En fanfare

I was moved by this film in many ways (even though I saw it dubbed over in German in a German cinema), but one quality stood out to me: the care that had been given to really portraying music in the making: The rehearsal scenes of both the orchestras seemed very real to me, no-one was mimicking to play an instrument, they could all really play and apparently seemed to do so. For real! This is quite exceptional, for it isn't easy to find people who can both act and play an instrument.

The composing scene, with the 'composer' working with pencil and paper on the piano, was the only scene that musically struck me as a bit unrealistic, for it would be hard to find a composer under 50 that doesn't use a computer to write the notes.

It was also really moving to see how even the most different styles in music can travel straight to the heart and have an important function in peoples lives.

For the rest I found the story moving, original and well performed.

This film does not waste time to get into the story and felt a bit rushed but it didn't matter as you do get to know the characters and their motivations in the end. I would say the film is still a bit choppy here and there but it had a lot of emotion and genuinely touching scenes.

By the time the last scene of the film reaches crescendo I could not hold tears. This film is a reminder to us all to remember to show people you care. We all feel that.

On the last note, I can't remember when I saw a French film in the cinema. What a treat. It's very very refreshing to see actors looking like real people with lines on their faces and the odd misaligned teeth. Bravo!

Just watched it on Varilux French Movie Festival in Brazil.

Nice story about bonding with family members, about the "what could have beens" in life.

It's a drama but with warmth and some laughs. Acting of the two main characters are on point, especially the brother played by Pierre Lotin whose role is a somewhat closed person but with good heart.

Believable story without being too dramatic. I really recommend it.

---

Just watched it on Varilux French Movie Festival in Brazil.

Nice story about bonding with family members, about the "what could have beens" in life.

It's a drama but with warmth and some laughs. Acting of the two main characters are on point, especially the brother played by Pierre Lotin whose role is a somewhat closed person but with good heart.

Believable story without being too dramatic. I really recommend it.

Oh how wonderful, a drama/comedy at its best. A country like France is truly a master at this. The actors are absolutely wonderful in their roles. The seriousness and humor are spot on. I really love that mix in a film. You are never disappointed. The film highlights many things that can be crucial in life. Without me revealing anything. After watching a film like this, you are filled with different emotions such as joy, hope and a little bit of sadness. Then the director has succeeded with his film in my opinion. The most important thing about film is that you are touched in one way or another. It is the experience and feelings you carry with you after you have seen a really good film. Watch the film and be touched in your own way.

"Thibaut" (Benjamin Lavernhe) is an accomplished conductor who is now based in the USA but who comes home to France now and again to perform. It's during one such visit that he confides to his sister "Rose" (Mathilde Courcol-Rozés) that he needs a bone-marrow transplant. She readily agrees to help out but when she is found to be incompatible, that news opens quite a can of worms that results in him having to ask "Jimmy" (Pierre Lottin) - a brother he didn't know he had and who lives in a quietly dying town where his workplace is earmarked for closure, to help out. Initially uninterested and disbelieving, the film now illustrates just how the two men come to terms with their past, their present and (hopefully) their future against a backdrop of resentment and privilege as they try to reconcile with the elements of "luck of the draw" that have governed their lives thus far. Fortunately, they have one thing in common. They both love music, and as it transpires that "Jimmy" plays trombone in his local mineworkers band we have a conduit for them to bond - or not! There are shades of "Brassed Off" (1996) as this offers us a social commentary on the decline of traditional rural industries that leave little by way of hope or opportunity in it's wake; a little bit of romance and some seriously horrible uniforms too! Along the way, there is also some fine classical Mozart, some crooning from Charles Aznavour and some enjoyable band rehearsals with an eclectic collection of the townsfolk proving remarkably talented with instrument and voice alike - after a soupçon of guidance. No, there probably isn't so much jeopardy about the denouement, though there is a twist - it's really a story about family and one that's presented without too much sentiment and a bit of enjoyably bloody-minded Gallic humour. I was never quite sure what an orchestral conductor actually did, standing there flailing his baton at a collection of perfectly proficient musicians, but this might just have helped explain a little - and that seating matters too!