Avis des utilisateurs

Good cast of strong women characters in an uneven plot and pacing, though enjoyable narrative I learned from. But the ending was rushed. Still, I'm glad I watched it.

The Palestinian film 3000 Layla was shown in the U.S. with the translated title, 3000 Nights (2015). It was written and directed by Mai Masri.

The movie stars the wonderful actor Maisa Abd Elhadi as Layal, a young Palestinian teacher who is arrested, "tried," and convicted of a crime she didn't commit. In fact, there's not any real evidence that any crime was committed at all. (Layal is tried by an Israeli military court, where the conviction rate is 99%, so it's not really a trial.)

She is sent to prison for eight years (3000 nights). When she learns that she is pregnant, no mercy is shown to her. In fact, all four of her limbs are chained when it's time to deliver the child. The child, Nour, is a source of comfort to Layal and her cellmates, but there's very little comfort to be found elsewhere in the prison. The prison guards are brutal, as are the Israeli inmates of the jail. The Palestinians in the jail are political prisoners, but the Israeli prisoners are true criminals. Sadly, instead of making common cause with the Palestinian prisoners, the Israeli prisoners join the guards in harassing them.

This movie has the sense of a documentary about it, but it's not the story of any one woman. It's a composite of the many horrors endured by Palestinian political prisoners in Israeli jails. The movie was filmed in a abandoned prison in Jordan, so it's a real prison, not a studio set.

The acting in this film is extraordinary. The actors' portrayal of strong, determined women who have very few options is exceptional. Maisa Abd Elhadi is a great actor, and I would love to see more of her films. (She has appeared in over a dozen feature films and TV series.)

We saw this film at the excellent Little Theatre in Rochester, New York. It was shown as part of Rochester's Fifth Annual Witness Palestine Film Festival. The organizers arranged to bring Hana Chamoun to Rochester to discuss the movie. Hana Chamoun has a supporting role as Fidaa, a Palestinian prisoner whose sister is in jail with her. She told us that the filming in a real jail was harrowing, because the atmosphere of captivity surrounded them. She herself became so emotional about one scene in the movie that she was psychologically shaken by a sense that the reality of her life was blurring with the reality of the film.

This movie will work well on a small screen. However, it hasn't been officially released in the U.S., and there's no DVD available. I hate to review a movie and call it a must-see film if you can't see it! However, if it's eventually released in the U.S., be sure to find it and watch it. You'll be saddened, but not disappointed.

It is the best movie I have ever seen. It is based on true story and showing today's reality and brutality as well. 3000 Nights is a gripping portrayal of selflessness and sacrifice, resonating with the powerful theme of resistance as strong women fight against injustice. It's a true story that mirrors today's harsh realities, though a minor love story adds a touch of humanity. Time slips away as you're drawn into their world, making it an unforgettable cinematic experience. Fear and hope are expertly woven together in this movie, which has a deep effect on those who see it. Incredible writing and great acting make 3000 Nights a great example of how strong the human spirit can be when things go wrong.

I loved the acting and the producing part. I have learned a lesson on the barbaric Israeli history. This made me feel so sorry for the innocent Palestinians that are prisoned for no reason but defending their land against the colonial occupier. Its a touching story that I recommend others to watch to learn more on history from true stories. This is the first time I see a Palestinian movie and I think its a amazing. Now I clearly understood why are hostages taken, in order to free the innocent people that are prisoned against all human rights laws in this planet. Israel is apartheid colonial occupier state.

I guess the bar for propaganda isn't very high anymore...

This movie was intentionally made to support a one sided narrative while utterly demonizing the other side. Even the movie alone for it cinematography isn't even worth the time it takes to get through the opening credits. No, this is just another agenda pushing piece poorly disguised as artistic expression in the hopes of garnering support, for which many will inevitably fall for no doubt.

This is the first film that I have scored above 8 ever. The issue of political prisoners (usually charged on arbitrary and fake evidence, by brutal and barbaric regimes) is regrettably today more common both in numbers of innocent victims and regimes that use this hideous practice routinely. Because of the global diversification of the news coverage of the world, for the first time ever in the history of man, our knowledge is not constrained by the media of specific regimes and races etc., Hence we (the world) can view this malicious practice objectively and hence strip the foolish national and commercial propaganda of particularly the states or businesses that pretends to be "moral, honest, or civilized" out and view this practice objectively wherever it occurs.

From the above point of view, I must congratulate the director, script writer, actors in this movie. The dialogue (as translated during the dubbing process") is excellent, unemotional, but very direct, to the point and so constructed that the physical and emotional impact thereof poignant.

The brutality of practice of holding political prisoners is also excellently portrayed by the physical environment of incrassation, and the barbaric sadism of the captors and their officials.

What made this film exceptional is the absence of sentimentality of the events by just concentrating on the relevant facts.

Again, to the team that made this film I must express thanks and wish them well for the future.