One Piece: Episode of Alabaster - Sabaku no Ojou to Kaizoku Tachi

It's merely a synopsis of the Arabasta Arc, which had a fantastic plot and deserves at least a nine on its own. However, numerous amazing moments, such as Ace's cameo and Mizu Mizu Luffy, are missing from the film. A lot of elements were trimmed and rearranged, which diminished some of its brilliance (particularly the crew's fight scenes). It was not a fantastic idea to make the eighth movie a recap of an arc, especially one that was very long and had a lot of content, but since it is a movie, I was expecting some things to be cut and left out. Some find the artwork of One Piece to be distinctive and interesting. Some find it repulsive, believing it to be drawn and unattractive. I rate it an eight since I like it. The film did include some lovely visual effects that enhanced the animation. Characters received tens, and appearances were included. Like Ace's, those pirates that cruise on their boat on the sand, and those turtle-looking guys. It did, of course, include the main characters and everything, and they are all amazing. Since I hadn't seen the Arabasta Arc in a while, this kind of brought back memories of it, which is probably why most One Piece fans would also love it. But as I've already mentioned, it omitted some excellent scenes, and I believe I would have preferred an entirely new film to serve as the eighth film. Just like every other film that came before it, this one deviates from the plot.

"One Piece: Episode of Alabasta - The Desert Princess and the Pirates" is a TV special that serves as a condensed retelling of the Alabasta arc, one of the most iconic and pivotal storylines in One Piece history. This special condenses the original arc's 100+ episodes into a single, streamlined format. While it provides an accessible way for new viewers to experience the emotional highs and action-packed moments of Alabasta, it doesn't quite capture the full impact and depth of the original material.

One of the standout features of Episode of Alabasta is its pacing. The Alabasta arc is one of the longest in One Piece, so condensing it into a 2-hour TV special allows the key moments to shine without feeling drawn out. The film focuses on the central themes of the arc-courage, loyalty, and the fight against corruption-making sure to deliver the emotional beats that make the Alabasta saga so beloved by fans. Key moments like Vivi's struggle with her duty to her kingdom and Luffy's unwavering support for her, despite the cost, are impactful even in the condensed format.

The animation is updated compared to the original episodes, with more refined visuals and a smoother animation style, which enhances the action sequences. The fight between Luffy and Crocodile, in particular, is dynamic and well-choreographed, capturing the intensity of the battle without losing any of the original's drama.

The special also does a good job of showcasing the main characters of Alabasta, particularly Princess Vivi. The focus on her emotional journey, including her relationship with the Straw Hat crew and her internal conflict as she contemplates her role in her kingdom's future, is a strong point. The film stays true to the heart of her character arc, making her one of the most compelling parts of the special.

The biggest issue with Episode of Alabasta is its inability to fully capture the depth and intricacies of the original arc. Alabasta is not just about the epic battles but also about the complex world-building, character development, and intricate politics surrounding the kingdom. In its shortened format, a lot of the nuance gets lost. For example, the backstories of certain characters, like the rebel army and Crocodile's motivations, feel underdeveloped. The film also glosses over the more subtle emotional moments that were integral.

RATING 6.4/10 Because is actually something unnecessary for One Piece viewers.

Another one of these One Piece "movies" or "films" that are more like a condensed version of an arc. But I get why you'd call it a movie or film as opposed to condensed version. Better for marketing. Still I find it a little funny that these are made as a sort of necessity now since this series is so ridiculously long that it doesn't even expects own fans to keep up with it so it makes these films to keep you caught up. But I also thought the purpose of these films were to highlight the important bits minus all the filler. To me the most important bits are the great fight scenes which is (to me) this series saving grace but it even rushed that.

If you haven't seen the series this movie gives a really rushed recap of one of the better arcs of One Piece in my opinion. It introduces Croc who is a great villain/character with a super cool power and also introduces mama Robin who is more than waifs material with an equally cool power and better character.

Everything felt really rushed and focused too much on the cheesy elements of the princess trying to compel her people to choose peace by merely yelling/pleading to them and existing. Then it basically just said, "oh and there were some really cool fights with Zoro, Nami and Luffy but yeah this girl cried for her country and became tattoo buddies with the Straw Hats. Should've shown more of the fights. 5.57/10.

Okay, I, just yesterday, went to my local Wal-Mart to buy One Piece The Movie: The Desert Princess and The Pirates Adventures in Alabasta. Being the One Piece buff I am, it's only natural that I anticipate. I mean, this is the new One Piece movie, right. I got home right after buying it, popped it into my DVD player, and sat down on my couch to watch.

Shortly after pressing play, my ears were greeted by a billowing wisp of air from my television speakers, as well as a beautiful orchestral blare. The movie kept going on like this and it was a truly beautiful thing to see and hear.

The animation has greatly improved from the TV anime. Though it's not on the same level as Miyazaki's critically acclaimed Spirited Away, it doesn't mean it can't startle you now and then.

The voice-overs are expertly done, and will blow you away once you hear them. I especially loved Pell's voice, as it suited the character so perfectly, I nearly jumped up from the couch and shouted, "Yes! Do it again!" The score has been crafted by careful hands here, and expertly comments the mood of each individual scene.

This movie is entertaining and I recommend it to anybody who is a One Piece fan or likes a good action film.

10/10 (Highly Recommended)

From development, to writing, to direction, and beyond, this eighth full-length feature of the franchise made an interesting choice. I see no problem whatsoever with adapting an episode from the manga, long and full as it is of tales ripe for translation into another medium. However, the doing here is rather inelegant as within minutes we're hastily introduced to two new supporting characters who will (supposedly) be integral to this one story: flashback, present day, flashback, then back to the present and the active narrative. We're effectively tossed headlong into the plot with exposition that disjointedly conveys necessary information that serves as foundation, and I have to think that it would have taken very little - additional scenes of a few minutes at most, rewriting, re-editing these early minutes - to provide a more cogent and lucid introduction to this one saga. Wherever the responsibility lies between the producers, writer Kamisaka Hirohiko, and director Imamura Takahiro, the incidence is notable and unfortunate, and not the best start for 'The desert princess and the pirates: Adventure in Alabasta' as this seem geared specifically for those who are already familiar with the manga or anime.

Would that the issues with this 'One Piece' film ended at the beginning. There's also the matter of a primary character, who has already been part of the Straw Hat Pirates in prior theatrical releases, being depicted at an earlier point in the manga when they were not. Granted, it's not as if the movies are directly tied to each other in a sequential order, and we could perhaps consider this in some measure as a partial treatment of the character's backstory. Even so, this matter was also easily solvable by more freely adapting the narrative. Moreover, in a plot of the Straw Hats encountering three parties who are at odds, with one manipulating the other two, and further including a character who can freely alter their appearance, I believe the feature sometimes struggles to identify the parties at hand, or where loyalties lie. Even if we generously suppose that the dialogue has been mangled in translation for subtitles, the fundamental scene writing is just as shoddy about communicating the course of events. And it's not just about the writing, for in what I assume to have been the choices of director Imamura in shaping the writing to his vision for the animation, the manner in which some particular shots or scenes present is terribly confusing as they are so inadequate in terms of imparting the intended idea.

Truthfully, I think this is a rare instance in which the animation itself is at fault. I don't mean to suggest that the artists at Toei turned in poor work, because that's absolutely not the case; as is routinely the case, the visual experience is characterized by terrific detail and texture, gorgeous backgrounds and environments, vibrant designs for characters and other active elements, fluid movement and action, and so on. Yet the creative decisions that guided those artists, that dictated how a shot or scene should appear, leads to some outright misuse of animation. And as much as I blame Kamisaka and Imamura for the failures of this picture, editor Goto Masahiro is culpable as least as much if not more. The narrative flow is all over the place, incohesive and almost incoherent, as the presentation flits heedlessly between multiple concurrent scenes. Violent action sequences and dramatic moments of critical importance are recklessly chopped up, obliterating their would-be potency and further complicating the the horribly weak plot development that stems from the troubled writing and direction. It seems time and time again that characters and even the smallest of minutiae come and go from out of nowhere, and beats transpire in a manner just as slipshod. The end result is that a tale which should be sober and thrilling, with high stakes and great risk for our heroes, is instead entirely unable to make any of it meaningful and impactful for us. There's barely any sense of basic narrative structure here. What happened?

I read an outside synopsis of the plot and I see a story that should have been compelling and absorbing as Luffy and his nakama are pushed to their limits. That is not the story we get in 'The desert princess and the pirates: Adventure in Alabasta.' There's barely a story at all as the writing, direction, animation, and editing butcher it, which is all the more astonishing since, again, the saga on hand is discretely adapting a plot from the manga. Sincerely, what happened here? I can only assume that the production was rushed, or that individuals with control over the outcome but without a creative bone in their body (i.e., suits in the executive suite) pushed for certain choices. For as excellent as all the previous 'One Piece' films were, this one is a mess, and almost unwatchable. I see the tremendous potential that it bore, but from start to finish that potential is almost completely squandered. Accentuating the point: amidst the exposition in the earliest scenes, we see the Straw Hats undertake preparations to counter a dangerous foe - but those preparations never, ever come into play as this is written, nor addressed again, except in the most meaningless fashion. The very notion was a waste, and frankly, so is the movie as a whole. Sloppy and flailing in pretty much every way that matters most, a mere ninety minutes feel far, far longer than they are, and the sad truth is that this 2007 feature was mismanaged from top to bottom. Where other films of the franchise are outstanding, this one was just a mistake, and I rather recommend you avoid it altogether.