The Proud Rebel

I grew up watching "Family Classics with Frazier Thomas", a program that featured a wide variety of family friendly movies. This was one of them(so was TOBOR THE GREAT but we won't get into that-I just finished reviewing that clunker a few minutes ago). Alan Ladd plays Civil War veteran John Chandler, who is seeking treatment for his mute son(played by real-life son David Ladd), and meets up with a town spinster (Olivia DeHavilland), who takes both of them in when Chandler is falsley accused of starting a brawl, facing thirty days in the town jail. In the meantime, a sheep herder (Dean Jagger) and his juvenile-delinquent sons attempt to force DeHavilland off her ranch. Chandler must also make the tough choice to sell young David's beloved dog to a breeder in order to pay for his treatment.

The performances are first-rate. Alan and David have one of the best father-son chemistries in movie history-(along with Jon Voight and Ricky Schroeder in THE CHAMP twenty or so years later). Also, Olivia DeHavilland, Dean Jagger, and veteran actor Harry Dean Stanton help make this one a must-see for all. Even horror veteran John Carradine makes a cameo appearance in the opening scene.

Sadly, this family classic makes the untimely death of Alan Ladd a few years later all the more tragic.

Rating: ****1/2 out of *****

Great acting by Olivia DeHavilland (!), Alan Ladd (!), and son David Ladd. Director Michael Curtiz (Casablanca) shows his soft side in this family film about a man selling his dog to heal his son's muteness. I loved this film when I was a pre-teen, and watched it again last night with my twelve-year-old, and she was pulled into it faster than I was. (Harry) Dean Stanton as the villain, good photography and effective musical score by Jerome Moross in the "Big Country" mold. Lackluster action scenes aren't bad enough to ruin the mood; but it will remind many viewers of "Shane".

This is the perfect movie-for-the whole-family which respects its audience, which is rarely the case in today's production aimed at the children's market which substitute heart and soul for special effects .

The screenplay is derivative and looks like a cross between "Shane " and "Lassie come home" ,but it does not matter ;there's a good chemistry between Alan Ladd and his son in real life :the boy does a very good job , particularly in the scene when he searches the empty farm ; and what a pleasure to see the great Olivia De Havilland directed by Curtiz after all these years !

The boy, David, is the focal point of this movie. The movie had a resounding impact on young boys coming of age in the late 50s and into the 60s. Its powerful impact at the time is what made it a successful movie. The many emotional ups and downs throughout the movie dealt with a wide variety of issues faced by a devoted war veteran father from the south, trying hard to steer away from violence as he travels the Midwest seeking medical resolution to his traumatized son who had been struck by aphasia after witnessing his mother's burning death in a Civil War atrocity . Some of the issues viewers are exposed to include the tragedies during and after the Civil War, the western range wars, the disenfranchisement of the southerners, an evil rancher and his evil sons, a frontier love story, and a son-dog-father saga. The traumatized boy-cum-hero is superbly portrayed by child actor, David Ladd, who becomes the film's hero at the climatic gunfight at the end of the movie, saving his father, reuniting with his dog and regaining his voice. The developing love story between the father portrayed by the ever stoic and stiff Alan Ladd and the widower farmer portrayed by Olivia de Havilland, takes second stage to the tear-jerking scenes superbly portrayed by the boy in two scenes: when he learns that his father had sold his dog, and when he regains his ability to speak at the end of the movie. A well-crafted movie and an outstanding performance by David Ladd who was eleven years old when the film was released.

The theme of the skilled gunfighter trying to lead a gun-free productive civilian life but is thwarted and forced back to his firearm to right an injustice, is a theme that recurs numerous times in western movies. In fact, this theme is quite common in the most successful of westerns including this movie, Shane and High Noon. The overriding message of this genre of movies is: if you are unjustly treated (justice commonly portrayed as inept or corrupt), then you may take up arms and take justice into your own hands, even if it means killing others. The hero and his gun are paramount.

Alan Ladd does the Shane thing again in this Western from 1958. Ladd, a former Confederate soldier, travels w/his supposedly tongue tied son (played by Alan's actual son in real life David who uses grunts & sign language to communicate) & their well trained sheep dog when he comes upon a town & visits a doctor, played Cecil Kellaway, to see if he can cure his son's malady (a running issue Ladd has been on the move to solve) which he can't but does give him the name of a specialist in Minnesota who may be able to help. Running into some trouble w/a sheep farmer, played by Dean Jagger & his two sons, Harry Dean Stanton (billed as Dean Stanton) & Tom Pittman, Ladd is railroaded into jail w/a bail amount he can't come up with but luckily Olivia de Havilland comes to his rescue (she witnessed the incident) & Ladd agrees to work off his debt which gives the ad hoc family a renewed purpose (especially since Jagger has designs on de Havilland's land for his sheep) but when he gets a generous offer for his sheep dog (an amount that would cover his specialist's bill), he sells the pooch knowing it'll break his son's heart when he returns. Director Michael Curtiz (Casablanca/Captain Blood) gets good mileage from the premise but it's too bad George Stevens got there first w/his seminal version of Shane & the narrative is further let down when the story's later focus is on a typical shoot out to right all wrongs between our players when the strength of the piece is Ladd not coming to terms w/his son's ailment which we now know stems from a mental trauma then something medical science can operate on. Also starring John Carradine as a traveling salesman & Henry Hull as a cantankerous judge.