Mandalay

Enjoyable 30's potboiler if you are a Kay Francis fan (as I am) Just saw this on TCM after years of wanting to see it. It starts out as a Dietrich/Sternberg foreign locale kind of pic, but switches gears midway and becomes a standard soap opera tale. Like many Warners 30's films its barely over an hr and parts of the story seem left on the cutting room floor or are not fleshed out properly. For example, its never explained why Francis is hiding out with Cortez on his boat in the beginning. Francis is not particularly believable as a Russian on the lam in the Orient, but she is effective playing the part, as long as you don't dwell on her background for too long. The first part of the film is very entertaining and risqué, its a shame it switches gears once Kay takes off for Mandalay. Kay wears some fab gowns and is always watcheable. She gets to sing too(probably dubbed), but 3 times for the same song is a little much. This role was originally intended for Ruth Chatterton, whom I cant picture playing it. Its campy fun and Kay is Kay. Watching her can be addicting........

Mandalay is the kind of exotic pre-code potboiler that is fun to watch even though none of it can be taken seriously. Perhaps that's the reason it is so entertaining, in a predictable sort of way.

Much of it is set in Rangoon, with lovely Kay Francis head-over-heals in love with heel Ricardo Cortez. Since it is Cortez, and he specialized in playing smooth cads, it isn't long before Francis is heart broken and soon working as a courtesan in a dive run by Warner Oland, always impressively menacing as a villain.

Francis' character becomes something of a local legend called Spot White, and soon she makes enough cash from men to be on her way out of the dive and in a boat on her way to Mandalay. There she meets nice but alcoholic doctor Lyle Talbot, not long before that rat Cortez shows up again. We'll leave it there for the story line.

Michael Curtiz directs it all at a fast pace, Francis gets to fashion some lovely gowns and wide brimmed hats (which her female fans demanded of her) and Cortez, as always, is a convincing louse. The film runs not much past an hour, which helps, and has a true pre-code ending which will not be revealed here. If the film had come out just a year later the ending would have been different, that's for sure.

A decent time waster, with some effectively atmospheric Oriental sets, and rather nicely photographed. Francis fans will have a good time, I feel. For others, a pre-coder that turns a bit soapy in the final half but worth sticking out, if only for that ending.

Mandalay (1934)

There are a few great reasons to see this movie. For one, it's an early Michael Curtiz film (he's the guy who did "Casablanca" and "Mildred Pierce"). Another, it stars the great Kay Francis, who is what we expect from her-charming, intense, subtle, significant. And finally, this is a pre-Code film (barely) with that little edge that makes it fresh. The plot is a bit jarring at first--the leading character played by Francis is Tanya (or Spot White, later) and she is trapped into being a nightclub hostess (and prostitute?). Francis is great at being both the victim and the ultimate in femme fatale (or a woman of power, at least). She's great. The cast around her is strong, too, and the scenes keep changing and evolving, so you have to stay awake to keep up. There is some really fabulous cinematography here, by the great but unheralded Tony Gaudio. One scene uses a mirror in the center of the frame to show one scene while the background shows another, giving us a fast impression of her nightclub. In smaller ways, the camera moves and approaches the key moments with elegance. Other scenes have just a great sense of light and drama (the short part with the turning paddlewheel of the boat at night is great). Everything begins in Rangoon. The scene shifts eventually to Mandalay, which is an inland city in Burma (Myanmar now). It requires a nice boat ride through the jungle, with all sorts of characters along. There are issues of servitude, alcoholism, virtue (as seen by Westerners visiting Asia), and maybe (in a strained way) love. It's a lot of drama and I like it, held in place finally by Francis. And check out the last five seconds. This is truly a pre-code film, and if justice is served in the end, it isn't what the Hays Code would ever have allowed. Sweet

Poor Ricardo Cortez. While undoubtedly a fine fellow in real life, in his reel life of the early '30s, he was almost always a cad, and, more often than not, he paid big time for it. He was very good at being a cad, as demonstrated in "Mandalay." The movie, set in a back lot Rangoon, is snappily directed by Michael Curtiz, who always brought his Hungarian verve to a film (Mildred Pierce, Casablanca, The Sea Hawk, among many). Some of the night club scenes are reminiscent of Josef von Sternberg's exoticisms.

Kay Francis can do no wrong, as far as I'm concerned (and I look forward to reading the new bio "I Can't Wait to be Forgotten"). Those big dark eyes and that velvety voice! And as a character in the film comments, she "certainly can wear clothes."

A lot appealed to me when 'Mandalay' was recommended here to me, in the more like this section. That it was directed by a great director in Michael Curtiz got my interest and seeing the names in the cast interested me further. Do like Kay Francis a lot, though she was often better than her material, Ricardo Cortez always makes for a good villain and Lyle Talbot is good when the role is interesting. The story did sound interesting but was worried about how the melodrama would fare.

'Mandalay' is by no means one of Curtiz's best films, consider it more a little above average minor work. All have done better, but nobody actually is disgraced. It is a great looking film and the performances are good. What is less successful is the story, which starts off good and ends surprisingly but too much of the second half is silly melodramatic soap that lacks surprises and is not as interesting. So 'Mandalay' is a slight mixed bag, with a little more good than bad.

Visually, 'Mandalay' looks wonderful. There is a lot of beautiful photography throughout, there is nothing cheap about the locations and Francis' wardrobe has the wow factor. The music fits the atmosphere well, and the song is a lovely one (the number of times it was used was not necessary though). The script in the first half has snap, bite and fun with a daring edge, while the story was absorbing in the first half. The ending is as has been said very surprising and not what one expects.

Curtiz directs with good skill visually and dramatically, though he didn't seem as engaged once the second half started before the spark came back towards the end. Francis is alluring and sensual, her role is perfect for playing to her strengths and she has no trouble commanding the screen. Talbot is good as a character not near as interesting, he is hardly bland. Cortez is typecast, but it was a character he played very well indeed, which he acts with a sinister touch, and it was clear the studio knew that. Warner Oland also does well and doesn't overdo his part, grate or feels out of place.

On the other hand, the second half isn't as strong. It loses momentum, from a little too much padding, and the dialogue loses its snap, becomes stilted and gets at its worst pretty stupid. The story also gets very soap-operatic and in pure over-heated melodrama fashion and creaks badly, it was like watching another film.

The supporting cast has some interesting names, but only Oland and Ruth Donnelly rise above their material. Everybody else struggles to register as characters that are never really fleshed out and feel like plot devices instead. As said, as lovely as the song is it is too repetitively used.

Concluding, starts well and ends surprisingly but loses its way generally in the second half. Worth seeing for the production values and the three leads. 6/10