Die dritte Generation

High hopes and expectations were crushed with this little film of Rainer Werner Fassbinder, a great talent by all accounts but he went overboard with this bizarre satire that goes nowhere (or close to that). "The Third Generation" and its wild act of presenting us a potential future dominated by technological security appartus and how left-wing anarchists can insurge themselves against the powers of capitalism and greedy corporations offer a shallow, verbose and messy critcism of everything and everyone, that never gets to be funny neither serious. And the thing about satire is that through a careful and detailed analysis of a living context, the period in which the artist lives, it must be either a funny thing offering amusing jabs at whatever is being target of criticism or ridicule - even if it's all about nervous laughter - or painfully dramatic to shock or disturb audiences, like a punch in the stomach; and with both ways the thinking audience will confront itself with possible solutions to the problematic presented.

The basic premise sounds very appealing: a radical group elaborates a criminal plan against a powerful international corporation. Barely they know that they're being used as a tool for a political party to active their powers and become a bigger thing. Mr. Fassbinder trips and falls with such story as there's plenty of talks that goes without coherence, almost no action, and long titles covering the screen in a chapter format presenting texts and words found on Germany's real public toilets, going form political perspectives, sex hookups descriptions and jokes (this whole toilet thing would make a nice film concept or a weird but fun documentary).

The ultimate take I got from it was that the director/writer was probably saying that radical left groups are all talk and no action or they lose themselves through sex, drugs and classic literature.

It's kind of a shameful critique as he only looked for that German context, and to expose that without seeing what happened in South and Central America or other nations going through repressive politics at the time, is very problematic. There was a lot going on in those groups with vision, attitude and the persuit for a better society. The reality wasn't funny, and neither this somewhat spoof of things.

I tried hard to like and accept this film, but despite some interesting moments here and there (the cast is alright, as a majority of them were part of Fassbinder group), it just lost me halfway through. Couldn't find a valid criticism of anything, everything and everyone seems missplaced and random, and no possible solutions were offered to this alternative reality, neither answers were given to its peculiar things (Why the group had to deal with the junkie girl in their apartment? Why they accept her lover so easily and how they convinced him to join their cause?). If given a proper treatment, there'd be a good story to be seen instead of the emptiness and rambling of it all. 4/10.

i can't say i really understood this movie but i was gripped. i'd drunk 8 beers before watching and fancied something heavy and wot heavier than Fassbinder i thought. i've read all the reviews of this movie on IMDb and they tell me it's a comedy. i didn't laugh once but Fassbinder really is way above my head in every way, so u may see the comedy that i missed out on. i also read u need to see this movie 2 or 3 times to get it. i think this movie was just too complex for my little brain but i still loved it. Fassbinder's 'fox and his friends' is one of my favourite ever films so i will always be open to a Fassbinder film. i will watch this film again because i really think there is something special going on. i shouldn't have drunk 8 beers before watching this complex work but like i said, i still enjoyed it which i think says something about Fassbinder.

One of Fassbinder's most underrated and misunderstood films with the spirited cast-including Udo Kier, Eddie Constantine, Hanna Schygulla, Margin Carstensen-make all this touching as well as troubling. This was made during a time when West Germany was dealing with many homegrown terrorist groups. Mind it, this is not an action film but an absurd comedy to be precise which explores the German Terrorism (Baader-Meinhoff crew) of the 70s. Fassbinder takes a neutral stand here and skewers both the left and the right, he takes a dig at the corruption and hypocrisy of both the capitalists and the communists. He pokes fun at radical bourgeois nihilist leftists who wants to make a statement against capitalism, but the result is that their efforts turn out to be a big flop as it helped the wealthy capitalist. Still kinda oddly compelling almost like adding another weird one to the opus of the old anti-burgeous Godard (La Chinoise) film which is relevant as shown in the on-screen title card and the aural tricks. Beyond Godard, Robert Bresson is a major influence in the film, scenes from controversial The Devil Probably is shown playing on the TV at the beginning of this film), and Tarkovsky's Solaris. But it is so stylized and deliberately non realist that it could be something else. But what matters is its visual aspect, made of unusual frames and geometric images that makes of it one of Faasbinder's best film I know followed by Lili Marleen, fascinating from the first to the last.

In Berlin, a cell of terrorist composed by middle-class people is activated with the sentence "The World as Will and Idea", based on the central work of the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer "The World as Will and Representation". They plan to abduct the businessman P. J. Lurz ( Eddie Constantine) that works with sales of computers, while they are chased by a persistent chief of police.

"Die Dritte Generation" a.k.a. "The Third Generation" is a weird, hermetic, disconnected but mesmerizing film of German director Rainer Werner Fassbinder, divided in six chapters and dedicated to those who truly love (meaning no one in the vision of the director). The plot explores the concept of terrorism and the contradictions of the middle- class and apparently the central idea is based on Schopenhauer's central work. Unfortunately I do not have knowledge in philosophy, sociology or political science to fully understand this inaccessible film. Fassbinder uses unusual angles with his camera and strange sounds to expose with irony the bourgeois values of each ridiculous terrorist of this generation that does not have ideology. In the end, I liked this collection of ideas in spite of I have not clearly understood the film as a whole. My vote is six.

Title (Brazil): "A Terceira Geração" ("The Third Generation")

This director thinks terrorism is a stupid joke. The third generation of terror here is a bunch of bored citizens who are dumb enough not to wonder who is giving out the money that pays for their guns. It's a quite scary and funny way to look at contemporary society and some of its extremely radical enemies. Some viewers might find it disturbing instead of hilarious.