This Isn't Funny

As others have said, not a simple, formulaic rom-com. Sharp writing in general, with a few minor storylines weaved into the main plot. Script and staged comedic bits were consistently funny. Would have given this a 9, but the musical intrusions were horrendously loud relative to the rest of the scenes. Perhaps they teach this sound-editing technique in film school - going from normal to SUDDENLY LOUD to normal - as a method of prodding the audience's interest. And it might work in a big theatre setting - maybe - but it's absolutely ridiculous for anyone viewing a Blu-Ray or streaming at home. Prepare to keep your volume remote handy so you can compensate a couple dozen times during the film.

Greetings again from the darkness – from the Dallas International Film Festival. Yes, it is funny. And it's also not funny. This little relationship gem breaks down into 3 chapters … conveniently and obviously noted with title placards: Before, Together, After.

The story follows Juice Bar manager Jamie and stand-up comedian Eliot as their worlds literally collide in a chance meeting that doesn't, on the surface, set the stage for love ever after. Director and co-writer Paul Ashton plays Jamie and co-writer Katie Page plays Eliot, and their natural on screen rapport comes courtesy of their real life relationship (as they disclosed in the post screen Q&A).

Don't mistake this for some simple rom-com. There is a lot going on here and it swirls around not just their budding romance, but also their individual lives. It's very interesting how the story offers commentary on such topics as how young adults still use their parents as an excuse for their own lack of career success and/or happiness. In an interesting twist, it also allows us to view those same parents as real people with their own issues, rather than just a drag on the "kids". And speaking of parenting, Jamie and Eliot go through some rather unique soul-searching on the topic.

If that's still not enough subject matter for you, we also witness Eliot's struggles with anxiety. Her trips to a therapist are a battleground for medication levels – Eliot wants to be free of them, and wonders if they are a crutch or actually help. No judgments here, just wonderful material for further discussion.

On top of all that, we are treated to some sterling stand-up from Beth Stelling and Ahmed Bharoocha who are both extraordinarily talented comics. Plus Ms. Page more than holds her own at the microphone, as she brings Eliot's personal life (and poor Jamie's mishaps) to her material. It's a joy to see an indie with such depth, insight and commentary on what relationships are like in today's ever-changing world.

I'm not sure where the title comes from, but the stand-up comedy that makes up a fully 25% of the film is funny. Maybe it's not the funniest stand-up you ever heard, but it is better than average, and it's more than interesting to watch the lives of the performers and then listen to their stand-up routines.

The two lead actors are more than adequate, and the supporting cast is excellent. The story itself is compelling though some of the "chance" encounters stretch credulity. The director keeps the action moving right along

Definitely worth watching.

Perfect title. It isn't funny.

They were right. Thanks for the warning. I should have listened.

Yep it's not funny at all and the jokes about rape are horrible