Avis des utilisateurs

Although it seems like a new and different proposal, it ends up falling into the most common clichés in Mexican films. The main plot is not very well defined, and whatever it was, it ends up being slow and cheesy, it has many unnecessary scenes that do not add anything to the story, some performances are bad, several things are not funny, the love story does not develop . Some characters are poorly written, they even seem like extras, despite that it becomes entertaining, has a good message about following your passions and is not so absurd.

I think that it is highly overrated by the public since everything that happens in the film seems indifferent to me. Simply boring.

The movie is the remake of 3 idiots but not very lengthy . It is of 1.48hr not bad but also not good. Good music , come to age movie, watch this to your children but there is some comedy which are not comedy but it is unsuitable for child. Some not more. Watch the film. Not worst,not best. Medium.

Bad copy of a great Indian movie. The same recycled actors and actress. The same cheap humor of "the new Mexican cinema"

Please, if you're of another country don't think that Mexicans are as weak as this movie in every sense is.

It's sad because there are a lot of talented young people in my country wishing an opportunity to do something new, but in México all of what matters is the money

Good try for remake 1×movie but original is 100×movie I am Indian and all Indian 80% people favourite movie 🍿

In general, this film seems an episode of a corny soap opera, at least a well made one, the message they seek to give to the viewer is invaluable. Unfortunately the story wasn't developed in the best way.Anyway I will give it six stars for the pretty woman. Have fun watching it guys!

I saw the film this past weekend in Austin, Texas with my gal who is from Honduras and the theater had quite a few Espanol speakers in the audience and everyone liked it. It has laughs, seriousness, and sadness and love moments in the script, and I thought the actors did a good job. Who cares if it is a remake? It was made to appeal to a Latin American audience. I think Lionsgate made a wise decision in distributing this film to an American audience, obviously they see something in the film that other critics do not. Do not be swayed by negative criticism and go enjoy the movie, I know I did, and I lived in Chihuahua, Mexico for two years and I am a Gringo and I do not think it is a substandard film from Mexico or a waste of money at all. Go see it and you be the judge.

These 2 movies shouldn't be compared, the Indian one uses Aamir Khan in a very high career position in a very developed industry with 7 times the budget. For latin-america is almost a miracle this exists, the usual budget for this kind of movies is 1 to 1.5 millions, and the script, planning and music is very simple. Yes, it falls very far from the original but it is a very good starting point. I celebrate they try to follow the original usually the industry here just takes the original concept and scraps the rest. Besides, It is nice they run a movie with this topic that is not violence or poor vs rich. Finally, they develop a little more the love story which is not very developed in the indian one.

Congrats guys, well done! Perfect acting for the title and story of the movie. No other actor would have done a great job as your guys. Adding it to my collection!

At its core, "3 Idiotas" revolves around the reunion of three college friends-Pancho (Alfonso Dosal), Felipe (Christian Vazquez), and Beto (German Valdez). The narrative unfolds as they embark on a road trip in search of their long-lost friend, Chava (Paulina Davila), who disappeared years ago. The journey becomes a catalyst for self-discovery and a reflection on the unorthodox philosophy imparted by their absent friend during their college days.

One of the film's strengths lies in its ability to balance humor with poignant social commentary. The comedic elements are skillfully woven into the narrative, providing lighthearted moments that resonate with the audience. The chemistry among the lead actors, particularly Dosal, Vazquez, and Valdez, contributes significantly to the film's charm, making their camaraderie both believable and endearing.

Bolado's direction breathes new life into the familiar narrative, infusing it with vibrant Mexican cultural references. The picturesque landscapes and vibrant cinematography enhance the visual appeal, creating a cinematic experience that is both visually engaging and emotionally resonant. The decision to adapt the story to a Mexican context adds layers to the narrative, making it relatable to a broader audience while retaining the essence of the original material.

The film's exploration of the pressure and expectations associated with the education system is particularly relevant. Through the characters' experiences in college, "3 Idiotas" delves into the societal demands placed on individuals to conform to traditional paths of success. The critique of a rigid education system that prioritizes grades over holistic learning is conveyed with humor and sensitivity, prompting viewers to reflect on their own perceptions of success and happiness.

The character dynamics are a highlight of the film. Pancho's rebellious spirit, Felipe's pursuit of artistic passion, and Beto's comedic innocence create a trio that embodies the spirit of non-conformity. Each character undergoes significant growth throughout the journey, and their individual arcs contribute to the overarching theme of self-discovery and authenticity.

The film also introduces a love story that adds a layer of emotion to the narrative. Chava's character serves as a symbol of pursuing one's dreams against societal expectations, and her relationship with Pancho adds a poignant element to the storyline. The romantic subplot is delicately handled, complementing the broader themes of the film without overshadowing the central focus on friendship and self-realization.

Musically, the film embraces a vibrant soundtrack that complements the narrative. The use of music, including popular Mexican tracks, enhances the cultural resonance of the film and contributes to the overall atmosphere. The soundtrack not only accompanies the characters' journey but also becomes a character in itself, evoking a range of emotions that enrich the viewing experience.

In conclusion, "3 Idiotas" (2017) successfully adapts the core elements of the original narrative into a Mexican context, delivering a film that is both entertaining and thought-provoking. Bolado's direction, coupled with the stellar performances of the cast, brings a fresh perspective to the timeless themes of friendship, individuality, and the pursuit of one's passions. The film's ability to seamlessly blend humor with social commentary makes it a standout contribution to the cinematic landscape, resonating with audiences who appreciate a heartfelt and culturally resonant story.