decristofaro11
A rejoint le sept. 2007
Bienvenue sur nouveau profil
Nos mises à jour sont toujours en cours de développement. Bien que la version précédente de le profil ne soit plus accessible, nous travaillons activement à des améliorations, et certaines fonctionnalités manquantes seront bientôt de retour ! Restez à l'écoute de leur retour. En attendant, l’analyse des évaluations est toujours disponible sur nos applications iOS et Android, qui se trouvent sur la page de profil. Pour consulter la répartition de vos évaluations par année et par genre, veuillez consulter notre nouveau Guide d'aide.
Badges2
Pour savoir comment gagner des badges, rendez-vous sur page d'aide sur les badges.
Évaluations23
Note de decristofaro11
Avis4
Note de decristofaro11
Many would remember the original 1938 Hitchcock movie, which deserves highest ranking of course, thinkng that this one is light and too 'American'.
But this 1979 release is nice and has a good rhythm and moreover it does not aims to emulate its ancient model.
It is a good comedy rendering of a very good story, with a good usage of the train as action setting.
I do not agree with some low ratings here, which, in my opinion, are due more to Hitchcock model than to this movie itself.
We saw it again in recent 2020s and we had a very good time, with no highbrows attitude of judging it a violation of the 'sacred master' work.
You will enjoy it as a intrigue movie of old times.
But this 1979 release is nice and has a good rhythm and moreover it does not aims to emulate its ancient model.
It is a good comedy rendering of a very good story, with a good usage of the train as action setting.
I do not agree with some low ratings here, which, in my opinion, are due more to Hitchcock model than to this movie itself.
We saw it again in recent 2020s and we had a very good time, with no highbrows attitude of judging it a violation of the 'sacred master' work.
You will enjoy it as a intrigue movie of old times.
This film is really nice, without any anguish nor anxiety.
A necessary little gift these days.
It is a fairly linear film, with no particular jumps: a nice and not-so-young cleaning lady is hired by the art academy in Paris, École des Beaux Arts, and her life changes.
Art and the relative freedom that the teachers always suggest play a not secondary part in the construction of the new "consciousness" reached by our Marie, and this adds a pleasant touch to the story.
It is a film that conveys good humor, with some thoughts too.
The star Karin Viard is really part of the building of this movie, not only in its running time: she is actually present in every scene. But she gently transmits the whole mood of the movie.
You will stay through the credits to see a last scene, and at the end, in the "thanks" section, in facts, you will see that the first thanked name is hers, Karin Viard.
A necessary little gift these days.
It is a fairly linear film, with no particular jumps: a nice and not-so-young cleaning lady is hired by the art academy in Paris, École des Beaux Arts, and her life changes.
Art and the relative freedom that the teachers always suggest play a not secondary part in the construction of the new "consciousness" reached by our Marie, and this adds a pleasant touch to the story.
It is a film that conveys good humor, with some thoughts too.
The star Karin Viard is really part of the building of this movie, not only in its running time: she is actually present in every scene. But she gently transmits the whole mood of the movie.
You will stay through the credits to see a last scene, and at the end, in the "thanks" section, in facts, you will see that the first thanked name is hers, Karin Viard.
This "Chained" is very well realized: you FEEL everything, you are there, spying the life of this man which is behaving in the most wrong ways you could imagine, without any help to recover.
So it is like a "documentary", perfect in its representation and in transmission of the tragedy, but... I think that stories, and so movies too, should be better than life: they should give audience some directions to become better people, making see how a character could change his behaviour, his ideas, in order to quit despotism, machism, cruelty and egotism, reaching some empathy with all beloved significant others, wife and step-daughter.
Here we follow the tragical crumbling of the life of a policeman, which is obviously wrongdoing at many levels, professional, personal and sentimental... and nobody helps him.
So I think that this total despair is strongly wrong in a work of art.
So it is like a "documentary", perfect in its representation and in transmission of the tragedy, but... I think that stories, and so movies too, should be better than life: they should give audience some directions to become better people, making see how a character could change his behaviour, his ideas, in order to quit despotism, machism, cruelty and egotism, reaching some empathy with all beloved significant others, wife and step-daughter.
Here we follow the tragical crumbling of the life of a policeman, which is obviously wrongdoing at many levels, professional, personal and sentimental... and nobody helps him.
So I think that this total despair is strongly wrong in a work of art.