उपयोगकर्ता समीक्षाएं

"Anuja" is a short film that, even with its brief 23 minutes, manages to leave a deep mark. It doesn't rely on big speeches or melodrama to make an impact; it trusts the strength of its simple narrative and the authenticity of the emotions it carries. What makes it so powerful is precisely that simplicity: by focusing on the relationship between two orphaned sisters working in a garment factory, it creates an intimate, honest portrait of the fight for survival in a world where childhood is a luxury few can afford.

The film's biggest strength lies in how it builds the bond between Anuja (Sajda Pathan) and Palak (Ananya Shanbhag). Their dynamic feels genuine, full of small gestures that reveal the affection and deep connection they share, even in the face of adversity. It's in the little things-the joy of sharing a jalebi, the excitement when talking about movies, the quiet care woven into the harsh routine of the factory-that the story gains depth. Their relationship isn't idealized; it's raw, real, built on sacrifices and tough choices, which makes the drama hit even harder. Pathan and Shanbhag's performances are stunning, especially considering they come from outside the professional acting world. They carry the film with a natural ease that avoids the trap of over-rehearsed performances, making the pain and hope of their characters feel almost tangible.

Narratively, "Anuja" makes an interesting choice by focusing more on the protagonist's internal conflict rather than on big external confrontations. The factory supervisor, while clearly an antagonist, isn't portrayed as a caricature. He's less of a standalone villain and more of a symbol of a system that keeps the cycle of poverty and exploitation going. The real struggle is inside Anuja's mind: choosing between an uncertain future full of possibilities or the fragile security of the present, where she can stay close to her sister. The film never forces an answer on the viewer, which is one of its greatest strengths. The open ending isn't lazy storytelling; on the contrary, it forces the audience to carry that choice with them, reflecting on the weight of decisions that many children are forced to make every day.

Visually, the film embraces a restrained, almost documentary-like aesthetic. The camera stays close, with minimal movement and simple compositions, which reinforces the intimate tone. The color palette is muted, reflecting the oppressive environment of the factory, but there are moments when the warmth of natural light-like in outdoor scenes or when the sisters share small moments of joy-hints at a spark of hope amid the harshness of daily life. This minimalist approach keeps the film from slipping into visual sensationalism that could undercut the story's emotional weight. The realism is there to serve the narrative, not to glamorize the suffering.

What also stands out is how the script handles the theme of child labor. "Anuja" isn't a film trying to deliver an obvious moral lesson or offer simplistic solutions to a complex problem. It shows, without filters, how the system fails these children-but it does so through their lived experience, not from some distant, condescending viewpoint. The specific focus-the tension between the right to education and the need to work-is universal, but it never feels generic. Every decision, every line of dialogue feels grounded in the concrete reality of these characters, making the story both specific and universally relatable.

Ultimately, there's something profoundly human in how the film deals with the idea of hope. Instead of presenting it as some abstract concept or an easy reward, "Anuja" shows hope as a difficult choice, one that demands courage and, often, sacrifice. It's a film that embodies the kind of cinema that understands emotional impact doesn't come from grand gestures, but from the honesty with which a story is told. That said, "Anuja" is a reminder that cinema can be powerful even when it whispers-and that sometimes, the smallest films carry the loudest voices.

The short film seems even shorter than it is, because it is so breathtaking. The girls are adorable and their life situation heartfelt. I needed to see this, this part of the world is not unknown to me, but it isn't easy to visualise and understand it. Not even sure I ever really can? It shows true love between sisters and their happiness, while working and living in low standard jobs and housing.

The opportunity offered to the youngest, to step out of her current situation might seem logical to every adult, but it isn't for the young child. Influenced by her employer and the love for her sister makes her decision to leave not easy.

The cliffhangers in the end of the film are necessary, but tough to handle. I want to know what will happen to both the sisters, but I will have ot imagine it for myself. And that power. That makes this movie impact the one who is watching. We have to know, we have to understand, and that is something we have to do by watching actively, and contemplate by ourselves. Dive into the mind of the orphin, what will she do?

A comparably shorter review should suffice for this extremely well made short film of 20 minutes or so. It transmits its message with amazing artistic clarity and leaves a strong impact on the audience through the sheer simplicity of its narrative. It has an authentic feel and vibe to it. Go ahead and watch it.

The plot is fairly simple. Anuja is a nine year old girl from the slums who works in a garment factory along with her elder sister. They share an affectionate bond and seek happiness from small things of everyday life. Watch them eating sweets or watching a movie over popcorn. Anuja is good in maths and her factory manager offers her a better paying position in his office. At around the same time the local school teacher asks her to join school. She has to now choose money through employment or education through school. A tough choice for her to make.

Everything about this movie is first rate without doubt and no surprises if it picks up the Oscar next month.

Road to the Oscars 2025: this is nominated in 1 category best short film.

Anuja was a charming look into a sad truth. Knowing that this is real and that a foundation that helps people like Anuja exist makes you think about how our world is designed. Nonetheless we get a charming little slice of life movie with a great ending.

2 sisters who lost their parents work at a bag factory. One of the sisters are given the opportunity to start in school for only 400 rupees. The sisters try to get the money.

I really liked the cute and believable sisterhood in this movie. Anuja and Palak act believable for their age and their relation and that helps the movie a lot. This is also just a well-made film through and through.

This is a hard truth movie. While it is packed with optimism as you kind of have to in a situation like this, it is hard to think that this is something that happens every day.

I really liked the open ended ending of this movie. Really showing the complexity of the situation the sisters are in. This is not just a moral easy question, it´s hard because you know what the cost is for all the lives involved and if that is something that happens every day it´s hard.

Overall I was charmed by this short. It´s well made and good. It is the most clean Oscar film I have watched so far, but somehow that works for it. It´s nothing insane or special, just competent.

Oscar Predictions: Political undertones, check. When it comes to the academy they like to make a political statement with their choice sometimes and in this case this check a box, but shorts like "A lien"(2022) and "I´m not a robot"(2023) dies the same with a more pro what we want in America angel. This is the winner so far to me. The most clean of the short, pure Oscar bait but it works and it´s good. I root for this!

I heard that a short film from India made the final nominations for oscars 2025 so I had to give it a try and after watching I don't know what to say I just gave an 8 just cause of the topic of the movie and it's post credit scene I mean the makers presented nothing new they just showed the reality on the big screen The ending was open ended which I liked it was like saying whatever she chooses it is going to be a wrong decision good creative choice

FAVOURITE CHARACTER :: elder sister her struggles were touching FAVOURITE MOMENT :: Anuja asking her sister in the middle of the night will he come with her.

Has it got a good message? Yeah, kind of. Does it move me to act upon it? Not really. The movie is powerful for a 23-minute runtime, but it is not powerful enough to stir me. It is rather minimal and pretty in its own little way, but nothing honestly stood out to me about the work. It ends posing a dilemma-a rather huge one at that-but the rest of it? Bland. At least to me it was.

The acting is pretty fine. The characters portrayed have some depth. The screenplay is quite intelligent, to which the shots do sufficient justice. It wouldn't be a "10/10 I recommend," but one could give it a chance.

An exceptional short that focuses on child labour in India. The writing was so good from the starting point until the last shot. The ending is left for us to choose what Anuja should do. Obviously she should go attend that exam. That moment could be life changing.

This short also depicts sisterhood, moral agency and difficult choices born of poverty.

The Cinematography of this short creates a very authentic visual that is raw and natural. Kudos to Akash Raje.

The acting performances were top-notch. Sajda Pathan was outstanding. A real-life former child laborer discovered by the Salaam Baalak Trust. Huge respect. Ananya Shanbhag was amazing too. A real-life factory worker. Huge respect to her too.

Excellent short but the ending could have been straight forward though so that many people get motivated from it.

No story. No content.

Writer & Director Adam Graves has done a cheap impression of Slumdog Millionaire (2008).

This film is just an another attempt to portray India's poverty in the west and win some brownies in the form of awards!

An extremely insincere, phoney and hollow attempt at filmmaking.

The two kids (Sajda Parhan and Ananya Shanbag) have acted well.

Everything else is crap ridden with clichés, tropes and stereotyping.

Btw which theater in India screens a film like Naya Daur (1957) these days? The film maker is so out of touch with modern India!

The film looks like a propaganda film for Salaam Baalak Trust.

Don't fall the publicity rhetoric. The film is not worth your time!

How did it even make it to the Oscars? I wonder!

I think it's important that people from the west see movies or stories like this. Not to feel sorry or superior but It gives a better understanding of the life of poor people in India. For many people here in the west it's very hard to understand why the people are in a situation like this and stories like this help to get an idea of true life India and how hard it can be for the not fortunate ones. Helping the poor in India might increase if more people with money and a conscience would understand. Thank you for this movie and your awesome work. All the best to the organisation and its protégés!

This short story revolves around two young girls who stay in Indian slums and try to earn their livelihood by working in cloth factories. They try to fight out of this poverty by choosing between education and food (an unfortunate choice that millions face in India) but are confused in this game of instant gratification that penalizes short-term hunger over long-term hunger and poverty.

I expected the movie to have a storyline, either inspiring or sad. But it does not have a close-ended storyline, neither joyous nor sad. It just en-cashes the problems of India, and the producers (big-name producers like Guneet Monga and Priyanka Chopra Jonas) just showcase a short "day-in-the-life" video in a desperate attempt to win some awards.

Anuja has been attracting a lot of attention recently due to its Oscar shortlisting and Priyanka Chopra's fame. As expected, it's a heart-wrenching story that reflects the struggle of a 9-year-old girl who is not even mature enough to make those choices. Perhaps that uncertainty is what makes it special.

The short film tells the story of a nine-year-old girl, Anuja (Sajda Pathan), who works in a factory. When questioned about her age by a school teacher who wants to take the opportunity to help her get an education, she claims that she is 14. Despite lying to his face, the teacher still gives her the choice to come back to school and take her exam. Anuja has a caring sister, Palak (Ananya Shanbhag), who is the only person Anuja might listen to.

Palak wants Anuja to become educated and build a bright future that she couldn't achieve for herself, which is also what their mother desired. Yet, she is unable to persuade Anuja to go and take the exam, but who knows if Anuja might listen to her. As promised to her sister, Anuja has to go to the exam, albeit reluctantly. At the same time, the factory owner offers her a job after noticing her remarkable talent for math. Will Anuja be able to make a choice at such a young age?

Anuja ends abruptly, feeling somewhat incomplete, but that uncertainty about Anuja's character actually makes it a complete film. It runs for 20-21 minutes and, therefore, feels short, which may explain why I couldn't feel any significant impact. Yet, it is absorbing enough to make you think about it for a moment.

The main reason for this age is that the story resonates with millions of girls across the world. They are too small to make choices, and maybe that's why they have remained backward and poor for years. Some girls don't even get that rare chance, and those who do fail to understand what it means. There is not much special about it other than mirroring some bitter facts of society.

Sajda Pathan was natural, and it is not a typical act that can be judged as a "performance." She is not even an actor, so it would be unfair to assess her acting. It's all about her screen presence, and the same goes for Ananya Shanbhag. Nagesh Bhosle was fine as the factory owner, and Gulshan Walia was decent in the two or three frames in which he appears. The rest of the cast hardly appears enough to be noticed.

Adam Graves' simple formula of human emotions without dramatic conflicts makes it a decent watch. There is a lot of hype surrounding this project in India, so I'd like to say, "cool down, guys. There is nothing out there for you to hype." Watch Anuja just to understand the problem that has existed for years, and many of us are already familiar with it. We have had many independent shorts and documentaries about the same. It's just that one "burning" moment at the end that might stay with you. You can skip the rest of the show, but what's there to skip in 20 minutes?

This 22-minute short film, nominated for an Oscar, grabbed my attention, and I had high hopes considering its inclusion in such a prestigious global award show.

The story follows two young girls struggling to make ends meet, with one sister being a math genius.

Sajda Pathan and Ananya Shanbhag play the sisters, and they truly bring a breath of fresh air to the narrative. The director has extracted the best performances from these two young talents.

The scene at the mall is engaging, and the celebration afterward beautifully encapsulates their lives. The story authentically reflects real life, which is its true charm. While it doesn't present anything groundbreaking, it remains a sweet watch.

With such a short runtime, it's definitely worth watching-though I wished for a better ending.

#PranuReviews #Anuja #AnujaReview.