Death Valley

As with a few others, after 10 minutes of viewing the first episode, I almost switched off. Found it cringeworthy and struggled with some overacting. However, I persevered and am so pleased I did! Really enjoyed this once the characters started to develop. It's not meant to be true to life - hence its endearing quirky nature. Timothy Spall plays a great part as John Chapel and I warmed to the character, Janie. There are some great one liners that had me laughing out loud - especially from Janie's boss Steffan Rhodri who is so funny!

And the beautiful scenery of Wales is an added bonus!

Really hoping there's going to be a second series.

Timothy Spall as always is excellent but based on the first episode I found it very disappointing. It is advertised as a comedy drama but I felt more effort was put into the comedy than the drama. It did make me chuckle a few times but I was hoping it would be a drama with a slight comedic touch. What I struggle with most was trying to cram the story it into one episode. We seemed to jump from puzzling over a few random clues to all of a sudden having a Death in Paradise type ending where everyone was gathered together and the big rather complex reveal was made with no explanation as to how they got there.

I will give episode two a try but not hopeful I'm afraid.

Edit. Well I gave episode two a try and enjoyed it more, by the time I watched all of season one I had changed my mind and now look forward to season 2.

As others here have pointed out, she's a thoroughly off-putting character. And not even in a convincing or consistent way. At the start of episode 1, she's so thrilled to see Timothy Spall, as a TV detective-show star she idolizes, that she acts like a breathless schoolgirl fan (though she's supposed to be a cop). Yet just minutes after pushing her way into his home and chatting with him, she's inexplicably treating him with disdain and is impatient to leave. A couple of scenes later, talking with him in a coffee shop, she begins helping herself to chunks of his brownie... and apparently we're supposed to find this hilarious. I did not. And that's as far as I got.

I don't understand people giving ratings of 1 for this. They must be very serious people because for me it's amongst the funniest detective shows that I've seen. The writing is excellent and it delivers exactly what it's meant to deliver. Not highly original but more enjoyable to watch than most in this genre. Timothy Spall is always excellent and Gwyneth Keyworth, while not the most convincing detective, is brilliant. It definitely doesn't take itself seriously, even slightly. If you're looking for authenticity and grittiness in your detective shows you'll hate this. I feel that you can have too much grittiness.

This show is great fun and a new spin on murder mystery show. I loved the relationship between Timothy Spall's character and Gwyneth Keyworth's character. I've always loved these two actors and they work so well together. Lovely setting in Wales and lots of other good actors. Murder mystery with some comedy. I binged watched in two days. I hope they make more! Just give this show a chance. If you like Death in Paradise, and Midsomer Murders, I am sure you will enjoy this. I also loved the Welsh accents and when some characters spoke in Welsh. The relationship between Gwyneth Keyworth and her mum is great too.