Murder Most Puzzling

The show is well cast and beautifully acted out by Logan who seems to be really enjoying the role and the supportingcast fit the bill perfectly.

It fits perfectly in the familiar cosy crime genre as they call it but has enough madcap moments and some humor to keep the audience engaged.

Thoroughly enjoyed it and looking forward to the next couple of episodes and hopefully more seasons. If one episode takes care of one book then I definitely want to see all twenty books played out as it will only get better from here as the characters grow and the puzzles progress.

A definite must watch and can't wait until next weeks episode.

The writing is just not there. I am always happy when finding series of this type, crime solving with a light heart and elements of humor makes my heart sing after I got tired of so many years of twisted plots or real life crime, these days I want light and funny, so this, especially lead by Phyllis Logan whom I love dearly, I was really looking forward to. The idea is great, the cast, or most of them at least, is great, but when the writing sticks to strict on stereotyped characters that keep falling into the same actions.... well, it REALLY, really gets on my nerves. I enjoyed the 1st episode even though it was obvious that it was falling on stereotypes, like for example the policeman reminded me of Father Brown one, sooooooo many episodes (series even!) kept repeating the same lines, same attitude..... now watching the second episode I had to stop in the first quarter of it...frustrating, so much that it makes Phyllis Logan's character irritating.... oh well.... maybe the writers will modify and not let them fall into the irritating mode they are at the moment, hope is the last thing we loose, someone said but, like another reviewer said, please PRETTY PLEASE, get Phyllis Logan a role at the level of her marvellous talent.

This isn't a "Grace" or a "Vera" series, but it's not as bad as "Death Valley", the recent detective series that starred Timothy Spall. Detective series are very popular right now, but there is a huge difference in quality. "Murder Most Puzzling" isn't the bottom of the heap, but it's not far from it.

Phyllis Logan is a good actress (Mrs. Hughes from "Downton Abbey"), but older actors and actresses are looking for a "Vera" series and the quality depends on the script and this script needs a lot of work. A crime drama can include comedic elements but the writers here don't know what it is. If there is a second series it needs a better script that is focused and less comedic.

Not by any means the worst thing I've ever seen & I get it's not meant to be too serious but the pretence of a crossword puzzler solving crime is just too far fetched. Phyllis Logan as always is excellent but the basic premise of this show is lame. I tried to stick it out but boredom set in just before halfway & I switched off I no longer cared what she did. A good lead can't really lift a show if the writing & plots are poor. Tho not at the stinkbomb level of Sister Boniface & Death Valley it lacks credibility. Can't see another series of this being commissioned but please find Phyllis Logan something better to do she's wasted in this.

I enjoyed it. Cozy mysteries are meant to be low stress, easy to watch and the type of show you can be doing something else while watching. This show fits the bill. I did not think anyone was overacting. I am not sure why some people said that. I am American and only really knew Phyllis Logan, so maybe that helped. I just finished Death Valley, which is the same genre and I quite enjoyed that one as well. I am not sure why so many reviewers are being so hard on this one. There are different levels of cozy mysteries. Ludwig is not like this one, you need to really pay attention with that type, which has multiple levels going on. I watch a lot of those too.

If you are a fan of this genre, watch it and decide for yourself.