Aggiungi una trama nella tua linguaPart One: This 2-part series follows River Hagg as he travels to war-torn Syria, in hopes of documenting stories of the worst humanitarian crisis since WWII. He finds a medical unit of forei... Leggi tuttoPart One: This 2-part series follows River Hagg as he travels to war-torn Syria, in hopes of documenting stories of the worst humanitarian crisis since WWII. He finds a medical unit of foreign volunteers as they provide aid to civilians, YPG fighters and ISIS. Part two: The volun... Leggi tuttoPart One: This 2-part series follows River Hagg as he travels to war-torn Syria, in hopes of documenting stories of the worst humanitarian crisis since WWII. He finds a medical unit of foreign volunteers as they provide aid to civilians, YPG fighters and ISIS. Part two: The volunteers continue to push with the YPG to the ISIS defended city of Manbij, Syria. River hear... Leggi tutto
- Agir Servan
- (non citato nei titoli originali)
Recensioni in evidenza
The storyteller brought us in through his eyes and shared the story without blinders, but with the blinding truth. I will be forever changed by what I saw.
I am not sure how I feel about River Rainbow. Is he a hero for developing this project, for the work he did, for the lives he saved? Or is he a jerk for leaving his family, his long suffering wife, and his babies, forcing them to fend for themselves while he chased his dream? I figure he's a little of both. In the end, this documentary is jaw dropping and awe inspiring. It's a must-see. A must-talk-about- afterwards. A piece of work that makes you realize how shameful complaining about the traffic is or how cool it is to have the new $1000 iPhone. Watch this documentary, and let it sink into your bones. The feeling won't soon go away, and truthfully, it shouldn't.
Well done, sir. Well done.
Screenplay...................................... 3 / 10 Interviews........................................ 2 Visuals................................................ 7 Sound................................................... 3 Editing................................................ 2 Music....................................................... 1 Timeless Utility................................. 6 Total.................................................... 24 / 70 ~= 3.4 (which I rounded to 3) Verdict................................................. Avoid.
There's something unusually raw and immediate about the real-life battle sequences. Probably because the fighters depicted are not regular US military, and don't have the same training and mannerisms.
They can be joking around while bullets are wizzing over their heads. Everything is improvised; the usual military structure is absent. If comrades get in trouble, they have to make their own ethical decisions about risking their lives to rescue them. No commander is there to give them orders. It humanizes them more completely and raises the stakes when you realize that any one of them can be dead at any time.
We don't get a lot of context, though. Some other Americans appear, as fighters, not medics, but they don't seem to be part of the US military, which does have a presence in the region.
Do these people ever coordinate or communicate with the US military? Are the Westerners breaking their countries' laws to be there? If they get in trouble, can they call their embassy for help? (Which becomes a germane question near the end of the story.)
Note that since this documentary was made, in 2017, the Kurds have been very successful, and ISIS has been driven into a few remnant pockets. Given recent developments in Syria, a follow up documentary would be valuable.
It's taken me this long to watch it simply because it's hard to find, but it's on Kanopy now (free/ad free, you just need a library card.)
Lo sapevi?
- QuizRicky Schroder and River O'Mahoney Hagg met and traveled together to Afghanistan to film and produce the Documentary series, The Fighting Season.
- Citazioni
River O'Mahoney Hagg: Seeing little kids get hurt, there's nothing worse than that. It's so tragic and ISIS doesn't give a f*ck who they hurt"
I più visti
Dettagli
- Colore