Recensioni degli utenti

The first six episodes really seemed like they had promise. The show touches on many interesting ideas, but does not follow through on many (or most) of them.

The seventh episode was a waste of time that added nothing to the stories.

The eight episode is 40 minutes of a concert I didn't want to attend, then a nonsensical ending to a story that had built such complicated characters.

Very unsatisfying overall, but if you're going to try it, binge it. Not worth waiting week to week.

Complete first season dilutes the whole rating-system. The invidual episodes have higher ratings the rating all over.

Most tourists only see the Grand Canal, so great to see other parts of that Northern Laguna, passed so quickly from Venice airport to the Old City. Fraser, the adolescent is definitely a complete paradox of a young man, but it's great to see such complex character-molding, with so candid treatment of alternate sexuality and the way the community embraces it - or otherwise. The rest of the Screen-Making community could learn a thing or two from this candid filmography, literally by letting scenes "roll", showing things as they are, as opposed to what the directors want them to be. The guys in this are certainly coquettish, but that's because normal guys, in real life DO act in this manner. Objectified? - huh! Now just don't go and spoil things, HBO - since my "7" , like many others' praise here is provisional.

It's crude , it's raw but whatever it is it's beautiful . Its certainly not for the people who believe in the totality of things , or people who believe that every action is supposed to have a motive . This show is all about the confusion that our minds go through , it's all about those unbridled moments in life where you struggle to define yourself, your ideas and your identity . It's about celebrating the uncertainty of our beings and not giving up on finding our true essence . If you look closely you will find some fragment or the other of your life in the show giving you the assurance that whatever you face is not uncommon and it's certainly not bad . In the end , there are few seemingly bad things about the characters but isnt it the way people are ? Not good , not bad but grey . So watch it if you want to because the result is highly subjective and is extremely dependent on the way you perceive things because in this show there is no single definite reason and I believe that is how things really are . What's good to you might be bad to someone else & vice versa .

Guys, the directing of this show is amazing. And the soundtrack??????? GOD. I really liked it. Although i missed a defined plot for the first episode, we still got the chance to meet the characters from Fraser´s sight.

I watched the first episode and it made me cry. I love it. I learned something from it; about young people that are arriving to the world. And what I learned about them is making me hopeful. It also made me aware of my own age in a different more positive way. In a good way. I feel that I am not only starting to understand and love youth of today, but I am also starting to understand my own perspective, relation to them. I am old enough that they are not reminding me of my own young age so I am free from nostalgia. That feels good. I don't desire to be like them. I can not be. They are radically different and that difference is something unique that I can grasp and admire without feeling regret about it. I was never like them so I am free from bitterness and resentment about lost opportunity. That's truly liberating. I am starting to understand that youth never repeat itself. The way I was young 40 years ago has nothing to do with a way they are young today. And yet, as I am starting to grasp this difference across the generations I am also starting to understand value of where I am standing right now in my own life. Because although my youth is in the past, I am still alive. And as much as they are unique and precious in their age of becoming, I am also unique and precious in mine. No need for comparison, regret and for nostalgia. It is exactly in this unreconcilable difference between us where we can meet and learn from each other. Help one another. After all Luca Guadagino is around my age, and the way he can look at youth of today is exactly speaking about all this. I am grateful for his gaze. It help me see the truth of generations myself. It help me learn to live my life just a bit better. Maybe that's the beginning of some kind of wisdom that belong to my age. I hope it is.

And concerning supposed inaccuracy in the representation of the American army base. This is, luckily, not a documentary TV show about a life in US military base. And beside that, even if it would be, those who claim that they know it better, are misunderstanding the nature of artistic insight into the truth of a place. One can spend all of one's life in such an establishment and yet still not really know it. Accuracy of description is not guaranteeing depth of an insight. On the contrary, such an accuracy usually lead to some form of unwilling reiteration of common wisdom - pure propaganda. Because everything that is grasped on the surface is always already constructed by prefabricated social conventions. To go under it, means to brake rules of representation. That's how art is made.

Seems to be a lot of negative feedback due to the fact this isn't "what it's like to be on a foreign military base" from those who have experience first hand, which I guess we have to respect, however, it's just a tv show and not a one sided documentary, so why base judgement on that? Interesting story for the modern age, felt like a typical Guadagnino to me so enjoyed it quite a lot. From my perspective, people should chill out and not expect a real life 100% factual account of what life is actually like in such an environment, but that's just me. Thanks!

Only one episode in and I know We Are Who We Are will be a classic for years to come. With stunning cinematography and a score from Dev Haynes (or Blood Orange as many may know him), so far Jack Dylan Grazer shines as Fraser in an ethereally beautiful, Italian-set, indie slow burn. Classy, stunning and poinant. Coming-of-age has never been so raw and sultry.

Like all Luca Guadanino's work he does not infantilize youth... take a gander at this sensual peek into another world bristling with life 🙏🏻💕

Complex characters that feel very real in our modern world. I love the soundtrack (curated by blood orange) as well. Everything I'm looking for in a tv show.

I keep reading how "painfully real" this show is. It is painful, yes. There is little character development and the relationships (between mother and son and friends) are just weird and not based in reality. The entire character of Fraser is the worst. He comes off as flippant and annoying and it's a horribly acted character. I am not in the military, but it doesn't seem realistic to me. The dialogue, the characters and their interactions with each other just don't work and it comes off very uneven and hard to watch. It's disappointing because I think there is some real talent that is wasted.

It has only one episode so far, but u can see how original it can be. The directing is amazing, and contrary to what some people say. this first episode was to introduce the characters. Obviously there isn´t a stablished plot yet.

Very original. I like it. Can't wait for more episodes.

Either one I'll take it , I'm already hooked . The crazy relationship with Frazier and his mom , can't wait to see how that plays out . Is he goi g to go with soldier or fall in love with Caitlin, or Brittany u can tell he and caitlyn will become closer . Can't wait to see Cudi with his family , great talent just what we needed .

In true Luca fashion, the directing is amazing and the scenery is stunning.

The first episode follows Fraser (played by Jack Dylan Grazier) and his family moving into a US military base in Italy.

Fraser is a quirky, troubled teen who we get to learn a bit about. His interactions and journeys around the base and outside of it make him a loveable and curious character.

The soundtrack, like in Luca's Call Me By Your Name, is extremely brilliant.

While the episode doesn't seem to have any particular direction, once I finished it, I wanted to watch more. Can't wait for the rest of the series.

Mediocre drama, filmed in a slow indulgent disconnected dreamlike style, concerning non-binary teenager angst during coming of age.

The first series of 8 episodes has a poor ending, despite the apparent resolution.

Disciplined people or people who respect other people's property might loathe this stuff, because the protagonists appear to be feral, damaged and without respect for anyone or anything other than themselves and their whims.

Many of the adult characters are unsympathetic.

But behind this front are sensitive flakes trying to understand themselves and how they fit and how they relate to others, obsessing over intense relationships with their co-passengers. As an exploration of non binary folks it may help with understand these people.

If you have teenage children, you might recoil at many scenes, but in other scenes you may sympathize with the uncertainties, the ambiguities, the messiness and the insecurities that many people must navigate.

Made for HBO/Sky, it is an unusual choice for the BBC to make available in the UK during the Covid-19 lockdowns, possibly due to the lack of new content during the pandemic.

I love Frazier , Sam & Brittany so far my fave ..... but it's just one episode . Can't wait for Monday nights thank u Luca excellent job

This show is pretty good and hopefully has the potential to spiral into some sort of 'call me by your name' and 'euphoria' love-child that everyone online seems desperate for it to become. However, the real reason you should stay tuned is Chloe Sevigny. She's an icon and we as a society need to stop sleeping on her brilliance.

I have been waiting on this show for months , reading articles , looking at Instagram post trying to get a glimpse of the show , I would dread mondays now I don't . Acting superb , script great directing A+ I can't wait for episode 2

Older brothers don't typically include much-younger sisters in their escapades. Caitlyn hadn't even hit puberty, yet her brother and his enlisted friends fully accepted her into their circle ~ then allowed her to bring the odd little Fraser along. Maybe there was an explanation, but I must have missed it. Very unlikely circle of friends.

Having spent a part of my life in and out of an overseas military base with my partner I was thrilled to watch the story of a lesbian couple and their son on post. Alas nothing could be further from the truth. Such a high ranking officer would have not allowed this spoiled brat to behave so abusively. In fact MPs would have interfered the very instant he drank alcohol, and (unlike what is shown) soldiers and their kids alike are expected to behave even off post - if they don't there are consequences.

Besides this inconsistency, the plot simply sucks (or should I say does not even exist?), the acting of most people is rather poor, the music bad, the scenery uninteresting, and watching it simply a waste of time....