Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo is a kind of odd mix. It's a slice-of-life romcom mixture that wants to be funny pretty much all the time, with a somewhat serious undertone. It has its share of outstanding qualities, but unfortunately fails to keep a healthy balance between silliness and seriousness.
The cast diversity is definitely there. All characters have very individual and unique traits which make you feel that every single one of them, despite their oddness, have their purpose and their right to be. It's making a great case for individualism in the otherwise highly conformist Japanese society. It's just... too much over the top. Many characters are exaggerated to a level where it just seems silly. And so become their interactions.
Another slightly disturbing imbalance is the amount of artificially created 'ecchi' moments and intentional innuendos, while the characters struggle even with the most basic displays of emotions. It is not unusual for this type of show, but the discrepancy in those behaviours was, in my opinion, a little too much.
While the storytelling and the animation itself are nothing out of the ordinary and the exaggerated silliness of the show make it hard to immerse or relate, two qualities struck me as outstanding:
1. The soundtrack. Not too aggressive, subtle and beautiful at the right moments.
2. The localization. I watched the show on Netflix, Japanese audio with German subs. But only the subtitles showed a great attention to detail and use a lot of 'urban' and common language. Also the overlay of textual passages, documents, books right in the video was done with a great attention to detail and seamlessly integrated into the overall frame. Not many Japanese shows put that much effort into making them accessible for foreign audiences.
Tl;dr: An overall good, silly and fun rom-com show with certain strengths and weaknesses. Decent watch but not outstanding imo.
