Avis des utilisateurs

What a positive surprise. I wouldn't have thought that the ordeals of a fallen noble family could be this captivating. This show explores the hardships of the family's women and children after their clan's men got exiled. In order to overcome this situation, they have to face all of the intrigues and conflicts that could conveniently be ignored during a life of wealthy idleness, but now have to be dealt with in order to utilize everyone's strengths in order to make a living.

Xi Hua Zhi is presenting a healthy mix of different genres. Besides the obvious family drama it tells stories about emotional struggles, business acumen, leadership, politics and balances serious topics with humorous relief and martial arts action. Even (for a Chinese show) unusual topics like disabilities and emancipation are convincingly woven into the storytelling - not in a condescending way as it is the case in most modern tv shows from the west, but in a way that it comprehensively fits even into the setting in the ancient Eastern society. While not all characters presented are fleshed out well, many of them are. Almost every family member (including the maids and concubines) has her own storyline with struggles, and most of them see a healthy share of character development. While the two lead actors do a good job carrying the show, there are a couple of hidden gems in the side character casts that will really get you invested. Most notably the display of the mentally challenged Shaohua, the good-hearted but lazy Baoxia, the self-doubting but highly skilled Fudong, the virtuous Shen Qi or the industrious and resourceful Jin'e are the ones that, imho, stood out the most in terms of acting.

What keeps this show from being 'perfect' are mainly three things. First, a lot of the drama seems just a bit too artificial and constructed. While a lot of the bigger picture leading to the challenges of the family can be explained with politics and the deeply distrustful and hurt personality of the Emperor, some of the things happening 'on-the-side' and some family members' reactions to that seem a tiny bit over the top. Second, especially towards the end of the show, some of the events seem a bit rushed. It feels as if the first half of the books' stories (which I admittedly haven't read) get like 32 episodes of space and the show takes time to explore these moments with the characters, whereas the other half has to be squeezed into the remaining eight episodes. This makes the end seem a bit rushed and, unfortunately also accompanied by the not too uncommon stereotypes (as in: all the girls have to find a husband). There's few expections to this rule in the show, but eventually, I couldn't help but feel like it was forced and thus a bit of missed potential, especially compared to what the story had been telling until then. But does this make it a bad watch? Absolutely not!

Xi Hua Zhi is a great show with a healthy mix of genres, great storytelling and a memorable cast of characters. I'm sure I'm gonna watch it again someday.

I enjoyed this much more than I thought I would. Jingyi Zhang was amazing as the lead actress and honestly, the entire female cast did a wonderful job. At first, I was skeptical about Yitian Hu but he proved me wrong real quick. Plus for some reason he kept getting more attractive with each episode.

All in all, the pacing of the storytelling helps the audience to truly connect with the background of each character, and the interplay of their relationships makes it even more meaningful. It wasn't just about overcoming hardships and situations of uncertainty but about defying certain norms and expectations that not only limit but divide us.

This show was heartwarming, with just the right amount of humor and suspense. My only regret is that I didn't watch it sooner.

This was a very well thought out story.

I'm a writer and I understand how difficult it can be flesh out so many characters but this story did it well, making almost all of them relevant in their own way.

All in all the show was really good. There were moments in the middle of the series were the story did drag a bit but that didn't affect my full experience much.

Now for a few criticisms; while the FL was acting her life out the ML could barely keep up. He didn't have much substance and he failed to build emotional value with the audience. I was also thoroughly disappointed with his relationship with his uncle till the very end. Not to hate but I think a different actor would have changed my opinion of his character drastically.

The show is still worth a watch.

This historical Chinese drama has everything well-balanced and stays clear of annoying devious and jealous third parties and petty squabbles. It's very inspirational. 3 generations of males in a family were exiled to the cold north for hard labour by the emperor and left behind 3 generations of their women and children to fend for themselves in the imperial city. There are very sad moments and very joyful moments too. The struggles these ladies go through in ancient China will enrage you and our strong and fearless female lead will inspire you. The series is fast paced and doesn't have a dull moment with a good balance of family drama, romance, palace intrigues and fighting scenes. The opening and closing songs are very catchy and good too. Highly recommend to watch.