Huston's classic 1941 remake, the same fate practically befell another of his filmed works. In fact, the original 1935 version of THE GLASS KEY has been all but impossible to see until recently, while its 1942 remake was easily available on DVD in Europe. Although I do own a copy of the latter, it has been ages since I watched it last and cannot sensibly compare the two versions now; having said that, the credits for the original – director Frank Tuttle (who would later make a star out of Alan Ladd in THIS GUN FOR HIRE and whose next picture, ironically enough, was the aforementioned remake of THE GLASS KEY!), stars George Raft (this obviously made him the first choice for Sam Spade in the remake of FALCON, but he turned it down to Bogie's eternal benefit!), Ray Milland and Ann Sheridan, plus character actors Edward Arnold, Guinn Williams and Irving Bacon – are sufficiently interesting to merit its re-evaluation as a worthy precursor to the noir subgenre.

Raft is influential lawyer Arnold's right-hand man who, carrying on from his own star-making turn in Howard Hawks' SCARFACE (1932), has an eye for his boss' sister; when the former decides to become the ally of the local political candidate (because he too has his heart set on the latter's sister!), everything starts to go wrong for him, especially after turning down the defense of a drunken motorist from a manslaughter charge and when setting his foot down on the nightclub owned by the local underworld kingpin. However, it is the politician's inveterate gambler son Milland who proves to be the catalyst for disaster as, ostensibly pursuing the affections of Arnold's daughter, he is truly after milking the girl out of her funds to satiate the aforementioned criminal with whom he is indebted. This state of affairs naturally pits Arnold and Milland at loggerheads and it is up to the quick-witted Raft to shuffle his boss out of a murder rap when Milland's corpse is found lying in the gutter one night after the latest scuffle with his prospective father-in-law!

At one point in the narrative – in a brutal sequence anticipating the later ones featuring Dick Powell's Philip Marlowe and Ralph Meeker's Mike Hammer in, respectively, Edward Dmytryk's MURDER, MY SWEET (1944) and Robert Aldrich's KISS ME DEADLY (1955) – Raft suffers greatly at the hands of the criminal's chief henchman Williams (effectively cast against type) and, eventually, ends up in hospital where he is nursed by a pre-stardom Sheridan. Yet, despite having also been assaulted by a massive dog, he goes back for more and, ultimately, defeats the thug by turning him against his own employer. The identity of the real murderer is not all that mysterious in itself but the journey to the denouement is an exciting ride and, indeed, it is kickstarted by a spectacular car-crash right in the very opening scene! For what it is worth, the characters of Arnold's mother and card-trick obsessed odd-job man, providing here the requisite elements of sentimentality and comic relief, were dispensed with for the remake in those somber days of WWII.