Les misérables

I have seen a number of film and TV adaptations of Les Miserables: this is by far the best. It has the required grandeur and outstanding performances by Jean Gabin (unbeatable as Jean Valjean), Bourvil (a very sly Thenardier) and Bernard Blier (a great Javert). Silvia Montfort is a striking Eponine. Quite long but doesn't feel it, it has enough scope to do justice to the story.

Classic French rendition with atmospheric production design, evocative cinematography in Technicolor Techniscope and awesome cast giving nice acting throughout. Set in 19th Century during Revolution of the Thirties , throwing over King Louis XVIII and taking over power Louis Felipe Orleans in 1830 and subsequent revolutionary fights for the French Republic . After facing poverty and a long time in prison for stealing bread for his starving relatives , convict Jean Valjean : Jean Gavin is freed . Later on , paroled Jean robs precious objects, and is detained but is reedemed for the kindness a bishop. After that , he carries out a prosperous life and is eventually appointed as a Mayor . But Police Inspector Javert : Bernard Blier finds out his true identity as he recognizes him and wants to bring him down . Along the way Valjean cares for an unfortunate prostitute named Fantine and adopts her daughter Cosette : Beatrice Altarriba taking her to París as his own child , and she subsequently falling for a student called Marius : Exposito, who has revolutionary ideas and joins the Revolution led by obstinate leader Enjoiras : Serge Reggiani . The pursuit consumes both men's lives and soon Valjean finds himself in the midst of the student revolution of June 1832 bursting after General Lamarque's death. The legend comes to life .

This known story Is nicely detailed , well paced , with a lot of incidents fitting to Victor Hugo's novel. As the plot follows faithfully the ordinary canon , as the ex-criminal relentlessly chased by the stubborn Javert , playing a cat and mouse game. Main and support cast deliver top-drawer performances . Jean Gavin is extraordinary as an ex-convicted who was imprisioned of a minor crime and spends the rest of his life mercilessly chased. While Bernard Blier is magnificent as the unrelenting and implacable policeman who pursues Valjean here and there . The ordinary comedian Bourvil here plays the extremely nasty and ambicious Thenardier . Beatriz Altarriba and Exposito perform the two lovers Cosette and Marius who are usually cared by Jean Valjean.

Other versions are the following ones : the classic Hollywood rendition Les Miserables 1935 by Richard Boleslawski with Fredric March, Charles Laughton , Rochelle Hudson, Sir Cedric Hardwicke. Les Miserables 1952 by Lewis Milestone with Michael Rennie , Robert Newton, Debra Paget. Italian version Les Miserables 1952 by Riccardo Freda with Gino Cervi, Valentine Cortese . Les Miserables 1982 by Robert Hossein with Lino Ventura, Jean Carmet, Michael Bouquet . Les Miserables 1995 by Claude Lelouch with Jean Paul Belmondo , Alexandra Martínez, Annie Girardot , Rufus, Jean Marais , Philippe Leotard . Les Miserables 2008 by Billie August with Liam Neeson, Geoffrey Rush , Uma Thurman, Claire Danes, Hans Matheson , Peter Vaughn . The lavish musical 2012 Les Miserables by Tom Hooper with Hugh Jackman, Russell Crowe, Amanda Seyfried , Anne Hathaway, Sacha Baron Cohen. And TV series Les Miserables 1978 by Glenn Jordan with Richard Jordan, Anthony Perkins , John Gielgud , Cryl Cusack, Flora Robson . And Les Miserables TV series 2018 with Dominic West, David Oyelowe, David Bradley, Olivia Colman , Lynn Collins , among others.

Jean-Paul Le Chanois,as anyone past infancy knows ,at least in France ,was the "Bête Noire" of the Nouvelle Vague .More than any other director,Godard and his clique were ruthless when they used to speak of him.Unlike Carné ,Duvivier,Clouzot and Grémillon- other victims of the Young Turks who were better than their persecutors anyway- ,he was never restored to favor even by the contemporary critics.Jean Tulard writes in the "Dictionnaire des Réalisateurs" ::" He represents the mediocrity of the fifties cinema (...)He made the worst of all "les Miserables" versions(..) " Objections to Le Chanois's version remained: the pictures are too clean,the characters (particularly Danielle Delorme's Fantine) seem well-fed .Bourvil is miscast as Thenardier:he is too gentle ,too nice to portray him successfully.Cosette is forgettable as a girlie,she is totally bland as Marius's love.How can a director be wrong with the famous scene of the doll,which every French schoolboy and every schoolgirl in my country know by heart? Such is the case here.Waterloo battle and the scenes on the barricades are not really exciting .(But Hossein's slow motions in the 1982 version starring Lino Ventura were not really an improvement on it.

On the plus side,Gabin is a good Valjean -he does not equal Harry Baur in the Raymond Bernard version though- and Bernard Blier is the best Javert I've ever seen.The Valjean/Javert relationship would inspire lots and lots of screenplays,"the fugitive" for instance.Also worthwhile is Silvia Montfort's portrayal of Thenardier's daughter:she easily outclasses Beatrice Altariba's Cosette.

People complain because there are scenes in the novel that were not filmed.Let's not forget that it's a mammoth novel:only a miniseries could do Hugo justice.And anyway it's better than the Liam Neeson version and its happy end.

NB:When the movie was released in France it was divided into two parts (called "epoques" (=eras)) which was the word they used at the time and the audience was invited to come back and thus pay twice to see the whole.

To me, the best versions of Les Miserables- a literary classic, and "the great French novel" for a reason- are the ones from 1935, 1978 and especially 1934. Apart from some draggy pacing, staid directing and the very unexciting barricade scenes, this film was still very good and as an adaptation is better than the 1952, 2000 and especially 1998 adaptations. The film looks very detailed and beautiful if at times too clean, and the photography is very skillful and mostly fluid(if clumsy at times in the scenes with the barricade). The music is haunting and dynamic and occasionally playful, while the script is very literate and maintains the brusque nature of Hugo's prose and the story is faithful in spirit to the book with some parts expanded on like with Valjean and Javert- though things were changed to accommodate the age difference between the actors- and Valjean and the bishop, which none of the other adaptations or even the book for that matter did. The storytelling is still poignant and the message of the book is there and it resonates. Of the cast the standouts are Jean Gabin, Bernard Blier and Bourvil. But that is not to dispute Daniele Delorme as a touching Fantine and while Béatrice Altariba achieves some pathos if not being entirely successful at overcoming Cosette's blandness. Gabin is a noble and understated Valjean with a lot of charisma and emotion, his change from immorality and redemption is portrayed very convincingly. Blier's Javert is cold-blooded, obsessive, strong-principled but there is vulnerability and a conflicted side he brings to Javert as well, which stops him from becoming too much of a one-dimensional antagonist. Bourvi's Thernadier is very slimy and funny, one of the best in the role actually, he manages not to be too sadistic or buffoonish, for a comic-villain role that Thernadier is those are a danger and Bourvil doesn't fall into that trap. In conclusion, a very good film and adaptation but from personal perspective it's not a first choice. 7.5/10 Bethany Cox

The worst of the four versions I have seen. Gabin is dull, uninspired--and look at the director, Le Chanois, no more than a journeyman when an artist is required for one of the great classic novels. Bourvil is excellent as the supreme hypocrite Thenardier, while Delorme has some touching moments as the unlucky Fantine. You can pass this one up, watch Fredric March and Charles Laughton instead; Laughton gives another of his superb performances as Javert.