Avis des utilisateurs

At first looked like a cliche cop comedy with a super weird brother and a super smart sister duo cop but that was not the case. The good and funny dialogue, good acting and a very well write storyline in each episode make this a very entertaining and funny serie.

The sibilings cops (Leighton Meeister and Luke Cook) have a good chemistry and are very funny. The supporting cast are good too and specially the chief's russian wife (Blazey Best) is hilarious.

This is a goodhearted comedy without gross and violence who emphasize family bounds and good nature. I hope there will be a second season for this show.

I had a sense that this show would be ok, but I wasn't prepared to like it this much. It has something I am not sure what it is, it's easy, light, kind, charming, whatever it is, the first episode made me feel good about it and myself. I hope it will get better or at least not get worse. I loved the characters and the dialogue...after hundreds of too dark too violent shows something like this feels even more human in a good way. I love the jokes, the interactions, the setting is very nice, the only problem I have is with a few minor characters but I think they will fall into place going forward.

I just finished watching the first episode, and I have to say, it's off to a pretty intriguing start! Every time Henry appeared on screen, I couldn't help but think, "This is exactly how Sheldon Cooper would act if he grew up and became a cop." The character's quirky, analytical, and socially awkward demeanor really gives off those Young Sheldon vibes, but in a fresh and entertaining way. It's like seeing Sheldon trade in his theoretical physics for a badge and a patrol car, and honestly, it works surprisingly well. While the comparison is hard to ignore, it doesn't take away from the show's charm-it actually adds a layer of humor and relatability. I'm curious to see how Henry's unique personality will play out in the context of police work and how it will clash or mesh with the other characters. For now, I'm hooked and definitely planning to keep watching. The show has potential, and I'm excited to see where it goes from here.

I forgot the last time I watched Leighton's show, maybe the movie with Adam Slander, I remembered that she is very pretty but didn't know she is actually very good at acting. Seriously, she is fun, pretty, natural and loveable. And Luke is also very good, this role could easily go to another way, which is the super annoying way....but he pull it off, he is funny!

Side cast are all very typical nerd type, which is a bit too much but overall they are not annoying, so I am OK with it.

I like that the cases are not all burtal murder or serious criminal stuff but served as the bridge to link up the relationship between the sister and brother.

The only thing I dont like is Shane, he is too young for Lou, they look like 10 years between them, so I am not hoping or waiting or longing for them to fall in love.

A wholesome, wonderful little show that proves sometimes the simple pleasures are the most satisfying. The chemistry between Leighton Meester and Luke Cook is excellent-they convincingly embody siblings with such natural rapport that it spills over into their real-life press appearances, which actually inspired me to watch the show in the first place. Clancy Brown delivers a relatable performance as the patriarch, perfectly capturing that small-town nepotism mixed with benevolent corruption.

This isn't an instant hit, cult classic, or high art-but it doesn't need to be. It's just genuinely charming, endearing, and just funny enough to keep you coming back. Sometimes that's exactly what you need.

I was never a fan of Leighton Meester previous TV series, so I was skeptical of this one at first.

The other thing that usually puts me off these types of TV shows is that there are enough "cop shows" out there for a lifetime. And most of them aren't "entirely original". In fact, I always have an impression that, with the rarest of exceptions, all American TV Shows are either about "cops" (detectives, FBI, spies, etc) or "doctors" or "lawyers", like there isn't any other people worth writing about.

But this show is just wonderful. It's surely entertaining, with new angles and ideas about the "cop" theme. It's also very very funny without being silly.

And, of course, Leighton shines bright in it with a healthy dose of charm and wit. The other characters are also very well cast and well written, so we can divide our attention equally and the show is never in risk of feeling boring soon.

Looking forward to the next few episodes already. Highly recommended.

Good Cop Bad Cop grabbed me from the start. The Hickman family dynamics are genuinely entertaining and meaningful, making even the lighter moments feel worthwhile.

While realism takes a backseat (understandably, given the comedic nature), the humor lands perfectly-I haven't chuckled this much at a show in ages. A refreshing and unexpectedly delightful watch!

Elaborating on the character dynamics - their interactions are not only entertaining but also meaningful, adding depth to the story and making even the lighter, more comedic moments feel worthwhile. You genuinely care about these characters and their connection to each other.

So many shows & films these days rely on cheap gags or predictable setups, but Good Cop Bad Cop manages to be genuinely funny without resorting to these tired tropes or forcibly inserting it into scenes.

It was a refreshing and unexpectedly delightful watch, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a lighthearted and entertaining show.

Didn't make it through episode 2. The brother is unlikable. Leighton Meester was good and could be fun, but the writing is pretty awful. The jokes land flat, the drama is predictable. The family dynamics are forced into to being awkward but are completely unbelievable. I was hopeful because I really like Wild Cards and its high cheese, but this one is not watchable. The premise just doesn't work. The interactions between all of the characters are just weird. No chemistry between any pair and nothing to make you want to keep watching. Normally I give a new show of interest at least 3 episodes before I dump it, but this one had to be dropped immediately.

You see some familiar faces on this show, and the rest of the cast is also fun. The people you might not expect and who don't have recurring roles do a great job and make it consistently funny.

It's a good comedy that makes for a fun series, and while it may seem silly, it's not entirely cringeworthy or forced, if that makes sense. It has some heart, nice stories being built, and also varied personalities that have interesting dynamics.

It has a lot of quirkiness and spectacle, with a talented cast that works well together, and everyone is deadpan funny.

It's a real must-see and enjoy a comedy that will make you laugh and have a good time.

Compliment Sandwich - The show has fantastic production design. It really looks like it's filmed in Seattle. The level of detail here is spot on.

However, the entire show feels like a bunch of Australian c grade actors trying their hand at American accents. It's much too distracting and completely cheapens what could potentially be a good show. I don't see why they couldn't have made it set in Australia.. I assume the actors would have been better at acting if they weren't concentrating on their accents. I also found Leighton Meisters acting fell flat. I just don't think she's a 'tough girl' rough-around-the-edges kind of actress.

The Tamborine Mountain backdrop is nice.

It's fun to see Leighton Meester back in a series again. She and Luke Cook are perfectly cast. Cozy mystery with plenty of humor and interesting supporting characters. Can't wait to see how the rest of the series plays out. The premise is an interesting one, estranged brother and sister reunited since the brother needs a job and is desperate to be a detective. The brother has no social skills but is a savvy detective and the sister is the can-do anything detective who works hard and will be her dad's successor as chief. The acting is strong and there's definitely a romance or two on the horizons for the siblings that will make for interesting storylines.

Leighton Meester and Luke Cook shine so far in this new series. These two are great actors and really sell the sibling dynamics. The characters bring a sense of balance and the supporting cast is a great amount of an extra kick and is complementary to the main detectives. I was laughing and enjoying the dialogue. The humor is injected at good points in the show and keeps the story moving along. I look forward to delving into the relationships and family dynamics as the 2 siblings solve crime and humorously get on each other's nerves. I'm really enjoying bringing together my love of procedural shows while enjoying the comedy break this show brings.

I don't think this show is trying to be anything more than it is. Easy watch, easy premise, and overall enjoyable. Fun detective stories with a brother and sister back and forth - I think in this climate we need stuff that helps us shut off.

I need some fun in my entertainment with a semi predictable storyline's but with a different structure of family. I really hope this show gets picked up and continues. Plus I like anything supporting the Australian filming economy and Australian actors. I think this could be great for numerous reasons. Good fun - give it a try. It's no Sherlock Holmes but it's genuine fun.

Yet another DEI type of show that has little to say, will try to court everyone and no one at the same time. Shallow script, shallow acting, shallow everything. It's supposed to be a cop show but it feels more like a Starbuck's counter. The show takes place in a small city, but everyone looks like they're still having a penthouse in downtown Manhattan. Looks like this show will be canceled twice, once because of ratings, the other time just to confirm the show was actually cancelled. Clancy Brown is a great actor sometimes, but his role here is boring. I would rather watch old episodes of him dubbing Mr Krabs.

Great cast & crew. Super captivating and thought out, Love Leighton Meester back at it. <3. It is an interesting dynamic, with a sister whom is kind & caring, but an eccentic & no social-skilled brother. I would like to see a love interest for both. Their father & his partner are both also equally funny too. Excited for more episodes to come. I really like the scenery & dialouge. The other cast members add charm, As someone who loves crime/thriller & sort of murderous genre department, this blew me away. I hope this can be renewed for a season 2, it only has 8 episodes! Not enough, ha! A must watch.

As with most new shows you expect there to be some time to develop characters and establish the protocols, but this show started well and just got better. The characters are charming and witty and even the misfit brother has some redeeming qualities.

Although the subject matter is heavy, they play it off in a light manner that just adds to the shows demeanor. I especially like the brother/sister play of the two detectives.

If you're looking for dark and meaningful, this show is not for you . . . But if you're looking for fun, and not taking things too seriously, I recommend that you give this show a try.

I'm looking forward to the next episode!

OK, so I have only seen 3 episodes but they have been so consistently good, I am ready to write a review so this gem can build a fan base. The show is genuinely funny but I guess with a "crime of the week" format, it would be classified as a dramedy?? The cases are clever but it is the laughs that warm my heart. The acting is spot-on for all the characters. The dynamic between the title characters is perfect with just enough sibling spice to feel real but a lot of humor too as their personalities clash. Their Dad, the Chief, is also good, and his girlfriend the "Russian wiseass" who owns the town's dance studio is a breakout star. All the supporting characters are "sit-com perfect" and take the show to the next level. Please let a streaming service pick this up!! I have not seen Wild Cards but am jealous that Prime picked it up but did not pick Good Cap, Bad Cop. This show is so good, I even watched two episodes on the CW-online with its obsessive commercials and poor technology just so I could see the episodes I had missed. Give it a try. You won't be sorry.

**Funny with Two of My Favorite Actors**

"Good Cop Bad Cop" on The CW is a refreshing blend of wit, charm, and action that leaves you laughing while keeping you on the edge of your seat. The series stands out for its sparkling dialogue-every line crackles with energy and clever repartee, making the banter between the leads a true highlight. The well-crafted patter not only drives the narrative forward but also infuses the show with a playful, yet sophisticated, sense of humor.

A major draw is undoubtedly the magnetic presence of Luke Cook. His performance is irresistibly sexy and effortlessly cool, adding a layer of charm that elevates every scene he's in. Cook's portrayal of his character is nuanced and compelling; his on-screen chemistry with his co-star is palpable, turning what could have been a standard buddy dynamic into a captivating interplay of lighthearted humor and underlying intensity.

Beyond the laughs and flirtatious glances, "Good Cop Bad Cop" smartly balances its comedic elements with the gritty realities of policing. The show doesn't shy away from exploring the complexities and moral ambiguities of law enforcement, yet it manages to do so without ever sacrificing its signature humor. The result is a series that feels both smart and accessible-perfectly in tune with The CW's blend of drama and quirky charm.

In short, "Good Cop Bad Cop" is a must-watch for anyone who appreciates razor-sharp dialogue, engaging characters, and that rare mix of comedy and drama. With its great patter and the undeniable allure of Luke Cook, the series delivers an entertaining and fresh take on the classic cop story.

Leighton Meester and Luke Cook deliver standout performances that transform what could have been a standard police procedural into something genuinely delightful. This show strikes the perfect balance between humor and heart, making it an ideal unwind-after-work watch that consistently delivers genuine laughs.

While the cases provide adequate framework, the real magic happens in the character interactions. Cook's portrayal is wonderfully eccentric, bringing a unique energy that perfectly complements Meester's more grounded approach.

Clancy Brown adds another layer of comedy gold, and his scenes with his Russian girlfriend are absolute comedic highlights.

The brother-sister dynamic between the leads is what truly elevates the series. Their contrasting detective styles-different observations, opposing tactics-create natural conflict and comedy. Yet beneath their constant bickering lies an unmistakable bond that anchors every episode. They may drive each other crazy, but their deep familial connection makes even their most heated moments feel authentic and ultimately loving.

It's character-driven television at its finest, where the mysteries serve the relationships rather than the other way around.

I came across this show by accident because I like cop shows. It's very funny and has a great cast. The episodes are well written and the jokes are sly and clever. Every episode involves a case that a family of cops has to solve. The family is dysfunctional and all the characters are perfectly developed and interesting. There is directing style to this that I love. It reminds me of the Thin Man films. A charming blend of comedy and intrigue.

The show had relatable characters with each one having some corky personalities. It was funny and just a relaxing kick back and have fun show. Hope to see it return for season two.

The plots were complex enough that in the world of current TV, I am seldom challenged and become knowing who did it/ how it wil end. This show left me guessing the who and or why up until the end.

It started like any other case. A quiet night, the hum of a half-empty coffee pot, and a tip from an anonymous source (read: autoplay on my streaming service). The file landed on my desk with a simple question: "Is Good Cop/Bad Cop any good?"

I lit a cigarette (figuratively - I quit), kicked my feet up, and hit play. What followed was not just a show. It was a breath of fresh air straight through the bulletproof glass of modern television.

Let's break it down.

The Suspects

First up, the leads - Leighton Meester (or however you spell it - let's call her "Charming with Intent") and Luke Cook (a.k.a. "Brother With Bite"). These two? Electric. Not since Starsky and Hutch, or Mulder and Scully if they'd been raised on Pop-Tarts and sibling rivalry, have I seen this kind of chemistry.

They play a brother-sister cop duo with the kind of banter that makes you believe they actually grew up fighting over the last slice of pizza. Cook's character? A whip-smart oddball with a knack for details, like Sherlock Holmes if he grew up in Glendale and learned empathy. He's not "Sheldon Cooper with a badge," though the comparison's tempting - he's more like a cross between Columbo, Monk, and that weirdly perceptive uncle you never fully trust around your toaster.

And Meester? She's the heart of the operation. Funny, grounded, radiates warmth like a heat lamp at a diner booth. She's got the kind of approachable charm that tricks you into thinking, "I could date someone like that." You can't. Don't be ridiculous. She's way out of your league. But go ahead and dream, pal. That's what television's for.

The Scene

This show doesn't try to be gritty. It doesn't want to teach you a moral lesson about systemic corruption or give you a dissertation on trauma. It wants you to have fun. And boy, does it deliver.

The writing is clever. The characters feel lived-in from episode one. The tone? Just the right side of lighthearted, like a fizzy soda pop with a twist of lime. You can watch it with your mom, your kid, or even your super-religious sister who once filed a formal complaint against The Golden Girls for "suggestive cheesecake." It's that clean - and still that good.

It's not a "prestige drama," and thank God for that. Not every show needs to stare into the abyss while quoting Dostoevsky. Sometimes, you just want something smart, sweet, and fun. Something that makes you laugh, makes you care, and lets you sleep easy instead of spiraling into existential dread. That's Good Cop/Bad Cop.

The Motive

Let's be real: television needs more of this. Shows that don't scream at you. Shows that don't drop 47 f-bombs an episode or make you feel like you need a therapist and a translator to keep up. This one's simple, funny, heartfelt, and - rarest of all - original.

The brother-sister cop duo isn't just a gimmick. It's the soul of the show. And every supporting character pulls their weight, too. No dead air. No filler. Just tight pacing, sharp dialogue, and enough charm to melt a polygraph.

Final Report

Verdict: Good Cop/Bad Cop is a refreshing twist on the procedural format - engaging, charming, and clean enough to share with the whole precinct.

I'm filing this one under "Case Closed." And if there's any justice in the world (TV justice, that is), we'll get a second season. Until then, I'm recommending this show to every civilian and off-duty detective I meet.

So consider this your official warning: do not let Good Cop/Bad Cop slip through the cracks. Watch it. Enjoy it. And remember, sometimes the best shows don't wear a badge - they wear a smile.

End of Report.

• Detective Billy, Pop Culture Division.

The first episode is kinda a hard watch, for me anyway, but the more I watch, the better the episodes are getting. So far episode five has been my favorite I think. Just give it a try, it all really starts to grow on you around episode two or three. I *really* hope this show makes it, I haven't been this into a show in years.