Harper Valley P.T.A.

I thought this was an excellent statement that exemplified the saying that "those who live in glass houses should not throw stones." A great movie that made one feel that maybe, just perhaps, we can all come out on top sometimes with our dignity intact.

This was a surprise. I really wasn't expecting something quite so unhinged and full of gags. I guess I thought I was going into something more conversational, more plot driven. This had some conversation, but it was more about the gags.

A lot of revenge plot. Done for laughs.

Not bad, but not my thing generally.

The most shocking part of this film is the closing credits, which lists where the manure from one of the gags came from. I am stunned! They use real manure!! I feel so bad for the actress or tunable who had to have manure dumped on them!! This movie lost to half star because of that.

A plus for the movie though is that in the opening credits, JJ is listed as one of the actors, which is my Joan's nickname and initials. And right after that, Joan is listed as one of the producers. Once I saw that, I knew there had to be an Alice in the movie somewhere. And sure enough, The main characters best friend in this film is named Alice! Where there is Joan, there is Alice! I love that!

I watched this movie because I was on an old sitcom kick, which is sort of a lifelong thing. Sitcom from the 1950s and 1960s - somewhat of the 70s, they mean more to me than all TV shows. So I was really getting into "The Dick Van Dyke Show and "Bewitched". Still am. And we all know Barbara Eden, the star of this film, was also the star of the "Bewitched@ rival show, "I Dream of Jeannie". So, if you're a classic TV show fan like I am, and you especially favor it comes from the 1950s through the 1970s, you will find this of interest. It was also adapted into a sitcom of its own.

Not my thing, but not bad. The opening credit song is the best part of it though. It's amazing that a movie can be made just from a song, and for that, it is definitely worth seeing.

Back during my youth in the 70s, the town I lived it was very conservative and tightly wound. Parents cringed at the thought of James Bond movies shown on TV, as the locals thought of them as hardcore porn. Strict standards were expected from everyone.

As teens, the local kids started to realize how overflowing with hypocrisy the town was, and when this movie came along, we rejoiced.

Stella Johnson is a freespirited widow in a conservative town who gets a nastygram from a disapproving PTA. Getting an earful from her friend who runs the local beauty parlor (they weren't called "salons" back then!), she confronts them at a meeting with their own failings (alcoholism, promiscuity, gambling, etc.), but after they don't back down, she engages in a series of pranks to expose and humiliate them. In the meantime she makes over her daughter, falls in love, runs for PTA president herself, and uncovers real corruption.

Yes, it's creaky material, done a jillion times before and probably done better. But Barbara Eden is an energetic and sympathetic heroine, and is believable as the dishy nonconformist mom. Nanette Fabray is also a hoot as her friend Alice. And a bunch of old pros do their best.

But we loved it in our town because so many of the younger set were disgusted with the self-righteousness and hypocrisy we saw in our teachers, in the town government, in the church leaders, and frequently in our own parents. We relished our daydreams of exposing their foibles and confronting them, but too often never did. (Unfortunately, the truly self-righteous view these as simple malice and never truly realize they brought it on themselves.) So even if this movie isn't all that, it appeals to the downtrodden teen who still lives in me and is still disgusted with the self-righteous, it's-OK-if-I-do-it establishment. And I STILL need to expose my sticky-fingered mother about her larcenous habits...

Why don't they make 'em like this any more? HARPER VALLEY P.T.A is one of a handful of flicks from the late 70s and early 80s that mixed social satire with hilarity(9 TO 5 and HOW TO BEAT THE HIGH COST OF LIVING were two others). Barbara Edan is Stella Johnson, a hard-working single mother who attracts the ire of the self-righteous town Parent-Teacher Association. As those of you who remember how the country song this film was based on goes, Stella gets a not-too-tolerant letter cataloging her many indiscretions(which are merely rumors)and responds by giving the members what-for at a public meeting. When this results in public rejection(not to mention rocks through the Johnson house windows)Stella takes action, setting in motion a series of elaborate revenges against the P.T.A members that not only even the score but show up each person's hypocrisies. It's great to see beautiful Barbara Eden fight the stuck-up blue-bloods, pompous elected officials, and self-righteous educators who make up the P.T.A., because everyone can see a little of their own communities in Harper Valley.

I don't really like to respond to specific reviews, but there's just no other way to rebut. Harper Valley PTA was not a made-for-TV movie, it had a theatrical showing, albeit not a particularly successful one. It also was very true to the events as portrayed in the song. The first 20 minutes of the movie, in fact, recreate the lyrics almost exactly, at times verbatim. The episodes of revenge and counter-revenge which follow are a logical progression from that story.

I don't think Harper Valley PTA will ever be considered even a good film, much less a great one. It is fun to watch, though, especially during the middle section. I've never seen a movie that starred Barbara Eden that wasn't at least watchable. Her screen persona is so natural and likable that it doesn't really matter what vehicle she's in.