अपनी भाषा में प्लॉट जोड़ेंOn the shores of Jeju Island, a fierce group of South Korean divers fights to save their vanishing culture from looming threats.On the shores of Jeju Island, a fierce group of South Korean divers fights to save their vanishing culture from looming threats.On the shores of Jeju Island, a fierce group of South Korean divers fights to save their vanishing culture from looming threats.
- निर्देशक
- पुरस्कार
- 5 जीत और कुल 3 नामांकन
फ़ीचर्ड समीक्षाएं
I enjoyed the concept very much and it was fascinating to learn about these women, but I felt the narrative lacking a bit. Felt like there was an opportunity to say a lot more, and I found the attempt to tie it into existential circumstances in the last third was a bit forced and didn't totally land for me.
I would've been much more interested in learning about the women's personal lives and their families and their mental hurdles and struggles rather than the focus on relatively dry speeches at the UN and whatnot. But overall pretty solid and touching, and the women documented are nothing short of remarkable.
I would've been much more interested in learning about the women's personal lives and their families and their mental hurdles and struggles rather than the focus on relatively dry speeches at the UN and whatnot. But overall pretty solid and touching, and the women documented are nothing short of remarkable.
Given that it's an A24 production, I had high hopes for good characters and storytelling but was ultimately disappointed.
The film is beautifully shot and the women profiled are incredible, but there is so little character building that an hour and a half later, I don't feel any closer to any of the characters. The film touches on some of the seawomen's past, the discrimination they faced, the lack of labour rights, and how they finally rose above it all. But the director gives the issue quite a superficial treatment using a few standard soundbites without diving deeper.
I also feel I didn't learn much about the "haenyeo" women. Why are the divers all women but their "bosses" all men? Is the area accessible to haenyeo divers only? Why are they able to compete with more modern forms of fishing? Given Malala is the producer, I also expected a deeper dive into related social issues.
Overall, the film is beautiful but lacklustre in emotion and substance. It's fun to see dozens of septuagenarians free diving, laughing and having a good time, but this isn't enough to sustain the film for an hour and a half. It feels like it's TV film you can watch on Discovery Channel.
The film is beautifully shot and the women profiled are incredible, but there is so little character building that an hour and a half later, I don't feel any closer to any of the characters. The film touches on some of the seawomen's past, the discrimination they faced, the lack of labour rights, and how they finally rose above it all. But the director gives the issue quite a superficial treatment using a few standard soundbites without diving deeper.
I also feel I didn't learn much about the "haenyeo" women. Why are the divers all women but their "bosses" all men? Is the area accessible to haenyeo divers only? Why are they able to compete with more modern forms of fishing? Given Malala is the producer, I also expected a deeper dive into related social issues.
Overall, the film is beautiful but lacklustre in emotion and substance. It's fun to see dozens of septuagenarians free diving, laughing and having a good time, but this isn't enough to sustain the film for an hour and a half. It feels like it's TV film you can watch on Discovery Channel.
It's fascinating to me that I learned for the first time about these strong, fearless, cheerful grandmothers called haenyeo, who in their 60s and 70s still snorkel a few meters and collect seafood to sell, and that's a tradition in South Korea. On the island of Jeji, a craft that has been handed down for generations, but is now dying out due to climate change, ocean pollution, and because the new generations do not want to do it. UNESCO protected this tradition in 2016.
However, although the film is visually wonderful, they failed to elaborate on some very important topics, such as when the government of Japan decided to release radioactive material into the ocean after Fukushima and when a haenyeo representative was invited to the UN to give a speech on what consequences this would have. . We don't really get a full epilogue to it, it's just scratched the surface. In essence, they did release that material into the ocean.
However, although the film is visually wonderful, they failed to elaborate on some very important topics, such as when the government of Japan decided to release radioactive material into the ocean after Fukushima and when a haenyeo representative was invited to the UN to give a speech on what consequences this would have. . We don't really get a full epilogue to it, it's just scratched the surface. In essence, they did release that material into the ocean.
I would highly recommend anyone wanting to learn more about this amazing tradition, read The Island of The Sea Women by Lisa See to get a more in depth understanding g of this culture. There is so much more to the Haenyou than this did orovides and a lot more history.
I watched this to learn more after finishing the book. And it was cool to see them in action, but too much fo us on what was happening in Japan. Although I understand and realize it's important, but it didn't teach me as much as I wanted to learn. Jeju island was deeply affected by the Korean War and the April 3 uprising that would have been more interesting since it directly affected these people.
I watched this to learn more after finishing the book. And it was cool to see them in action, but too much fo us on what was happening in Japan. Although I understand and realize it's important, but it didn't teach me as much as I wanted to learn. Jeju island was deeply affected by the Korean War and the April 3 uprising that would have been more interesting since it directly affected these people.
I wanted to hear more about their training to become divers, their lives, etc. Instead it just had footage of harvesting and told a little about the divers. Then it switched to protesting Japan's release of nuclear wastewater into the ocean. Not at all what I was interested in. I read about the sea women in a book that was more moving and interesting than this movie. Skip the movie, read the books about the hanyeo women. You will learn more and be pulled into their lives in a much more emotional way.
The book also talked about the unique adaptations of these women's bodies. Scientists studied them and their cold resistance and other unique abilities.
The book also talked about the unique adaptations of these women's bodies. Scientists studied them and their cold resistance and other unique abilities.
क्या आपको पता है
- ट्रिवियाThe true history behind the New York Times bestseller The Island of Sea Women, a novel by Lisa See published in 2019.
टॉप पसंद
रेटिंग देने के लिए साइन-इन करें और वैयक्तिकृत सुझावों के लिए वॉचलिस्ट करें
विवरण
बॉक्स ऑफ़िस
- दुनिया भर में सकल
- $1,994
- चलने की अवधि
- 1 घं 27 मि(87 min)
- रंग
इस पेज में योगदान दें
किसी बदलाव का सुझाव दें या अनुपलब्ध कॉन्टेंट जोड़ें