La squale

What struck me about this film was the influence of US culture on the characterisation. Initially I thought I was just superimposing my own preconceptions, but I was lucky enough to attend a screening where the director was there to take questions afterwards. He made the point that a lot of Black and Arab youth culture in France borrows directly from the American idea of 'the ghetto', and from the language of film pornography. Ultimately I was disappointed because I like my French films 'French' (that is to say, coquettish, poetic, and a little existential). But that's not to say that La Squale is an excellent depiction of a very real French way of life - a good example of its genre.

I like this film because it's a true, genuine and realistic denunciation of gang rapes. When it was shot, the phenomena was not clearly known, and most of the people did not know these kind of acts could happen in certain neighborhoods. Recently in France (in October 2012), some gang rapers were sentenced to one year jail (only) for these kind of acts. The scandal is not finished yet but this film deserves credit for making light on an awful, misogynous practice in french treacherous suburbs. The actors are inhabitants of these kind of neighborhoods and they talk the same way these people are used to talking. In that sense it's a genuine reproduction of reality.

As a "middle class" French, i started to feel embarrassed to define this movie as one of the worst i've ever seen... But i held on and now i can scream it freely. The end is over pathetic and disgusting, the acting is bad, and worst, as it's still cool to play feminist no one will dare to say that girl, désirée, is as bad, violent and stupid as everyone around her. This is not a matter of self defence, it's just common sense. I hate those kind of guys, and even more the girls who desperately try to look like them. Avoid this film please. Whether you're French or not, rich or poor doesn't matter. Here we call this kind of movies "navet", a turnip. It means this is tripe.

I found this movie to be an excellent portrayal and representation of the struggles todays young people must endure.

The players in this film were very east to relate to however, challenging to understand their experience.

The movie is fast paced and has a very action oriented base to it. There is certainly plenty of Romance, as well as intense and sometimes graphic sexual violence. Unlike some other American films, this violence does actually help move to story along to its conclusion.

The ending is a representation of friendship and sincerity through a tragic betrayal.

Wonderfully acted, filmed and written - I found this movie to be wonderful as well as deep, thought provoking and interesting.

Luckily this is not the side of France (all other bad raps aside) that we regularly see or tourism would be worse than that of Detroit.

The thing I found most interesting about this film is the plain language, almost indiscernable at points in its guttural aspects and the fact that it presented French life like many places--plain, miserable at times and a struggle...).

Well acted and technically sound, I won't analyze it here since this is not for the NY Times and some other blow-hard will at some point. Thematically though, I will say it is played out in many a western "gangsta' film as well as some of those which are not either, and in this respect, nothing particularly sets it aside.

However, for a student of the French language it may prove challenging, since I felt it was difficult to follow at times and the mix of "street language" is very cool for upping one's punk vocabulary for sure. This will play better depending on who you are as an audience. What I'd rate it is a relative middle of the road...