Strong Island

Firstly, I don't in any way purport to be a film reviewer - that said after watching this excellent film I was already feeling compelled to lodge a review for it - this was further amplified when I saw what I believe are extremely unfair negative reviews featuring prominently - and my strong suspicion is that these reviews are motivated by racism, hatred and complete ignorance. And I say this as a white middle aged man, who lives outside America but there is no way a fair minded person could watch this wonderful film and give it 1-4 stars - they've a clear axe to grind. e.g one of the reviews almost IMMEDIATELY flagging that the film maker is a transgender.....what does that have to do with ANYTHING?

The films arc is somewhat unconventional in that it focuses heavily on pulling the viewer inside the family - showing you who they were, how they came to be, what they went through to get where they were etc etc. It humanises them and allows them to be seen as vulnerable, imperfect people like the rest of us. I find it very odd that people see this as too slow paced or boring - I'm no soft touch but even I was moved and affected by the way this mosiac was painted.

The structure of the story telling sometimes seems a tad convoluted as it moves back and forth perhaps not giving as much info as one would like but it works well in the end. I'm again shocked some reviews feel the interviewees were acting (incredibly insulting - if anything I felt is was clearly raw emotional and absolutely genuine), the facial closeups are because the entire film is about the effect of the tragic loss of William on their family - nothing shows this more affectingly than the faces of the people closest to it. And finally that people had the poor judgement to accuse the interviewees of racist tones etc - is just outrageous & sadly like most of such comments far more telling about those who wrote them. I found the poise & balance in the story telling & interviewees pretty amazing given the events that occurred on top of what I am sure I can't really even slightly empathise with - that is being a person of colour in a deeply racist country.

Although it'd have been easy to give it a 10 to 'balance out' what I feel are stupidly low scores motivated by numerous hatreds, I've tried to be true and given it an 8. I agree the editing isn't as good as it could be in a few minor spots, I found the very upbeat closing credit music choice quite jarring given the rather somber conclusion (though felt it might have had personal relevance to the maker/family) and agree that a bit more Errol Morris type expert interviews on the self defence laws, interpretation of the autopsy etc would have been a terrific counter to the phenomenal emotional depth of the film.

I won't include any spoilers but it truly is a superb film - I watch a lot of feature docus and whilst i wouldn't say this is the best I've seen it's several hours very well invested if you're open to empathising with others and can put prejudices and preconceptions aside (which I believe several other reviewers clearly have not been able to do). I'm shocked it's currently only got a ~6.5 rating....it's a 8-9 IMHO and my wife felt the same way. I hope to see more from the filmmaker in the future and thank him for sharing this deeply personal story with the world - I believe it's important and extremely thought provoking both socially and as a person.

Moving and incredibly honest portrayal of The Ford family's tragedies resulting from racial segregation. Some questions left unanswered: Who was Lesline and did the family get the car back.

Any mother raising sons prays to get through that difficult period from 14 or 15 to full maturity. This exemplar American family almost made it.

But local corruption put a monster in its path: the corrupt Datre family, and the cops they owned. How could a grand jury not return a true bill for mot murder but manslaughter if the fix was not in or the jury was not dominated by racists?

Why should one stupid outburst of anger negate justice for a young man who risked his life to apprehend a mugger? Was this testimony included about William's last day?

Very thought provoking.

Unfortunately this was painted to be a compelling story of mis-justice that was then solved or at least contested but it was nothing more than a diary or almost autobiography of someone we'd never heard of. The constant reference to Racism in the families past was almost building up to some sort of mis-justice due to race or color but that didn't seem to be the case. There was parts talking about the struggle of coming to terms with sexuality and growing up which seemed completely irrelevant to the confusing story line that zigzagged at the speed of a snail. Don't get my wrong its a sad story, no one should be murdered and no one should have to deal with a death in family but I just couldn't help but feel this documentary was almost the director/producers way of dealing with it rather than it shedding any light on a given subject. This was almost a professionally shot YouTube video certainly not fit for mainstream Netflix.

I fail to understand any reviewers who did not / could not appreciate this brilliant docu. Incredibly shot and edited. The quietness is especially compelling. The photographs contributed to the cinematic value. I struggle to understand how other reviewers wanted this story to be something else when this is the family's story. It is their lived experience. Congrats to Yancy for their achievements.

A Oscar nominated documentary from 2017. It entails the trek to Long Island by the Fords, an African American family & how during their stay, the elder son tragically lost his life during a verbal altercation w/a white individual. One night out, the son was driving his vehicle when a tow truck, w/its lights out, collided w/him prompting the owner to offer his body shop's services to make repairs. As weeks drove on & hostilities began to surface, the son made an ill-timed decision to confront the owner of the repair establishment leading to one of the employees to pull out .22 rifle & fire, killing the son instantly. We follow Yance Ford's journey in trying to glean some meaning by her brother's death especially from all accounts he was a thoughtful & respected man even intervening in another occasion apprehending a person who was the perpetrator of a shooting. The subject matter is heart wrenching but ultimately I have to judge the film by its construction & not by its importance which I think is evidenced by the unusual decision to begin a recap of a particular event near the doc's last 15 minutes making the film feel like its spinning its wheels as it were but if one can overlook this lapse in presentation then this potent story is another all too familiar modern discourse of our current racial polemics.