Avis des utilisateurs

The crimson field is brilliant.

I usually don't watch shows like this because it tends to be too gory for me but there is some violence and some gore but it isn't over the top. I throughly enjoy the characters because you can hate them one episode and love them the next!

It's a sympathetic show and also a very realistic portrayal of what the time would have been like.

I think that anyone who watches this would thoroughly enjoy it because of how well the actors and actresses portray their parts, the suspense and excitement will capture in the first episode.

I would recommend! I look forward to this every week!

The Crimson Field has been such a beautiful series, at times reducing me to tears, all the actors have done a brilliant job in bringing the story alive. I really hope that there is another series or 3! I feel there is so much more for all the characters to tell. We have had a glimpse into what it would have been like 100 yrs ago, the V A D's , nurses and surgeons worked wonders in such difficult conditions. All the actors deserve credit, I wan't to hear all their stories, and the fizzing will they /won't they romance between Tom and Kitty has kept us on tender hooks! The writers have done a wonderful job, Sarah Phelps has real talent in making us believe anything that she writes.

Sarah Phelps has written a new perspective on WWI that is intelligent, humorous, compassionate and poignant. While it is from the point of view of nurses and VAD's in WWI, the experiences of the soldiers who are their patients, and that of the other men on staff, are given equal attention.

Each major character has a depth of storyline that still has not been fully revealed (writing this review after viewing S1Ep5). I've been counting the days until the next episode airs, eager to learn more about what past events has shaped each of these very well drawn, fully realized people. Above all, this is where the uncommon strength of this series lies. I hope that we get to see these wonderful characters proceed through to 1918.

All of the actors are very talented and a joy to watch, but most especially newcomer Richard Rankin. His character, the Scottish surgeon Capt. Thomas Gillan, is explosive, passionate and conflicted.

I completely agree with previous reviewers that favored director Richard Clark's episodes, his vision is truly beautiful.

I posted a version of this review in episode 1 reviews but I have expanded it somewhat as it is also an accurate review of the series and all episodes I have watched thus far.

I thoroughly enjoyed the premiere episode of The Crimson Field as well as all subsequent episodes. I am on pins and needles waiting for the season finale to see how many plot points can be wrapped up yet still leave us wanting more. It is an intriguing and refreshing premise to watch a show focused mainly on how women cope with the realities of a front line field hospital in WWI. It is a period deserving of special attention during this centenary year. It is also a period that has become more familiar to general viewers through Downton Abbey(Season 2) and The Crimson Field almost seems a logical progression from some of the events exposed in that drama.

I have thoroughly enjoyed seeing the characters of The Crimson Field develop under the deft and expert writing of Sarah Phelps' scripts. The work of the directors, Richard Clark in particular with episodes 3&4, have shown a lot of finesse in crafting an hour of TV that tugs on your heartstrings and effortlessly draw you into the world and the struggles of the inhabitants living and working so close to the front lines.

The early promise in the performances of relative newcomers such as Oona Chaplin (Game of Thrones) and Richard Rankin has been more than fulfilled. There is one episode yet to go but I am already convinced that a second season is absolutely required. Viewers will not be ready to leave the world and characters so expertly portrayed after a single season.

I am really loving this series, and hoping it not only is renewed for a second season but is picked up in the US. The portrayals of each character are great, and we see them as they are revealed layer by layer. Also like that they are not black-and-white, cardboard people, but layered and ones we grow to care about and respect. The sets and action are true to the time period, well devised and shown. Crossing my fingers to see more... I find Richard Rankin's portrayal especially good. He is a doctor who is more progressive that many of his "superiors" but also from a lower social class than most, so he fights a double battle. The support he receives from the Lt. Col. Roland Brett (head doctor played by Kevin Doyle) and Brett's own struggle with what's good for the patient vs. the Army wanting to put men back out in the field is well-portrayed. I'm liking very much the lives of the nurses and VAD's. Oona Chaplin is Kitty, a VAD with a secret and spectacularly shows the emotions boiling under her very controlled surface. The other nurses and VAD's all have their own secrets and these are slowly being revealed. All in all, excellent series. Hoping to hear the BBC has renewed it soon.

I could see where this could of been an amazing show, but it really ended up being more of a soap opera with the odd sexual romp between nurses and doctors, and the tormented looks of anguished pasts on the faces on some of the characters is overdone. I think nobody does period drama better than the UK, but this was isn't one of those for me. I think if you wanted light entertainment about the personal lives of the nurses entwined with love and romance this would be an ideal show. They also added the bad guy character into the plot as well. The acting is good according to the scripts given to them, but there really wasn't anyone that stood out. I find the same actors appearing in British shows whether it is a murder mystery, police drama or historical piece. I have seen the character that lost his legs in two separate Poirot movies, and I am sure a Midsomer Murder here and there.

BBC One needs to be much more attentive to highlighting the work that is being accomplished in this show, to draw in a much wider audience. I have thoroughly enjoyed watching The Crimson Field. It has been a delight to be introduced to so many actors and actresses who are so very talented. To be able to portray each story line, to actually get the underlying feelings and angst across in each episode in such a short time is difficult under the best of conditions. Some of the best stories from history are those of people who were not in the lime light, as that is how you get the best "feel" for how "real" people dealt with "real" life without boring the viewer to tears. The story line is quite believable, and the interaction between and amongst the principle characters is quite spot on. Modern viewers who are easily disappointed by "not enough action" or "not enough gore" or something equally compelling need to remember that, during this period, things were much simpler and people were still functioning around stereotypes and clichés. News from the rest of the world was *not* instantaneous as it is now, therefore watching a period piece with hindsight is really quite unfair to all involved in the production. To be able to portray so much within a short period of time requires all involved to be succinct and on-point ... which this series is. Now it needs to be available in the US *and* we need to have at least another 3 seasons to be able to properly follow these story lines to their conclusions.

This is a third-rate British costume/period drama of the sort that PBS swoons for; unfortunately it's cheaply produced and--at a time when the film version of Testament of Youth has been just released--shockingly bad by comparison. This is really about a field hospital's bunch of nurses and their romances and feuds. Occasionally a wounded Tommy drops in for colorful effect. Many close-ups of agonized female faces, all in emotional pain. At the very least see the movie of Testament. Much better would be to read Vera Brittain's book, which is as good as or better than the traditional 'must read' of WWI, Robert Graves's Goodbye To All That.

As a fan of period dramas, I knew The Crimson Field would be up my street, but I have really loved every second of this and will be devastated if this is the only series. The mix of well known actors and new faces was inspired casting and I've been hooked by all the characters and the back stories which emerged over the first couple of episodes. Still so much to be resolved and only one episode left. How can this be?? Richard Rankin and Oona Chaplin deserve special mention for their sizzling tension and I would love them to have their happy ending! But as a seasoned drama addict, I know that what the viewer wants isn't always what is delivered by the writer. Talking of the writer, Sarah Phelps has excelled herself in creating this and I really hope the BBC see sense and commission at least one more series to bring her remaining ideas to life.

The Crimson Field is an extremely well written drama about a WWI field hospital. It doesn't focus on the war & fighting, so don't look for that. This drama focuses on the nurses, doctors, patients and volunteers. Sarah Phelps has written episodes that leave you intrigued and emotionally involved in the characters; your heart will break for them and you will find yourself rooting for love to win in the end. The actresses and actors do an amazing job portraying their characters, a better cast couldn't have been chosen! My personal favorite episodes thus far are 3 & 4, directed by the talented Richard Clark. I am desperately hoping BBC announces that season 2 will be filmed.

I rate The Crimson Field with 'Call the Midwife' and 'Downton Abbey.' It is British drama at its best with a fantastic cast of those some of you may remember from other shows. However, there is no stereotype in their roles from previous shows. Truly remarkable acting. What is equally important is that the show is true to the actually happenings, both from a historical point of view as well as social. The war itself was a slaughterhouse due to the ineptitude of the British and French generals and senior officers. Some of which is depicted in the series. It was a hundred years ago that the war began and truly didn't end until 1945. Again, the result of the British and French generals seeking retribution from Germany when the armistice took place.

The Crimson Field has been such an amazing series to watch and I cannot believe the final episode is tomorrow! The actors have done a brilliant job, contrasting drama and humour well! Sarah Phelps has created such a different and fresh look on the role that women had to play in World War One. Each episode changes your feelings about each character and the many stories taking place within the general story makes it that much more enjoyable to watch. Every character have different qualities that are either subtle or obvious meaning that each week of the series, when new characteristics are shown, new characters become your favourites and your old favourites become your least. Because your opinions change, and even though the general story is carried on and romances/relationships between the characters are continued, plots to each episodes are different making the show never boring. Definitely recommended and I will be so upset if I hear the BBC haven't renewed it.

The Crimson Field does what other shows fail to do: it sheds light on an area of an era that is rarely seen, centering around three dimensional female characters, all of which are different in their own rights. It is incredibly unfortunate that this television show was axed by BBC before it could round out any story lines. But the 6 episode first season is an incredible watch nonetheless. The writing is impeccable, thanks to the talented Sarah Phelps, and the episodes are beautifully shot and directed, two of which are done by Richard Clark, director of episodes of Doctor Who and Outlander. The actors are spot on and give life to the characters. Watch for Richard Rankin as Captain Thomas Gillan, a hot headed Scottish surgeon who has eyes for VAD Kitty Trevelyan, played by Game of Thrones alum Oona Chaplin, against his better judgement. This show will have you laughing and crying and feeling things, which is basically why we watch television, isn't it?

God what a lot of cream puff reviews have been published here. I think the Crimson Field drama comprises modern carbon cut out characters. They are not believable. The script produces a WWW/Facebook/Twitter version of the 1914-14 war.

I think it is important we look at what people were writing and actually saying back which 'acclaimed' writer Sara Phelps singularly failed to do. Has she read a single book from that era? Sadly you can tell a mile off the woman involved in this modern look at WW1 has been deeply involved in 50 Episodes of EastEnders.

Why has the BBC 'modernised' historic dramas instead of using genuinely used phrases and words? We have been writing endless films/dramas since the end of that war and recently the lion's share of BBC dramas have been pretty crappy knock about scripts like this.

The way they speak is nothing like and I mean nothing like the way people wrote and spoke during that period. So this modern UK drama is a slap in the face to even the simple use of English of that era. If you want to actually read and hear what they wrote find a way to watch ITV's The Great War: The People's Story. This is way, way better and will move you to tears. Just don't believe they spoke then like the way they do in this drama. Read a few diaries. And to think the BBC has asked Phelps to 'adapt' Agatha Christie. I can't wait.

Within the first minutes of watching this series I knew that I was hooked. It gives an honest representation of life in the war hospitals of Northern France during the First World War. While many depictions of war-time focus on the absolute patriotism of those involved, this series shows that lines do get blurred when individual, real people are involved. The impeccable production is what initially catches your attention, but then an outstanding cast brings the writing of Sarah Phelps to life. The dynamic relationships between the characters means that there is truly something for everyone to love in this show. In fact, I would argue that it has a lot in common with the massive hit show, Downton Abbey, as it explores many of the same themes though in a completely unique way. Where D.A. explores the realities of hierarchy in early 20th century British society, The Crimson Field does the same with the ranking within the army and hospital camps. Also present are complicated love stories, a discussion of homosexuality, loyalty and duty, one's honour, and so much more! Truly, this is one of the greatest television shows that I have seen of late. If you feel as I do, passionately about great TV, please head to ipetitions and sign to have the BBC recommission this show!

I loved the reviewer who said it needs a "lighter touch"-- it's WW1----- that's what war is like!!!! That's how nurses treat one another and are treated by their supervisors. I can't imagine a "lovely war" I found it extremely realistic and moving. I've only just started watching, but I know that I would like to watch it until the end. It's a tribute to the young women and men during WW1-not just some war romance. I worked as an OR nurse for 30 years--not a romantic or glamorous job, but very tough on the ego and emotions. I really found this to be a great tribute. Great acting, as well. It's very well done, and we need to remember The War To End All Wars! Ha!

If you are like me, a period drama addict, look no further. The show features three women of different backgrounds who are stationed at a field hospital in France to start their voluntary work as VADs (voluntary aid detachment).

The first episode gives you an insight of life at a field hospital, where the doctors and nurses are as much center of the storyline as are their patients. Karl Davis as Cpl. Prentiss only one of the many patients, whose story will break your heart. The first episode is just as gripping as the following 5 episodes. I don't want to give away too much, but expect to be taken on a roller coaster ride of the good kind.

The Crimson Field is my 20th century 'Pride & Prejudice', featuring the Scottish Mr. Darcy actor Richard Rankin as surgeon Capt. Thomas Gillan and Oona Chaplin as VAD Kitty Trevelyan. Only two actors of a great cast that make this show so special. Keep a look out for Mr. Rankin. This is just the beginning.

Can't believe this miniseries didn't get the best ratings ever. Either Brit audiences are drinking too much or it was due to a lousy time slot... hopefully not the decision of some psychotic executive. Crimson is as fine a drama as BBC has ever produced. Hopefully some other network will resurrect it... and the cast and crew can be reassembled. A big raspberry to BBC!

Admittedly, the drama here is flamboyant and the tone is mildly but definitely anti-authoritarian. Perhaps 2014 audiences weren't able to handle its antiwar theme what with ISIS reaching its peak. But the plots are so gripping, the acting superb, the realism so real... simply a beautifully made series.

I really am enjoying this show and while I am not sure if it is meant to continue I hope it gets another season. I love history especially if there is a military aspect to it. This show is one of the more realistic dramas of any kind that I have seen with a military backdrop. We have all seen shows where something happens that is such a huge gaffe or unrealistic thing or often an over the top portrayal of a stereotypical military member that you realize it is a show and it ruins the moment.

I am about 20 minutes from the end and so far I haven't seen anything that makes me think OK that is garbage can't happen, wouldn't happen or that person wouldn't really be like that. Unfortunately on many occasions shows that are pretty accurate can also be a bit boring. This one isn't

Another reviewer used the word sympathetic and I think for me that is right on the money. Even some of the less likable characters are at least a bit sympathetic. You may not like the person but you get where they are coming from.

Anyhow, great cast, great topic, great story line and thoroughly enjoyable and great to watch. I only wish US made shows would tackle things like this instead of oversexed lawyers or horrible housewives of some godawful place. I feel like these kinds of shows really help us understand at least a bit the life and times of those before us.

A small example of that is most of history's shows put Germans of WW1 and WW2 in Grey uniforms. This is the first show in my memory that correctly shows the color of a German field uniform. Small think but it shows they did their homework.

Whoever produced, directed, and played in this show I hope it continues but even if it doesn't I hope you know you did an amazing job and I was totally engrossed in the movie and I thank you. If a grouchy Marine can enjoy a show with a bit of smooching and a couple character arcs that make you sad and still enjoy it, I think it should certainly be a great show for some of you more cultured folks. Give it a shot I am absolutely certain that if this topic intrigues you, you will enjoy Crimson Field.