The St. Louis Kid

By the time the St. Louis Kid was made Warner Brothers had gotten the James Cagney persona fixed in the mind of the movie going public. The cocky wiseacre working class hero in perpetual motion who always gets what he's after, be it money, power or a girl.

Here it's a girl, but he also gets himself mixed up in a labor dispute between dairy farmers and the trucking company that ships their product in between St. Louis and Chicago. In those early years of the New Deal labor disputes were a pretty hot topic in the newsreels.

Robert Barrat, a leader of the farmers, is killed by one of the goons hired by Cagney's trucking company and the cops think Cagney did it. Patricia Ellis, the girl Cagney's been courting, witnessed the murder so the goons have snatched her.

Will the ever resourceful James Cagney will find a way to set all this right? You have to see the film to see if and how.

Cagney has Allen Jenkins along acting as Pancho to his Cisco Kid. Jenkins is funny, but you know Cagney only keeps him around for his amusement value. The plot calls for the pair to spend some time in the jail of the local town constable played by Spencer Charters who is also a dim bulb.

Fast paced {is their any other kind of Cagney film} action makes the 67 minute running time go by real fast. St. Louis Kid is very typical of the stuff Warner Brothers would continue to give Cagney throughout his years with them.

... because the first half has a hard time getting started. Ed Kennedy (James Cagney) and Buck (Allen Jenkins) are long haul truckers who get into trouble with fist-to-cuffs throughout their runs. Ed decides to stop this behavior, but out on a run a local girl runs into the back of their truck ( Patricia Ellis as Ann Reid) and claims it was all their fault. They get dragged to a local court but get out of their mess by talking up the virtue of the farmer and how he doesn't have a chance against the dairy cartels- Ed just read the local paper. The judge lets them go, impressed with their knowledge of local issues. But they are right back in it again when a real war starts between the dairy farmers in the same locality and truckers trying to bring low priced milk from other places into these areas.

There are just lots of fights and one-upmanship that isn't particularly funny and doesn't lead anywhere until Ed is framed for the murder of a farmer that Ann witnessed, and Ann is missing too, kidnapped by the gangland thugs who really committed the murder. At this point the suspense goes up and the film intensity level became more what I expect from a Cagney film. Had both halves been as good as the second half, I'd have given the whole thing a 7 or 8 out of 10.

Patricia Ellis just doesn't work for me as Cagney's love interest in this. I think WB was trying to build her up into being a new Joan Blondell type, but the character she is playing is just too unlikable and self righteous.

An interesting aside - Cagney was sick of being the guy who goes around punching people, so he had the makeup man wrap his hands in bandages, and in the opening scene tells Allen Jenkins he won't be punching people anymore. When a fight does break out, Cagney hits the other guy's head with his own head, and down they go. Cagney was just trying to vary the old punching formula, but director Ray Enright thought Cagney was trying to hurt his means of making a living and get him in trouble with Jack Warner.

In practically every Jimmy Cagney film of the early through mid 1930s, he plays a fast-talking lovable jerk. However, in this film, he is so obnoxious and so pugnacious that the character actually crosses an invisible line for me--to being unlikable and even ridiculous. This is saying a lot because I generally love Cagney films and will put up with a lot from his loud-mouthed characters! In this case, he plays a guy that seems to be in court ALL THE TIME for assault. His character makes Mike Tyson's out of the ring behaviors seem restrained--he's that quick to fight. In fact, in the first half hour, he goes from one jail to another in the space of a day--he's that out of control. As a result, I kept thinking to myself that sooner or later, this character MUST be sent to prison for "hard time" instead of bouncing in and out of jail again and again. Plus, even if he never got sent away for a long stretch in prison, he should be in debt for the next 600 years due to his getting fined almost every day for fighting.

All this fighting just defies common sense--as does his behaviors when trying to woo the lady who hates his guts. He's in jail in a small town and he waits until the jailer falls asleep and lets himself out of jail so he can stalk and annoy her! And, naturally being a Hollywood film, he DOES charm the lady with his relentless and obnoxious ways! This pushiness is NOT vintage Cagney, but once again a super-obnoxious and ridiculous character--the guy once again crosses the line.

The rest of the film does get better once you get to the final third, but by then I was so irritated with this film (in particular Cagney's character), that I just wanted it all to end. This has to be among the worst Cagney films I have seen despite the improvement towards the end.

St. Louis Kid, The (1934)

*** (out of 4)

Exciting Warner Bros. "ripped from the headlines" film has James Cagney playing a truck driver who gets involved in a battle between farmers and the businessmen who aren't paying enough for milk. This is a fast, fun and action packed film, which is what audiences expected from a Cagney film. Cagney is very good in the role of the fast talking, quick to throw punches truck driver and the supporting cast helps him well.

Jimmy the Gent (1934)

** (out of 4)

A crooked businessman (James Cagney) pretends to go straight to win back his ex (Bette Davis). Considering the two leads and director Michael Curtiz, this was a major disappointment that really didn't work on any level. The only real reason to watch this is the performance from Cagney as well as his shaved head. Davis is very boring throughout and really brings down the film because she has no chemistry with Cagney.

Jimmy Cagney plays a 'little tough guy' truck driver who is pulled into a dispute between farmers and a dairy syndicate. Great old WB social drama with a cast of solid character actors like Charles C. Wilson, Robert Barrat, Hobart Cavanagh, Addison Richards, Arthur Aylesworth, and the always terrific Allen Jenkins. Patricia Ellis is the girl who hates Cagney at first but comes around to loving him by the end of the picture. Cagney's the main reason to watch, of course, and he's loads of fun as the cocky, wise-cracking runt that's quick with his fists. It's a fast-paced and entertaining movie with a little bit of a then-topical message for flavor. If you're a fan of Cagney or these types of movies WB put out in the 1930s, you'll probably like this a lot.