Wasted Talent

I loved A Bronx Tale and thought this documentary might be one-sided in favor of Lillo Brancato. However, the director did an excellent job presenting both perspectives, including insights from those close to Lillo and the NYPD officers involved in the tragic incident. I highly recommend this documentary.

It's heartbreaking to see such talent go to waste. Lillo's story is a tragic one, but it's well worth watching. It's a powerful reminder of life's unpredictability and the consequences of our choices. Watch it to believe it! The depth of storytelling truly captivates and leaves a lasting impact.

What a mess. This overall story is a mess. A complete mess. I am not here to share my opinion on whether or not he is guilty or not guilty. I would rather review the documentary overall. I thought the story could have been laid out better. It bounces around from A Bronx Tale, to heroin usage, and then recovery. It's all extremely odd the way it flows. And then the documentary is centered around a group of friends, so being former addicts themselves, trying to clear the name of the main subject. I think that's where the documentary goes wrong. It's not enough interesting content about the character to really hold the viewers attention.

Greetings again from the darkness. The first thing to note here is that the title refers to a young actor who scuttled his career through drug addiction - an addiction which ultimately led to a burglary that ended in tragedy and a prison sentence. What the title doesn't refer to is the police officer who was killed by the actor's associate during that attempted burglary. In my opinion, what was wasted was that officer's life, so no matter how talented and charming and rehabilitated one might find Lillo Brancato, my sympathies were with that police officer's family the entire run time ... not a possible squandered Golden Globe.

The goal here is to set aside personal opinion, and evaluate this documentary from director Steve Stanulis on merit. The subject is Lillo Brancato, the young man "discovered" to star alongside Robert De Niro in A BRONX TALE, the 1993 film that was also De Niro's directorial debut. Mr. Stanulis, himself an actor and filmmaker, has a good grasp of the industry and wisely puts Mr. Brancato front and center so he can tell much of his own story. Lillo recalls in great detail the events that led to his being cast in his first movie, and getting to meet Chaz (Palminteri) and "Bob" (De Niro). He was basically plucked off the beach due to his facial similarities to De Niro, and then proceeded to wow the filmmakers with his natural acting ability. He's also very forthcoming about his drug use (a crack pipe in a car), his ongoing commitment to staying clean in the program, and his desire to continue acting.

Other interviews include journalists, Lillo's "super" attorney Joseph Tacopina (a likely documentary subject himself), other actors including Lillo's friend and co-star from "The Sopranos" Drea De Matteo, Lillo's brother, former NBA player Jayson Williams, and even clips from the District Attorney at the time the case was at trial. Director Stanulis also interviews local cops who make it very clear that the police force remain mad at Lillo, and view him as a privileged kid who wasn't held accountable for the death of one of their own. See, Lillo's friend shot Officer Daniel Enchautegui, and Lillo was charged only with the 2005 burglary, while his friend went to prison for murder. So no, the cops don't believe justice was served.

There are some attempts to couch this as a young guy from the neighborhood making it big and not being able to handle fame and money. Once again, it's difficult to muster sympathy for someone in this situation. It does help that Lillo is so direct about staying clean and sober since November 2006, being released from prison in 2013, and resuming his acting in 2015. He also admits to not heeding the advice from either De Niro or James Gandolfini, both who recognized the dangerous path the young man was on. Fortunately for Lillo, his second chance comes at a time when he's still young enough to enjoy. Sadly, there are no second chances for the officer that was killed that day.

I lost interest in about five minutes. I have no idea who these people are except for Lilo Brancato. Why was an ex-NYPD officer doing a documentary about someone involved in the killing of one of his own? I couldn't get past that. I saw this as a publicity push to shine up Brancato's image and that will never happen. To be sure, many people told him as he spiraled out of control that he was wasting his talent but he CHOSE that path anyway. I want no part of his egocentric comeback. Officer Enchautegui will not have that opportunity.

Poorly made, poorly executed, poor choice of subject. I wonder who paid for this?

Before watching this documentary if anyone would have asked me who Lillo Brancato is I wouldn't be able to answer. Then again I'm not really good in remembering names, and I'm absolutely not interested in celebrity gossip and sorts. But when I saw his face on the screen I remembered him from A Bronx Tale and The Sopranos. But that's about it, never heared about that story where a cop died, couldn't care less if I have to be honest. That aside, this documentary is mostly about Lillo Brancato, about how he became an actor, how he got into drugs and how that lead to that crime. I'm not going to say that there were no interesting parts in this documentary as there were plenty but hearing Lillo Brancato pretending God saved him and that kind of nonsense just had the opposite effect of what I think of this persona now. First I wished he would start acting again, now I couldn't care less if I saw his religious face again on a big screen. He's clearly a bit mentally ill.