Utopia

This is the first review I have ever written. Like with a lot of movies that move me, I go back to IMDb after its over, and think of writing a review. And then I think pff it's late, it'll take too long. I'm tired. etc.

but when i fell upon a couple negative reviews after watching this film, thought i'd try and set the record straight.

This is a very good documentary. not because of how it's filmed, or edited or whatever, it's simply about the subject. It's deep. It's moving. And once it's over, it sticks with you for a while. You know that effect, like your left in some aftermath of a shocking event.

The negative reviews say its one-sided. A lot of documentary's are biased anyway, when you think about it, just trying their best to get their point across. And if this one is, it doesn't matter 'cos we clearly don't hear enough about the sufferings and struggles of the aboriginal community, and you can't deny them. Maybe the Australian "white man" was demonised, maybe things were slightly inflated to fit the purpose. Don't care. You need to hear this stuff. Everyone needs to hear this stuff. Take it with a pinch of salt if you want, but watch it.

ps just read Jesse Boland's review (above). way better than mines and on point.

The treatment of Australian aborigines was indeed shocking but this film is so biased, one-sided and dishonest that it does not help their cause one bit. Pilger ignores the fact that since the late 1960's (at least) successive governments have made strenuous efforts to make reparations. He blames the mining industry but some Aboriginal groups get a substantial income out of leasing land to mining companies and that the mining companies do employ Aboriginals. There are some successful Aboriginals. Pilger does not interview a single one. Why not? Pilger ignores the terrible problems caused by drink and levels of violence. It is worth noting that Pilger has not lived in Australia for decades but prefers to fly in every so often, criticise the country of his birth and then fly out again.

Deceptive journalism at its best. A thoroughly one sided and repetitive film. John Pilger is a self righteous git who edits facts, interviews and footage to suit his point of view.

Cheap tricks like adding foreboding music and dark shaky film effects are used to accompany many shots featuring the Australian army, police, government and other opposing parties.

Token attempts to appear unbiased by allowing people to explain their actions regarding the aboriginal people are few and often cut short.

Yes the aboriginal people have suffered many injustices over the years and more needs to be done, but Pilger paints a picture of a demonic race of white Australians mercilessly eradicating the entirely innocent indigenous population. The whole film is focused on blame and not once does he show or mention anything positive that the Australian government is doing or has ever done to help.

I feel less intelligent having seen this film, it seems like John Pilger has taken many a leaf from 'A Current affair' and 'Today tonight'. Incitive rubbish. Do not waste your time.

As an Australian, I fully acknowledge and support the content of this hard-to-watch documentary. This is not 'news' to anyone in Australia who watches our shameful history regarding indigenous peoples.

John Pilger is a highly acclaimed award winning Australian journalist who throughout his lifetime has contributed to humanity by calling the truth - http://johnpilger.com/biography.

One reviewer criticizes him for not having lived in Australia for decades. The truth is the truth, no matter where you live in our global village. I would like to correct some content in one of the reviews here, which is otherwise a very thoughtful and intelligent review. 'The first thing shown to you is a 70's era anchorman talking about the plan of sitting ministers to simply round up people for no reason, and move them away, then taint their drinking water to sterilize them in a "Humane" manner'. This man was not an anchorman. At that time, he was by far the richest 'self-made' man in Australia. His name is Lang Hancock, a Western Australian iron-ore mining magnate (1909-1992). His daughter, Gina Reinhart (1954-present), is heir to his fortune and is one of the four richest women in the world. As an Australian I am utterly ashamed and disgusted by Hancock's sickening view and he did not speak back then for all Australians, although many Australians still wish the 'aboriginal problem' would 'just go away'!

Another reviewer suggests that Pilger's report is biased and one-sided. Of course, we do not need to 'fix what is not broken' so Pilger's film explores the underbelly of racism and genocide...... the 'positive' things can readily be found if one cares to look.

Journalists such as Pilger shine the light in the darkest of places across the world - where most don't dare go. He is not frightened by power and people often, if indeed they even bother to access such documentaries, feel very uncomfortable and challenged about their own view of our world. This then, surely, is a vehicle for inspection and change.

The recently fire that engulfed Australia's Outback led me to watch a documentary that shows what sorts of historical policies led to the inferno. John Pilger has spent his life exposing the lies behind right-wing propaganda. As an Australian, he has often emphasized his government's treatment of the country's indigenous population. His "Utopia" shows that apartheid, long since abolished in South Africa, is alive and well in Australia (if not on paper). The Aborigines live in conditions that practically make Australia an advanced Third World country. Most white Australians remain disgustingly unaware of their country's centuries-long treatment of the Aborigines. In fact, when Pilger asks several people at an Australia Day celebration about the genocide against the indigenous population, the attendees spout vague platitudes about how "we're all Aussies". Meanwhile, most of the Aborigines don't get to experience the country's quality health care system.

The same stories apply to the United States, Canada and New Zealand (all of which reduced their indigenous populations to minorities in their own lands). But if Pilger's documentary is any indication, Australia is the worst offender. Indeed, it's on the UN's shame list, both for its treatment of the Aborigines, but also for failing to eliminate certain preventable diseases that even Sri Lanka has eliminated!

Basically, anyone who wants to learn Australia's true history should see this documentary. Certainly every Australian should. There's a straight line from the genocide against the Aborigines to the fire that engulfed the country.