VALUTAZIONE IMDb
5,7/10
2996
LA TUA VALUTAZIONE
Un giovane afro-americano che vive a Chicago entra in un nuovo e seducente mondo fatto di denaro e potere dopo essere stato assunto come autista per un uomo d'affari benestante.Un giovane afro-americano che vive a Chicago entra in un nuovo e seducente mondo fatto di denaro e potere dopo essere stato assunto come autista per un uomo d'affari benestante.Un giovane afro-americano che vive a Chicago entra in un nuovo e seducente mondo fatto di denaro e potere dopo essere stato assunto come autista per un uomo d'affari benestante.
- Regia
- Sceneggiatura
- Star
- Premi
- 4 vittorie e 7 candidature totali
Aaron Moten
- Tony
- (as Aaron Clifton Moten)
Stephen McKinley Henderson
- Mr. Green
- (as Stephen Henderson)
Alan B. Jones
- Detective Calhoun
- (as Alan Bomar Jones)
Recensioni in evidenza
I don't usually write reviews, but since I did not find any sound review here, here it is.
The movie builds up great, great character development, good acting, intriguing plot; and then the third act begins, and it's all downhill from there. All buildup and character development stare into abyss upon an obvious climax. The realism that was there in the first two acts dies in the third act, and questionable choices are made in the plot, which makes you doubt whether there are different writing teams for Native Son. P.S I haven't read the book.
I think this will suffice.
McCarthyism drove Richard Wright away from his land ;he sought refuge in France where his novels were already famous ;so the first adaptation (by himself) was filmed in Argentina by French Pierre Chenal ,a film noir past master ; a colossal mistake was to have the writer play the part of Bigger (25) when he was in his forties; in spite of that ,the film is estimable.
A MTV work followed,in the eighties ,starring Victor Love ,Matt Dillon and Elizabeth McGovern was also interesting :were it for the faithfullness to the novel and good acting , it is to recommend.
The same cannot be said of this third adaptation , transferred to the modern era -which is highly debatable- : the boiler,to name but one detail ,becomes ridiculous in a wealthy family's house .Acting is undistinguished ,the script written in a slapdash manner,and the novel sweeetened ,cheapened and botched : the girlfriend's fate for instance ; the Bigger/Jan relationship is hardly skimmed over ; one never feels that the unfortunate hero knows that his fight is already lost ,and that his boss' patronizing and the rich kids ' social activism will always leave him a chauffeur , a flunkey ; the beginning is a mess, the ending takes the easy way out .Bigger 's frames of mind voice over are not enough to do the powerful novel justice.
A MTV work followed,in the eighties ,starring Victor Love ,Matt Dillon and Elizabeth McGovern was also interesting :were it for the faithfullness to the novel and good acting , it is to recommend.
The same cannot be said of this third adaptation , transferred to the modern era -which is highly debatable- : the boiler,to name but one detail ,becomes ridiculous in a wealthy family's house .Acting is undistinguished ,the script written in a slapdash manner,and the novel sweeetened ,cheapened and botched : the girlfriend's fate for instance ; the Bigger/Jan relationship is hardly skimmed over ; one never feels that the unfortunate hero knows that his fight is already lost ,and that his boss' patronizing and the rich kids ' social activism will always leave him a chauffeur , a flunkey ; the beginning is a mess, the ending takes the easy way out .Bigger 's frames of mind voice over are not enough to do the powerful novel justice.
Read the book a long time ago. Still have it. Watched the movie and it started off following the novel by Robin Wright fairly well.
I don't believe a movie adaptation of a novel has to follow the story line and it can be more interesting to have some twists or re-telling of the story. In this case I would say it is a re-telling but the one let down for me is the buildup to the ending.
It felt like it was rushed and they did not have the time or the budget to provide the finer details of the story to explain the heart of the original story of why the title "Native Son" applied so well to Big and his part to society.
An incredible cast and I enjoyed everyone's acting. Most of the camerawork was great in my opinion. Felt like it did update the story for our present time. Wished there was more reference to slum lords and the legal system.
For folks that have not read the book, I hope it inspires them to read it. I know I will be re-reading the story again.
I don't believe a movie adaptation of a novel has to follow the story line and it can be more interesting to have some twists or re-telling of the story. In this case I would say it is a re-telling but the one let down for me is the buildup to the ending.
It felt like it was rushed and they did not have the time or the budget to provide the finer details of the story to explain the heart of the original story of why the title "Native Son" applied so well to Big and his part to society.
An incredible cast and I enjoyed everyone's acting. Most of the camerawork was great in my opinion. Felt like it did update the story for our present time. Wished there was more reference to slum lords and the legal system.
For folks that have not read the book, I hope it inspires them to read it. I know I will be re-reading the story again.
Native Son had the makings of a great film - setting, cinematography, cast, story... the plot builds, the characters are developed, and then - a sudden tragedy after which it felt like someone pulled the plug on the film.
Was it a lack of innovation with the screenplay? Was the film's budget exceeded?
Such a shame to develop a main character to this degree, and then basically shut the movie down.
Was it a lack of innovation with the screenplay? Was the film's budget exceeded?
Such a shame to develop a main character to this degree, and then basically shut the movie down.
Quality acting, especially by our lead. The story alone garners it 5 stars...while the acting and directing does the rest. I enjoyed it and was hurt by it, while also being pulled on what character to route for...
Lo sapevi?
- QuizAdapted from Richard Wright's novel of the same name.
- ConnessioniRemake of Native Son (1951)
I più visti
Accedi per valutare e creare un elenco di titoli salvati per ottenere consigli personalizzati
- How long is Native Son?Powered by Alexa
Dettagli
- Data di uscita
- Paese di origine
- Lingua
- Celebre anche come
- Vatan Evladı
- Luoghi delle riprese
- Aziende produttrici
- Vedi altri crediti dell’azienda su IMDbPro
- Tempo di esecuzione1 ora 44 minuti
- Colore
- Proporzioni
- 2.39 : 1
Contribuisci a questa pagina
Suggerisci una modifica o aggiungi i contenuti mancanti