उपयोगकर्ता समीक्षाएं

I would definitely recommend this documentary, especially for people who enjoy true crime and conspiracy theories. It starts out slow, but by the end of the documentary, it really makes you think about a number of inconsistencies that were reported by the government.

This particular documentary gives the viewer an inside look into the missing pieces of an investigation that was fast tracked by the government, anyone alive at the time remembers how easily the pieces fit into the constructed explanation, with what amounted to the lone gunman theory. Worth watching if you're interested in finding out more about the events, using some archive footage the director weaves a masterpiece exposing the holes in the story whilst still meshing the interviews of those actually involved in the events. This documentary not only raises more questions it answers some, I highly recommend this film to people who like to look at situations from all aspects and don't always accept the manufactured answers we're given when such atrocities occur.

The film was a bit slow to start off. The intro was well done and grabbed my attention for the first few minutes but it jumped into what seemed like a whole lot of "here-say" from eyewitnesses. i was beginning to lose interest (having been spoiled by the overwhelming hard hitting quick facts from documentaries like "Loose Change").

The movie took a turn for the better when they started getting into the facts of the bombing, the inconsistencies, etc. Once the movie hit this stride, it became more and more interesting while infuriating at the same time. watching it i felt like i was duped by the "official" story.

Overall it was a great film that didn't force an opinion on you but laid out all the evidence for you to analyze.

Other films and books i'd have to recommend if you're interested in these types of cover ups would be the following:

Loose Change 2nd edition Kill Zone: A Sniper Looks at Dealey Plaza by Craig Roberts

The truth is stranger than fiction my friends, don't believe everything you're told to believe.

I was very impressed with the way A Noble Lie tells the story of the OKC bombing. The film makers don't use cheesy sound fx, savvy editing or the like to add fluff here. Any documentary that does usually means the content is not strong enough to rest on its own. That is not the case with this one.

A Noble Lie uses physical evidence, eye witness testimony, media reports, and court documents to allow the viewer to come to their own conclusion. All in all it was very informative, and did not pile on too much at the same time. I would like to see some things discussed more in detail, like Tim McVeigh's interviews in prison, and I'm hearing a sequel is in the works, so hopefully that happens.

Any person with a critical eye that likes to think for themselves, I recommend checking this one out.

When you rely on Alex Jones as an expert, and one of your positive reviews proclaim you the best source on the "deep state" conspiracy nonsense, you have no credibiity.

And when you base a murder claim on, "Oh he looked like a white supremacist bank robber, trust Tim McVeigh on this," your credibility keeps on dropping.

This documentary stands as a monument to those that lost their lives needlessly in the Oklahoma City bombing.

As if speaking from the dead the souls lost that dreadful day are finally heard through the voices of the rescuer's, the Police, the witnesses and the surviving family members in their call for a proper investigation!

Shockingly this film reveals to us that the official story is a cancerous lie that needs to be cut out of the history books. It also makes obvious that only when the truth is known will the victims finally have closure and be able move towards justice.

The main reason I found this documentary so outstanding is its respect for those it represents; honouring the subject without arrogance and clearly wary of sensationalism or theorising. A "Noble Lie" lets the facts and the eyewitnesses do the talking; which is why its a must see!"

Watched it with an open mind, but as the journalist claims HE HIMSELF became the PIVOTAL part in a conspiracy where all smart people targeted the "proudly self educated masses" I came to a realisation:

Either he's severely delusional

OR HE'S A FRAUD. A marketing gimmick, trying to promote his own career.

This film is such a respectable piece of work - It's been about 5 years since last I saw this film, and I was delighted to discover it offered available for unlimited views via my streaming service subscription, so I decided to revisit it and see if it holds up as well as it first did upon initial release - it does not disappoint.

Oklahoma City is NOT a simple or linear event to make sense of, it defies even the concept of 'narrative', True, False, Fictititious or None of The Above.

There are multiple layers upon layers of cover-stories, disinformation, official denial and flat out lies, to unpack and reconcile it all would take a lifetime (which of course is the point) - the only possible answer to such a challege is "Don't Even Try."

"Just present all the evidence and information that checks out and has been verified - and embrace The Contradiction.

The sheer volume and density of revelatory information, evidence, quotes, witness testimonials is just VAST - and it comes at such rapidfire pace, you will notice something, some fact, that sticks in your consciousness and gains traction on every viewing that you never even recognised the true significance of before - and then the film will tell you where that information came from, who said it, and in what book it appears in to allow you to go and verify that it is indeed the case.

Example, case in-point : The place where McVeigh was living for the week prior to the bombing, with the Big Yellow Ryder Truck parked outside for everyone to see (in order to get noticed) was a motel in Kansas.

What I had not appreciated prior to now was that

1) The Motel was JUST OUTSIDE THE GATES of an Army Fort in Kansas.

2) The name of the motel was "Dreamland", the same name given to Groom Lake Test Flight Range in Arizona, aka "Area-51"

That, to me, tells me that The US Army owned and operated that motel, which was why McVeigh was there, trying to get noticed all week.

NB. The Dreamland motel has since been closed down, razed to ground and demolished, with a Memorial to OKC (funded, by implication, using public money by another State, which States are generally not inclined to do, that is entirely counterintuitive), which further speaks to the implication that DoD paid for it as part of the Cover and Deception to hide their involvement in directing McVeigh and Nichols and the bomb truck

The movie has 10,000 gems like that embeded within it.

Hell, even Alex Jones manages to be on his best behaviour for this one....

It's America, there's a tragedy or outrage, so obviously you look for the conspiracy. If it's South it must be them damn Yankee Feds. If it's North it must be them damn gun toting rednecks of the NRA. America has a conspiracy theory for everything from flat Earth to lunar landings. Long may it continue, might not stand up to critical examination, but it always intrigues you. As a Brit the main thing that got me is why the hell are ATF in the same building as a childcare centre, what next, FBI offices above the retirees home. We pour scorn on others we say are using human shields, no military, intelligence, or enforcement agency should be anywhere near these places.As for the basic premise it's the old story, possibility / probability / definitive. Depending on viewpoint you'll choose the one you prefer, I'll choose the wonderful Scottish cop out verdict - NOT PROVEN. :-)

Alex Jones is included in several places talking about conspiracies. Unfortunately, he eliminates all credibility from anything he's involved in.

Be better off cutting yourself than watching a second of this ham brained conspiracy joke of a movie. "There were ATF agents outside of the building the ATF works out of!" What? Look, Alex J0nes is in the film as an expert, what more do you need to know? Do something more interesting with your life than watch this absolute drivel. Go pet a dog or something. Hell, go get a vasectomy as it would be less painless than watching this movie. A donkey kick to the balls would be better than this movie. A colonoscopy without any anesthesia would be better than watching this movie! I didn't like this movie.

This mass of garbage lost all credibility at 00:05:37. As soon as a filmmaker, or anyone, decides to use the known fraud and liar Alex Jones as a buttress to any argument they immediately lose. There may have been other, more thoughtful interviews throughout, but I can't lend any serious credence to any piece that seriously allows InfoWars into its source material.

This is one long Facebook reel dedicated to influencing the least sophisticated into believing hyperbolic conspiracy theories intent on derailing serious discussion about the motivations of mass murderers and fostering uneducated mistrust in government as a whole.

So Jane Graham appears in this film, but they don't ask her about the two perpetrators of the bombing, who she saw in the building twice, on the two days before the bombing, and then saw, by accident, on television, walking in front of the cameras, right in front of the Murrah Building? Jane Graham gave video testimony to this effect, in great detail, in the video 'Coverup in Oklahoma', where she holds a photograph of a screen grab of that video of two of the perpetrators. She talks for almost one hour, in two interviews, about those two perpetrators. Their photo is very clearly shown both at 47:10 and at the very end of 'Coverup in Oklahoma' - so why does A Noble Lie not mention these two murderers? Why didn't Alex Jones ask Jane Graham about these two perpetrators when he interviewed her? Therefore, you can take 'A Noble Lie' as a REAL 'noble lie', it is disinformation, designed to allow the perpetrators to go free, because we have VIDEO evidence of who they are, yet these two men have never been arrested or charged.

We know who did this. We know why they did this. And these filmmakers , if you can actually call them that, are right up there with those that claim the US government was responsible for 9/11!! It's such a far flung theory about the e ents and investigation it makes you laugh at some of the arguments. The minute you see Alex Jones in the beginning you should know better than to waste your time. Spend a couple of hours on something that makes you proud to be an American. This film is like every other anti-government conspiracy, it's to make the viewer think that the culprits and their accomplices weren't as guilty as they were. It's a joke.

Anything that includes Alex Jones as a source for information can not be legitimate. I stopped watching the film once Alex Jones appeared in interviews. Using Jones in this film erases any shred of credibility, accountability, and dignity. Alex Jones is a known quack who has pushed baseless and harmful ideas, claims, and conspiracy theories onto uneducated individuals. His words and actions have caused irreparable and irrevocable harm to families of victims of violent crimes. Jones' presence at the Oklahoma City bombing site does not under any circumstances automatically make him a credible witness.

In the different world pre 4 chan this silly film filled with totally unsubstantiated theories would be the provence of tin foil merchants yelling at Pidgeons. Unfortunately some people will add this to their slew of paranoid delusions along side such empty phrases as "the main stream media" and "do your own research." I suggest people who indulge in this kind of thing watch "Conspiracy Theories Lie" an excellent examination of the Kennedy Assassination nonsense that has gone on for decades and shows all too clearly how vital critical thinking and evaluating our preconceptions and possibly shallow perspectives that limit a rational response to a messy world will lead you eventually to end up at a rally supporting a racist, flatulent, narcissistic, imbecile with nothing to add to the world than limited responses to a complicated world.