Everyones_A_Critic

As much as my wife and I were looking forward to the recent release of "The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe," I very disappointed with the movie, even judging it on its own merits and not comparing it to the book or previous movies. However, as primitive as the 1998 movie version of this book was, it far exceeded "The Chronicles of Narnia" in so many ways. In this movie, the casting was horrible, the dialog was terrible and emotionless (especially Tumnus – James McAvoy), the actors unattractive (Tilda Swinton and Georgie Henley), and most importantly, the Andrew Adamson (director) didn't capture the essence of the C.S. Lewis book. There was too much focus on Mrs. MacReady (minor character) and not enough focus on the Professor. The audio of the special effect characters, such as Aslan, Beavers, and Fox, was too close to the audience and not in place with the setting of the scene.

I would have given the movie 1 of 5 stars had it not been for the special effects, which were truly amazing. Talking animals, flying beasts, hybrid goons, and a fantastic battle scene added to the excitement of the moment and I temporarily forgot how awful the rest of it was.

The movie ending doesn't allow for a smooth continuation, and I seriously doubt they'll get the funding to do a sequel. Overall, 2 of 10.

One of the many reasons I appreciated this movie was because it spoke of a certain truth behind the Israeli government; namely, their unique and authentic desire to protect and live side-by-side with their Arab neighbors. Although there may be army generals who could have allowed the explosion under the Dome of the Rock to take place, they no doubt would expect a massive retaliatory attack on Israel by surrounding countries resulting in instability in the region. Political and religious suicide, to be exact. However, I felt that the film depicted the soldiers acting collectively and selflessly to prevent such a tragedy to occur because their job is to protect and defend the Land of Israel, its landmarks, and citizens, including Arab-Israeli citizens.

The under ground activity is very symbolic of the underground politics of the Israel government in its efforts to deal with the political situation of the region. Like the US, there are many times civilian lives have been spared and the heroes are never known nor are the events made public.

It's hard to identify the protagonist, although Menachem is most likely the closest candidate. Depending on who is viewing the film, he may be seen as friend or foe.

The movie plot suffered slightly due to the intermediate love (lust) story involving Pini. Audiences have enough trouble keeping up with their own relationships, it's not necessary to drag them into a failure from the beginning.

Editing and lighting techniques were overlooked but forgiven because the film was shot mostly outdoors. Overall, a very well-done film and deserves 8 of 10 stars.