The Lie

Viewers must be able to differentiate between good acting and how the movie made them feel! Most parents know exactly that teenage behaviours can be obnoxious and intolerable and watching this movie reminded them of that! That does not mean that the story is not good. In fact the movie poses the very important "what would you do " question.. I am certain that the answers are easier said than done!

This is one of those movies that makes you repeatedly think 'What the hell?' Like the girl running away from the father. She gets away then starts waking down the residential street one block away. Who the hell goes one block away and then out into the open?? And who walks down the middle of the street? I can honestly say that I have never walked down the middle of any street. Then when she sees the car behind her coming fast she starts running while staying in the street. Wtf?? That's this movie in a nutshell. Ridiculous scenarios that are just not believable.

Only real reason I'm writing this is to counter everyone else's absurdly angry reviews. This was a decent story, well acted, and no I didn't know where it was going. I went along with the ride. People are mad at the plot because the parents did stupid things... well, people do stupid things. Isn't that the point? Also, if a movie inspired a reaction from you... isn't that also the point?

I hope the title of the review helps others like me, who go into this expecting a Blumhouse movie released in conjunction with Prime a few weeks before Halloween, to be a scary movie. Now that's put this aside

The cast do their best with this ridiculous plot, that would borderline work as a poor 25 minute episode of Inside Number 9

The writing is pretty dreadful, the direction bland and lacking much in the way of thrills The movie is glacier paced, without the script or character development to hold it up Someone needs to go back to film school - It's so bad the you will see the ending coming within minutes of the incident itself There's no attempt to even throw the viewer in the other direction

I would recommend watching the first 10 mins, then mins 58 to 60, and the last 5 minute and save yourself a precious evening you could be spending on something much more worthwhile

I find it hard to rate a movie when the first ~90% of the film is excellent, well-acted and extremely watchable. I also get very angry when so much effort is made to produce a great film only to ruin it with an ending that's so far-fetched that it feels a troll wrote it.

I was drawn to this film because the premise looked good and one of the leads was Mireille Enos (who I absolutely adore: have seen her work in 'The Killing', 'Hanna', 'Good Omens' and 'World War Z').

Enos, Peter Sarsgaard and Joey King were brilliant and compelling in their performances. The first ~90% of the film was easily an 8 rating. The atrocious ending which lasted (if I recall) about 10 minutes was a 1 rating. The final actions of the daughter were inline with the plot. I didn't have an issue with this and I think most viewers would agree when they really think about it. The entire premise is built around the choices a teen makes...

It is the actions of the parents during the final minutes that leave you questioning the worth of this film.

Should you watch this? I think yes (though my overall rating is a 5 but the first 90% of the film is an 8). The drama is superb, Enos & Sarsgaard were incredible, and out of a 90 minute film - I'm certain you'll love (and be glued into) the first 80 minutes of it. Just be prepared for the crash and burn landing.